Mastering SOAP Preparation for Medicine-Psychiatry Residency Success

Preparing for the Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) can feel overwhelming in any specialty, but it carries unique nuances for those targeting a med psych residency. Whether you’re applying solely to medicine psychiatry combined programs or considering them alongside categorical internal medicine and psychiatry, having a structured SOAP preparation plan can dramatically change your outcome in Match Week.

This guide walks you through what SOAP is, how to prepare for SOAP specifically as a Medicine-Psychiatry applicant, and how to protect your long-term goals in combined training—even if Match Week doesn’t initially go as planned.

---

Understanding SOAP in the Context of Medicine-Psychiatry

Before you can master SOAP preparation, you need a precise understanding of what is SOAP, how it works, and how it interacts with your specialty strategy.

What Is SOAP?

The Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) is the NRMP-managed process that helps unmatched or partially matched applicants obtain unfilled residency positions during Match Week. It is not a separate match but an organized, time-limited application and offer system.

Key SOAP basics:

• Who is eligible?
  • Applicants who are:
    • Registered for the Main Match and
    • Unmatched or partially matched by Monday of Match Week and
    • Not withdrawn from the Match and
    • Have no Match violation sanctions.
• What happens on Monday?
  • 10:00–11:00 AM ET: Applicants learn if they are:
    • Matched, Partially Matched, or Unmatched.
  • 11:00 AM ET: List of unfilled programs becomes available to SOAP-eligible applicants.
• Application limits:
  • Up to 45 total SOAP applications across all rounds.
• Rounds of offers:
  • Programs review applications and submit preference lists.
  • Multiple rounds (usually 4) of offers occur from Wednesday–Thursday of Match Week.
  • You may hold only one SOAP offer at a time; you can accept or reject it within a short time window (typically 2 hours).

Understanding this structure is central to SOAP preparation—you don’t have time during Match Week to figure out the rules.

Why SOAP Strategy Is Different for Medicine-Psychiatry

Medicine-Psychiatry combined programs are:

• Few in number compared to categorical internal medicine (IM) or psychiatry.
• Highly selective, with generally smaller class sizes.
• Sometimes under-recognized on the SOAP unfilled list—there may be zero med psych residency positions available some years.

Because of this, you must assume that:

• You may not be able to rely on SOAP to land a combined program.
• You need a dual strategy that protects:
  1. Your ability to practice broadly (e.g., IM or psychiatry categorical), and
  2. Your long-term goal of working at the medicine-psychiatry interface.

SOAP, for med psych–interested applicants, should be understood as:

• A potential safety valve if your combined programs go unfilled.
• A bridge to a categorical pathway that can still lead to med-psych style careers (e.g., consult-liaison psychiatry, integrated primary care-mental health, psychosomatic medicine roles, or combined fellowships down the line).

---

Pre-Match SOAP Preparation: Building a Med-Psych–Focused Safety Net

Effective SOAP preparation starts months before Match Week. You should build a structure that can be activated quickly if you find yourself SOAP-eligible.

1. Clarify Your Primary and Secondary Goals

Before applications even go in:

• Primary goal (ideal):
  • Match into a medicine psychiatry combined program (sometimes called med psych residency or internal medicine/psychiatry combined).
• Secondary goals (realistic backups):
  • Categorical Internal Medicine residency with strong:
    • Psychosomatic medicine,
    • Behavioral health integration, or
    • Consultation-liaison psychiatry exposure.
  • Categorical Psychiatry residency with:
    • Medical-psychiatric units,
    • Strong internal medicine integration,
    • CL psychiatry and primary care collaboration.

As you prepare for SOAP, you should be comfortable articulating to both IM and Psychiatry programs:

• Why you’re drawn to the medicine-psychiatry interface.
• How you will thrive in their categorical environment even if you had originally hoped for combined training.

2. Know the Medicine-Psychiatry Program Landscape

Because medicine psychiatry combined positions are limited, SOAP preparation means knowing exactly what exists:

• Identify all ACGME-accredited Medicine-Psychiatry programs.
• Note:
  • Number of positions per year.
  • How often they historically fill.
  • Whether they have:
    • An affiliated categorical IM program.
    • An affiliated categorical Psychiatry program.
    • A track record of allowing residents to transfer between combined and categorical paths (when feasible).

This matters for SOAP because:

• If a med psych residency doesn’t show up in SOAP but its categorical IM or Psych programs do, you might still:
  • Match into the categorical path and later transition (if the institution has a precedent or is open to it).
  • Build a training schedule loaded with consult-liaison and integrated care rotations to mimic med-psych depth.

---

3. Create Your SOAP Documents Early (and Tailor for Med-Psych)

You should have SOAP-ready materials finalized by late January or early February, well before Rank Order List (ROL) certification.

Core documents to prepare:

1. SOAP-Optimized CV

   • Highlight:
     • Combined internal medicine and psychiatry experiences (CL rotations, integrated clinics, addiction medicine, primary care mental health).
     • Research, QI projects, or leadership roles at the med-psych interface.
   • Structure clearly:
     • Education, exams, clinical experience, research, leadership, volunteerism.

2. Multiple Versions of Your Personal Statement (PS)

   • One for Medicine-Psychiatry combined (already used for main ERAS if applicable).
   • One for categorical Internal Medicine:
     • Emphasize your interest in complex comorbidity, behavioral health integration, and psychosocial determinants of health.
   • One for categorical Psychiatry:
     • Emphasize comfort with medical complexity and desire to work closely with other medical specialties.
   • Optional: A SOAP-specific PS focusing on:
     • Resilience,
     • Adaptability,
     • Commitment to patient care despite an unexpected match outcome.

3. Updated Letters of Recommendation (LoRs) (if possible)

   • Aim for at least:
     • One Internal Medicine faculty who can speak to your clinical reasoning and reliability.
     • One Psychiatry faculty highlighting your empathy, alliance-building, and diagnostic skill.
     • If available, a med-psych–aligned mentor (CL psychiatry attending, integrated care leader, or faculty who has dual training).

Having these ready allows you to rapidly assign the right PS and LoRs during SOAP to:

• Pure IM programs
• Pure Psychiatry programs
• Rarely, med psych programs that happen to be unfilled.

4. Anticipate Risk Scenarios (and Decision Trees)

Before Match Week, outline “if–then” scenarios:

• IF I am unmatched and there are no med psych residency positions in SOAP:
  • THEN:
    • Apply to IM and Psychiatry programs with strong med-psych alignment.
    • Prioritize geography and program culture where integrated models are common.
• IF I am unmatched and only IM positions are available in desirable locations:
  • THEN:
    • Apply broadly to IM.
    • Focus on programs with advanced CL, addiction medicine, or psychosomatic emphasis.
• IF I am partially matched (e.g., matched to an advanced position but need a prelim year):
  • THEN:
    • Prioritize prelim medicine positions in institutions that:
      • Have strong psychiatry departments.
      • Offer opportunities to round on med-psych consult services.

Write these decision trees down. In Match Week, stress impairs judgment; SOAP preparation is about pre-deciding your priorities while calm.

---

Strategic Use of SOAP During Match Week for Med-Psych Applicants

Once Match Week begins, timing and strategy become critical.

1. Monday: Rapid Situation Analysis

When you learn you are unmatched or partially matched, your first steps should be:

1. Meet with your dean’s office / advising team immediately.

   • Many schools have a SOAP residency task force to help students navigate offers, communication, and application selection.

2. Access the list of unfilled programs.

   • Filter by:
     • Medicine-Psychiatry
     • Internal Medicine (categorical and prelim)
     • Psychiatry (categorical and prelim, if any)
   • Note which programs:
     • Are in institutions you already know.
     • Are connected to med-psych friendly systems (academic centers, safety-net hospitals, VA systems, etc.).

3. Cross-reference with your pre-made program spreadsheet.

   • This is where early SOAP preparation pays off: you’ll already know which places are med-psych supportive.

2. Prioritizing Programs: A Med-Psych Lens

Because you can only send 45 total SOAP applications, your prioritization must be deliberate.

High-priority targets (for a med-psych interested applicant):

1. Any Medicine-Psychiatry combined programs listed (rare, but possible).
2. Categorical Internal Medicine programs that:
   • Have:
     • Strong psychiatry departments.
     • CL psychiatry, integrated primary care-mental health, or behavioral health tracks.
   • Serve:
     • Populations with high psychiatric and medical comorbidity (e.g., VA, safety-net hospitals).
3. Categorical Psychiatry programs that:
   • Emphasize:
     • Medical-psychiatric units,
     • CL psychiatry,
     • Collaborative care with primary care or hospitalist services.
4. Preliminary medicine or transitional year spots in institutions:
   • With strong psychiatry and med-psych–style services.
   • That might allow you to reapply strategically next cycle.

When in doubt, ask:
“Will this program help me build a career at the intersection of medicine and psychiatry—even if my path isn’t formally combined?”

3. Tailoring Your SOAP Communication and Materials

Even though SOAP restricts unsolicited phone/email contact with programs during certain windows, your written application and personal statements speak on your behalf.

For med-psych–aligned messaging:

• In applications to Internal Medicine:

  • Emphasize:
    • Skill with complex patients whose medical illness is influenced by mental health, substance use, or social determinants.
    • Interest in behavioral medicine, integrated care, chronic disease with psychiatric comorbidity.
  • Show that:
    • You understand the IM culture and are committed to general internal medicine training, not just “using IM as a path to get to psychiatry”.

• In applications to Psychiatry:

  • Emphasize:
    • Comfort with medical complexity (ICU exposure, cardiac, endocrine, neurology).
    • Ability to communicate effectively with medical teams.
  • Show that:
    • You want to be the psychiatrist who can confidently handle complex medically ill patients, not just those with isolated psychiatric disorders.

For any Medicine-Psychiatry combined position in SOAP:

• Be explicit:
  • Discuss your longitudinal commitment:
    • Rotations,
    • Research,
    • Advocacy,
    • Personal experiences at the interface.
  • Make clear you fully understand the demands of dual training (e.g., longer training, dual board preparation) and are committed.

---

4. Handling SOAP Offers: Decision-Making Under Time Pressure

When SOAP offers start arriving, you may have minutes to hours to decide. A structured decision framework is crucial.

A. Understand That an Accepted SOAP Position Is Binding

• Once you accept a SOAP offer:
  • You are legally bound to that program.
  • You are removed from consideration for all other positions in the Match, including later SOAP rounds.
• Rejection of an offer:
  • Frees you to receive other offers in later rounds but carries the risk of:
    • Ending SOAP without a position at all.

B. Evaluate Offers Using a Med-Psych–Oriented Hierarchy

If you receive multiple or sequential offers, ask:

1. Does this program align with my ultimate med-psych identity?

   • Even if not formally combined, can I:
     • Train heavily in CL psychiatry, addiction, and integrated care?
     • Work with complex medically ill psychiatric patients?

2. Program quality, support, and culture

   • Does the program have:
     • Solid reputation and educational structure?
     • Good mentorship?
     • Reasonable workload and attention to wellness?

3. Geography and personal factors

   • Will I have the support (family, financial, mental health resources) to perform well for 3–4 years?

4. Future flexibility

   • Could I:
     • Transition from categorical IM to Psych (or vice versa) later in the same institution?
     • Pursue fellowships to approximate med-psych training (e.g., CL psychiatry after psych, addiction medicine, hospital medicine with behavioral health focus)?

You don’t have to share your entire thought process with the program—but you do need clarity for yourself.

---

If You Don’t Match Through SOAP: Preserving Your Med-Psych Goals

Despite careful SOAP preparation, some applicants may end Match Week without a position. This is devastating emotionally, but it is not the end of your med-psych career trajectory.

1. Immediate Next Steps

• Meet with your dean/advisor for a frank debrief:
  • Identify whether the main barriers were:
    • Exam scores?
    • Number/strength of letters?
    • Limited clinical performance or red flags?
    • Application strategy (too narrow, late, poorly tailored)?
• Clarify your narrative:
  • Why did you go unmatched?
  • What will you do in the coming year to address those gaps?

2. Productive Gap Year Options for Future Med-Psych Applicants

If you are reapplying next cycle, structure the year to strengthen your med-psych profile:

• Clinical roles (varies by region and licensing):

  • Research assistant or clinical coordinator in:
    • CL psychiatry,
    • Integrated care projects,
    • Primary care–mental health initiatives.
  • Work in inpatient psychiatry or medical wards as a clinical assistant (where allowed).

• Research/QI:

  • Projects at the intersection of:
    • Chronic illness and depression,
    • Substance use and liver/cardiac disease,
    • Somatic symptom disorders,
    • High-utilizer patients with comorbid conditions.

• Education and Certifications:

  • Additional certifications relevant to med-psych (motivational interviewing, addiction treatment trainings, trauma-informed care, etc.).

Craft a plan that clearly shows future programs:

“I used this year strategically to grow into exactly the kind of resident who can excel in a medicine-psychiatry combined program or a med-psych–aligned categorical program.”

3. Reframing Your Career Path

Remember:

• Many leaders in psychosomatic medicine, CL psychiatry, and integrated primary care did not complete formal med psych residency; instead, they:
  • Trained in Internal Medicine or Psychiatry.
  • Sought extra rotations, mentorship, and fellowships.
• A categorical pathway with smart choices can absolutely lead to a career that is functionally “med-psych” in practice.

Your SOAP preparation—and how you respond if SOAP does not yield a spot—should always center this long-view perspective.

---

Practical Tips and Common Pitfalls in SOAP Preparation for Med-Psych

Practical Tips

1. Start SOAP Preparation Early

   • By December–January:
     • Draft SOAP-tailored personal statements.
     • Update CV.
     • Identify med-psych–aligned IM and Psych programs you’d consider in SOAP.

2. Leverage Mentors with Combined or CL Backgrounds

   • Ask:
     • How they would rank possible SOAP outcomes if they were in your shoes.
     • Which types of environments best prepare you for med-psych style careers.

3. Practice Explaining Your Med-Psych Interest in Two Ways

   • To Internal Medicine audiences:
     • “I’m drawn to medically complex patients whose outcomes hinge on behavioral and psychiatric factors.”
   • To Psychiatry audiences:
     • “I want to care for psychiatrically ill patients with significant medical comorbidities, and I’m comfortable on medical floors and ICUs.”

4. Understand the Rules of Communication in SOAP

   • Some periods prohibit applicant-initiated contact with programs.
   • Use official NRMP and ERAS resources to ensure:
     • You don’t violate policies.
     • Your school’s advisors coordinate any allowed communication strategically.

5. Take Care of Your Mental Health During Match Week

   • For med-psych–oriented applicants, the irony is clear:
     You want to work at the mental health–medical interface while your own mental health is under acute strain.
   • Establish:
     • Supportive peers, mentors, or mental health professionals to talk to.
     • Boundaries around social media use during Match Week.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

• Putting all hope on SOAP for a Medicine-Psychiatry combined spot
  • Many years, there are no unfilled med-psych residency positions.
• Failing to prepare alternate personal statements
  • Programs can tell when a PS is “not really for them”.
• Undervaluing categorical IM or Psychiatry as “backup”
  • Programs want applicants who genuinely appreciate their training, not those who treat them as second-class options.
• Overusing SOAP applications on low-yield or geographically unacceptable programs
  • Be broad but intentional; 45 is a real limit.
• Making rash decisions on offers without reflecting on long-term fit
  • This is where a pre-planned hierarchy and mentor guidance are invaluable.

---

FAQs: SOAP Preparation for Medicine-Psychiatry Applicants

1. Can I realistically expect to find a Medicine-Psychiatry combined residency spot through SOAP?
In many years, no med psych residency programs appear on the SOAP list because these programs are few and often fully fill in the Main Match. You should not rely on SOAP as your primary route to a combined program. Instead, use SOAP to secure a categorical position (IM or Psychiatry) that still supports your med-psych interests.

---

2. How should I split my 45 SOAP applications between Internal Medicine and Psychiatry?
There’s no single correct formula. Consider:

• Your original application pattern (more IM vs more Psych).
• Where your clinical performance and letters are strongest.
• The actual availability of positions on the SOAP list.

A common strategy is to apply to a mix of IM and Psychiatry programs that show strong med-psych alignment, with a slight tilt toward the specialty in which you are stronger or more comfortable. Your advisor or dean can help you make a data-driven split based on your individual profile.

---

3. If I SOAP into a categorical Internal Medicine or Psychiatry program, can I still later become a “med-psych” specialist?
Yes. Many physicians practicing in consult-liaison psychiatry, psychosomatic medicine, integrated primary care, and medical-psychiatric units trained in categorical IM or Psychiatry. You can shape your training through:

• Electives and rotations caring for patients with complex comorbidities.
• Research and QI at the med-psych interface.
• Fellowships (e.g., CL psychiatry after psychiatry residency, addiction medicine, or hospital medicine with behavioral focus).

SOAP preparation should keep this long-term flexibility in mind.

---

4. What is SOAP preparation I should do if I feel confident I will match but want a safety plan?
Even if you expect to match, smart SOAP preparation includes:

• Keeping an updated CV and at least one alternate personal statement (IM- or Psych-focused).
• Maintaining open communication with mentors about backup plans.
• Having a spreadsheet of med-psych–friendly IM and Psychiatry programs you would consider in a worst-case scenario.
• Familiarizing yourself with the logistics of what is SOAP, including timelines and communication rules, so you’re not learning under duress.

Doing this does not jinx your chances; it simply protects your career trajectory if the unexpected happens.

---

Thoughtful SOAP preparation allows Medicine-Psychiatry–interested applicants to navigate Match Week with structure rather than panic. Whether you ultimately land in a combined med psych residency, categorical Internal Medicine, or categorical Psychiatry, the right strategy ensures you stay on course toward a career at the powerful intersection of medicine and mental health.