SOAP Preparation in Ophthalmology: A Complete Guide for Residents

Understanding SOAP in the Context of Ophthalmology

The Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) can feel especially high‑stakes for students aiming for ophthalmology residency. Ophthalmology is one of the most competitive specialties; most applicants invest years in research, away rotations, and networking. When the National Resident Matching Program (NRMP) “Did I Match?” notification shows that you are unmatched or partially matched, the transition from the ophtho match mindset to SOAP residency strategy has to be fast, organized, and emotionally steady.

Before you plan your SOAP preparation, you must clearly understand what is SOAP:

• What is SOAP?
  SOAP is a structured, time‑limited process run by NRMP during Match Week that allows unmatched or partially matched applicants to apply to and receive offers from unfilled residency programs in NRMP-participating specialties.

• Who participates?

  • Unmatched applicants (no PGY‑1 position)
  • Partially matched applicants (e.g., matched to an advanced position but not a prelim year, or vice versa)
  • Programs with unfilled positions after the main Match algorithm

• Key differences from the regular Match:

  • No rank order list or algorithm for this part; offers are direct from programs.
  • Very compressed timeline (days, not months).
  • Communication rules are stricter and more proscriptive.
  • Applications are limited in number and go only to unfilled programs.

For ophthalmology specifically, there are two nuances:

1. Ophthalmology has its own early match (SF Match) for the majority of programs, separate from NRMP. If you are unmatched via SF Match, you may still go through NRMP Match for a transitional year, preliminary year, or another specialty.
2. Occasional NRMP‑participating ophtho programs (rare) or combined tracks may appear, but most of your SOAP strategy will center on:
   • Securing a PGY‑1 year (preliminary medicine, surgery, or transitional year).
   • Considering alternate specialties if you are open to pivoting.

Your SOAP preparation in ophthalmology, therefore, has two parallel goals:

1. Immediate goal (this Match cycle): Secure an accredited PGY‑1 spot and continue clinical training without a gap.
2. Strategic goal (next ophtho match cycle): Strengthen your application so that a PGY‑1 year becomes a launching pad into ophthalmology, not a detour away from it.

The rest of this guide will walk through how to plan and execute SOAP preparation with that dual lens in mind.

---

Pre‑SOAP Preparation: What to Do Before Match Week

The most effective SOAP strategy starts months before you ever find out whether you matched. This is especially true for ophthalmology residency applicants who already know they are in a high‑risk, competitive environment.

1. Clarify Your Priorities and Backup Plans Early

Before rank lists are due—for both SF Match (ophtho) and NRMP (PGY‑1 or other specialties)—sit down and answer:

• If I don’t match in ophthalmology:
  • Am I willing to pursue a different specialty permanently (e.g., internal medicine, neurology, radiology, anesthesiology)?
  • Or is my primary goal to reapply to ophthalmology next year?
• If my main goal is to reapply to ophtho:
  • Do I prefer a transitional year, prelim medicine, or prelim surgery?
  • Am I geographically flexible enough to accept any location?
• How much does a gap year vs. a straight-through PGY‑1 matter to me financially and personally?

This clarity will help you make rapid decisions during SOAP—when your inbox is flooded, you’re exhausted, and the clock is ticking.

2. Optimize Your ERAS for SOAP in Advance

Although SOAP residency applications use the same ERAS platform, the narrative and emphasis you put forth may differ from your main application. You can’t fully rewrite everything during SOAP week; your best option is to:

• Have multiple versions of your personal statement ready, such as:

  • Ophthalmology-focused (used already for SF Match).
  • “Bridge” statement: explains your ophthalmology interest but frames your enthusiasm and readiness for a strong PGY‑1 year in medicine, surgery, or transitional year.
  • Alternate specialty statement (if you are truly open to pivoting).

• Prepare adaptable experience descriptions:

  • Research: emphasize clinical reasoning, data analysis, perseverance, and teamwork.
  • Clinical rotations: highlight broad internal medicine or surgical exposure, not only ophthalmology clinics and ORs.
  • Teaching/leadership: outline how these skills translate to being a strong intern.

• Keep documents updated and accessible:

  • CV and ERAS entries current.
  • USMLE/COMLEX transcripts properly released.
  • MSPE and transcripts verified.

Doing this before Match Week gives you bandwidth to focus on strategy rather than basic paperwork.

3. Line Up Advisors and References

SOAP is fast. You will need quick, honest feedback about which programs to target and how to respond to evolving options. Build your support network in advance:

• Ophthalmology mentors (faculty, program directors, research supervisors):

  • Discuss realistic reapplicant strategies now.
  • Ask if they’d be willing to advise you rapidly during Match Week.
  • Explore possibilities for future ophtho research or a position in their department if you don’t match.

• Core clinical faculty (medicine, surgery, transitional year leadership):

  • Ask if they are willing to update or tailor letters of recommendation if needed.
  • Request feedback on your competitiveness for prelim or TY programs.

• Deans’ office / career advisors:

  • Many schools have specific SOAP playbooks and dedicated staff during Match Week.
  • Clarify who your point person will be and how to reach them rapidly.

4. Understand SOAP Rules, Timelines, and Technical Logistics

You must know the official NRMP SOAP schedule (it slightly changes year to year). Learn exactly:

• When you will find out if you matched.
• When the List of Unfilled Programs is released.
• When ERAS opens for SOAP applications.
• When the four SOAP offer rounds occur.

Also, understand communication rules:

• You may not contact programs on the unfilled list before they contact you (rules change slightly year to year—verify with NRMP).
• Programs may contact you via ERAS, phone, or video, but must follow NRMP policies.
• You must respond to offers within the specific time window, and accepting an offer is a binding commitment.

Finally, test your tech:

• Stable internet, updated browser, NRMP and ERAS logins working.
• Quiet space and backup device for virtual interviews.

---

Strategic SOAP Preparation for Ophthalmology Applicants

On SOAP Monday, once you learn you are unmatched or partially matched, emotions surge—but you must quickly pivot to strategy. Here’s how to think about your options as an ophthalmology-focused applicant.

1. Define Your Primary SOAP Objective

You typically have three realistic pathways as an unmatched ophtho applicant:

1. Secure a PGY‑1 year (prelim/TY) and reapply to ophthalmology
   Best for those who:

   • Remain strongly committed to ophtho.
   • Have at least moderately competitive metrics (e.g., passing boards, some research).
   • Are fully willing to move anywhere for a PGY‑1 year.

2. Secure a categorical spot in another specialty and consider ophtho later (or move on)
   Best for those who:

   • Are open to an alternative long‑term specialty.
   • Value stability and geographic preference over the uncertainty of reapplying.
   • May have metrics that make re‑entry to ophtho relatively unlikely.

3. Consider returning as a reapplicant without a residency start (research, MPH, fellowships, etc.)
   Best for those who:

   • Have very strong research opportunities lined up (e.g., prominent ophtho lab).
   • Need to significantly repair academic issues (board failures, limited clinical performance).
   • Have clear mentorship validating that a non‑clinical gap year could substantially improve competitiveness.

During SOAP week, option #1 is the most common and practical focus: use SOAP to land a strong PGY‑1 year that positions you well for a future ophtho application.

2. Target Programs That Align With Ophthalmology Goals

When the list of unfilled programs appears, filter it with your ophtho lens:

• Prioritize preliminary medicine, preliminary surgery, and transitional year programs that:

  • Are affiliated with medical centers that have an ophthalmology department.
  • Are in cities with multiple ophtho training programs (increases networking options).
  • Are known to have former interns who successfully matched into ophtho.

• Look at:

  • Program website for current and past residents’ fellowship or match outcomes.
  • Whether intern schedules allow electives in ophthalmology, neurology, or ENT.
  • Culture and workload—will you realistically have time for ophtho research or networking?

A strong, supportive prelim or TY year can significantly strengthen your ophtho application by giving you:

• Fresh, clinically focused letters (from non-ophtho attendings who can vouch for your work ethic and patient care).
• Continued clinical currency (no gaps).
• Opportunities for ophtho electives, call experience, and scholarly work.

3. Optimize Your ERAS for SOAP Positions

You will typically have a maximum number of applications (e.g., 45) you can send during SOAP. Use them wisely:

• Group your target programs:

  • High‑priority prelim/TY programs with strong ophtho adjacency.
  • Backup prelim/TY programs where you’d still be comfortable training.
  • Categorical backup specialties (if you’ve decided this is a viable route).

• Tailor documents:

  • Use your “bridge” personal statement for prelim/TY programs:
    • Explain your strong interest in becoming an excellent intern.
    • Mention that you are pursuing ophthalmology but emphasize your dedication to patient care and broad learning.
    • Make clear that you intend to contribute fully even if your long‑term goal is ophtho—programs worry about interns with “one foot out the door.”
  • For categorical backup specialties, use a genuine specialty‑specific statement. Do not submit a visibly ophtho‑centric essay to, say, internal medicine or pediatrics.

• Highlight transferable skills:

  • Ophthalmology research → collaboration, attention to detail, data literacy.
  • Ophtho rotations → procedure comfort, visual diagnostic skills, precise documentation.
  • Leadership roles → reliability, communication, and resilience.

4. Prepare for SOAP Interviews With a Focused Narrative

Programs may conduct short, intense interviews during SOAP—sometimes only 10–15 minutes. You must be ready to answer:

1. “Why are you applying to our program during SOAP?”
   Example framing for a prelim medicine spot:

   “I applied primarily in ophthalmology because I am deeply interested in visual neuroscience and microsurgery. However, being a strong, well-rounded intern is foundational for any future path. Your preliminary medicine program offers broad clinical exposure, high teaching intensity, and access to subspecialties—including ophthalmology. I want to spend my intern year in a program that will challenge me clinically, allow me to grow as a physician, and support residents pursuing various long-term goals. I’m committed to giving my best to every patient and team, regardless of where I ultimately specialize.”

2. “Are you going to reapply to ophthalmology?”
   Answer honestly, but address program concerns:

   • Acknowledge that you are interested in reapplying.
   • Emphasize that your day‑to‑day commitment during the intern year will not be compromised.
   • Highlight that success in their program is your first priority.

3. “Why didn’t you match?”
   Be concise and non‑defensive:

   • Recognize ophthalmology’s competitiveness.
   • Identify one or two realistic contributing factors (e.g., limited research, late decision to pursue ophtho, Step score below average).
   • Emphasize what you have learned and how you intend to grow.

   Example:

   “Ophthalmology is extremely competitive, and I decided on the specialty later in medical school, so my dedicated research time and letters were limited compared to many applicants. I received encouraging feedback from interviews but ultimately did not match. I’ve reflected a lot on this and am focused now on: 1) building a very strong clinical foundation as an intern, and 2) continuing to seek mentorship to improve as a future applicant and as a physician.”

---

Executing SOAP Week: Step‑by‑Step

Once SOAP begins, the pace accelerates. Here’s a structured approach to navigate the week effectively.

1. Monday: Process, Regroup, and Plan

• Morning: Learn your match status from NRMP. If unmatched:

  • Take a brief, intentional pause—walk, talk to a trusted friend, or step outside.
  • Avoid making big decisions from a heightened emotional state.

• Midday: Meet (virtually or in person) with:

  • Dean/career advisor.
  • Ophthalmology mentor, if available.
  • Anyone who can help you calibrate expectations realistically.

• Afternoon: Review:

  • The list of unfilled programs.
  • Your pre‑SOAP priority rankings.
  • Any new data (e.g., which programs unexpectedly have spots).

Then finalize where you will send your first wave of SOAP applications.

2. Tuesday: Application Submission and Early Communications

• Submit your SOAP applications as soon as ERAS opens and you are confident in your list.
• Monitor ERAS and email closely:
  • Respond promptly and professionally to any messages.
  • If programs request a brief written response or statement, keep it clear and consistent with your narrative.
• Prepare for same‑day or next‑day interviews:
  • Have a 30‑second “elevator pitch” ready:
    • Who you are.
    • Your clinical strengths.
    • Your near‑term goals for the intern year.

3. Wednesday–Thursday: Interview and Offer Rounds

During the offer rounds:

• Keep your phone charged and your notifications on.
• Understand that:
  • Once you accept an offer, the process ends for you.
  • Declining an offer is final—you will not get that slot back.
• Before each round:
  • Rank‑order the programs where you have interviewed or have strong interest.
  • Discuss with mentors or loved ones if you are stuck between “better ophtho proximity” and “better categorical stability.”

If you do not receive offers in the early rounds:

• Stay engaged—later rounds can still yield strong opportunities.
• Continue following up appropriately with programs that have shown interest but have not yet made decisions.

4. If You Exit SOAP Without an Offer

If you reach the end of SOAP without a position:

• Immediately set up meetings with:
  • Your dean’s office.
  • Ophthalmology mentors.
  • Potential research supervisors.

Plan concrete next steps:

• Research fellowship (particularly in ophthalmology).
• Post‑graduate clinical roles (e.g., research coordinator, clinical instructor jobs where permissible).
• Additional degrees (e.g., MPH, MS in clinical investigation)—only if clearly strategic and affordable.

This is also the time to systematically examine:

• Exam performance (failed or low‑pass attempts).
• Red flags (leaves of absence, professionalism issues).
• How to rehabilitate your application realistically for either another ophtho cycle or an alternative specialty.

---

Long‑Term Strategy: Using SOAP Outcomes to Strengthen a Future Ophtho Application

Your performance during SOAP and the position you secure (or do not secure) will shape your path back to ophthalmology. If your goal remains an ophthalmology residency, think one year ahead from day one of your new role.

1. If You Matched to a Prelim or TY Spot

Use this year to become the kind of intern ophtho programs want to recruit:

• Clinical excellence:

  • Be reliable, punctual, and prepared daily.
  • Take ownership of patients; anticipate next steps.
  • Seek feedback proactively and act on it.

• Relationships and letters:

  • Identify attendings who appreciate your work ethic early.
  • Ask for detailed letters that highlight specifics:
    • Example: leadership on night float, meticulous care of complex patients, teaching juniors.

• Ophthalmology continued engagement:

  • Arrange ophtho electives or clinic time if possible.
  • Get involved in at least one active research or quality improvement project with ophthalmology faculty.
  • Attend departmental conferences or grand rounds when feasible.

• Application timeline and logistics:

  • Plan to complete any additional exams (e.g., Step 3) early if this will strengthen your reapplication.
  • Coordinate with your program director:
    • Be transparent about your reapplication plans.
    • Request schedule flexibility around interview season if allowed.
  • Update your personal statement to reflect:
    • What you learned from not matching.
    • How your intern year has deepened your commitment to patient care and ophthalmology.

2. If You Pivot to a Categorical Alternate Specialty

If, during SOAP, you choose a categorical spot outside ophthalmology:

• Give yourself permission to truly explore and invest in that path.
• Many physicians discover a deep sense of fulfillment in their SOAP‑matched specialty.
• If, after dedicated time, you still wish to re‑enter ophthalmology:
  • Seek honest mentorship—switching into ophthalmology from another categorical specialty is uncommon but not impossible.
  • Focus on being an outstanding resident first; programs rarely take lateral transfers from residents struggling in their current specialty.

3. If You Do Not Secure Any Position

Rebuilding is absolutely possible but must be deliberate and structured:

• Obtain precise feedback on your application:

  • Ask ophtho and non‑ophtho faculty to review your file comprehensively.
  • Identify whether the barrier was:
    • Academics (scores, failures).
    • Limited clinical performance.
    • Weak letters.
    • Insufficient research or late engagement with the field.

• Structure your “gap” year:

  • Prioritize roles that:
    • Keep you clinically adjacent (ophthalmic technician, clinical research coordinator).
    • Provide strong, name‑recognizable mentorship.
    • Offer opportunities to produce scholarly work (posters, manuscripts).
  • Maintain some degree of financial and mental sustainability—burnout during a gap year will harm your long-term trajectory.

• Document your growth:

  • Keep a log of clinical experiences, research tasks, teaching roles, and feedback.
  • Use this material for future personal statements and interviews to demonstrate reflection and maturity.

---

Practical Tips and Common Pitfalls for Ophtho SOAP Applicants

Practical Tips

• Create a SOAP “command document” before Match Week:

  • Emergency contacts (mentors, dean).
  • Logins and schedule.
  • Pre‑ranked program types (e.g., “Any prelim/TY in cities with ophtho program”).
  • Draft email templates for rapid responses.

• Rehearse your story out loud:

  • Practice explaining your unmatched status, career goals, and why you’re applying to each program type.
  • Use simple, non‑defensive language.

• Stay off social media during peak emotions:

  • Comparing yourself to peers can impair clear decision‑making.
  • If needed, delete apps temporarily or ask a friend to change your password for the week.

Common Pitfalls

• Being rigid about geography:

  • Ophthalmology is too competitive to combine with narrow location preferences during SOAP.
  • If your primary goal is to reapply to ophtho, prioritize clinical quality and flexibility over city/state.

• Sending a generic, ophtho‑centric personal statement to all SOAP programs:

  • This may signal to prelim/TY or alternate specialty programs that you are not truly committed to being an excellent intern or categorical resident.

• Over‑ or under‑disclosing reapplication plans:

  • Programs expect honesty but also want reassurance of your investment in their team.
  • Find a balanced, sincere answer.

• Waiting passively for offers:

  • Within NRMP rules, you can and should respond promptly to communication, express interest appropriately, and remain engaged.

---

FAQ: SOAP Preparation in Ophthalmology

1. If I’m committed to ophthalmology, should I only apply to prelim/TY programs during SOAP?
Not necessarily. If a categorical program in another specialty appeals to you as a genuine long‑term option, it’s reasonable to include it. For many applicants, however, a strong prelim or transitional year is the best bridge back to the ophtho match. The key is clarity: don’t apply to categorical programs you’d be unhappy to complete if you never enter ophthalmology.

---

2. How do I explain not matching ophthalmology during SOAP interviews without sounding negative?
Briefly acknowledge ophthalmology’s competitiveness, identify one or two realistic contributing factors (e.g., later decision to pursue ophthalmology, limited research), and then pivot quickly to what you’ve learned and how eager you are to grow as an intern. Avoid blaming programs, mentors, or “the system.” Emphasize your resilience, insight, and commitment to patient care.

---

3. Can a strong prelim medicine or surgery year realistically help me match ophthalmology later?
Yes. Many successful ophthalmology residents first completed prelim or transitional years. Strong evaluations, enthusiastic letters from intern‑year attendings, additional clinical maturity, and opportunities to maintain ophtho involvement can significantly enhance your application. This pathway is especially powerful if you simultaneously improve other areas (research, Step 3, networking).

---

4. What is the most important part of SOAP preparation for an ophtho applicant?
The single most important element is advance planning: clarifying your goals, preparing tailored personal statements, understanding SOAP rules and timelines, and lining up mentors who can advise you rapidly. When SOAP starts, it moves too quickly to build a strategy from scratch. Thoughtful preparation allows you to act decisively and increase your chances of securing a position that keeps you moving toward an ophthalmology residency.