Mastering SOAP Preparation for PM&R Residency: Your Comprehensive Guide

Preparing for the Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) is stressful in any specialty, but it has some unique nuances in Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation (PM&R). Whether you’re strongly targeting a PM&R residency, worried about the physiatry match, or simply being realistic and preparing a backup plan, understanding SOAP—and how to use it strategically—can dramatically change your outcome.

This guide walks you through SOAP preparation specifically for PM&R: what to expect, how to get ready before Match Week, and how to act decisively during SOAP to maximize your chances of securing a strong position.

---

Understanding SOAP in the Context of PM&R

SOAP (Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program) is the structured process for unmatched or partially matched applicants to obtain unfilled residency positions during Match Week. It’s not a “second-class” pathway; many excellent residents and future physiatrists enter training via SOAP.

What is SOAP?

In practical terms, SOAP is:

• A time-limited, highly structured process that happens during Match Week.
• Managed entirely through the NRMP and ERAS systems.
• Designed for applicants who:
  • Are eligible for the Main Residency Match,
  • Register with NRMP,
  • Do not fully match on Monday of Match Week.

During SOAP:

• You receive a list of unfilled programs.
• You can apply to a limited number of programs (up to 45 in recent years) via ERAS.
• Programs review your application and may invite you for short, focused interviews (often virtual).
• Offers are made to applicants in several SOAP offer rounds (usually four rounds across Wednesday–Thursday).
• If you accept an offer, you are legally bound to that program (NRMP binding agreement).

Why SOAP Matters for PM&R

PM&R has become more competitive over the past decade. Recent cycles show:

• Growing interest in lifestyle-friendly, multidisciplinary fields.
• Increased awareness of physiatry among medical students.
• Strong applicant pools including MDs, DOs, and IMGs.

As competitiveness rises:

• Not all strong applicants match on Monday—especially those with:
  • Limited PM&R audition rotations or letters,
  • Late specialty decision,
  • Geographic constraints,
  • USMLE/COMLEX challenges.
• SOAP becomes a critical safety net for those applicants.

While PM&R often fills most positions in the Main Match, a small number of PM&R residency slots do sometimes remain unfilled each year, and others may become available through SOAP due to last-minute dynamics. In addition, SOAP can help you secure:

• Preliminary year positions (IM, surgery, transitional) that set you up to reapply to PM&R.
• Categorical positions in other specialties if you’re considering an alternative path.

Understanding this landscape helps you approach SOAP preparation realistically: hope to match, but prepare thoroughly in case you don’t.

---

Pre–Match Week SOAP Preparation: What To Do Now

SOAP is fast and emotionally intense. The worst time to start learning what is SOAP and how it works is Monday of Match Week when you receive an “unmatched” or “partially matched” notification. Thoughtful SOAP preparation before Match Week dramatically reduces panic and improves your performance under pressure.

1. Clarify Your PM&R Career Goals Now

Before you think about SOAP strategy, be clear on your priorities:

Ask yourself:

• Is PM&R your top and only long-term goal?
• Would you be open to:
  • A prelim or transitional year now, then reapplying to PM&R?
  • Training in a related specialty (e.g., neurology, internal medicine, family medicine) and later doing a fellowship in pain, sports, or rehab-related areas?
  • Relocating to less preferred geographic areas for training?
• How flexible are you regarding:
  • Program size (small vs. large)
  • Academic vs. community
  • Patient population (VA, county, rehab hospital, private)

Write these down. This clarity will guide your SOAP choices when time is limited.

2. Review Your Application Through a SOAP Lens

Look at your PM&R residency application as if you were a PD reviewing it during SOAP.

Ask:

• Does my personal statement clearly explain why PM&R?
• Is there any content that could raise concern for PDs in a compressed review?
• Are my USMLE/COMLEX scores or attempts clearly presented?
• Do I have at least:
  • One strong PM&R letter (ideally from a physiatrist),
  • Plus other solid clinical letters?

Identify weaknesses and consider how you will address them in interviews:

• Low scores → emphasize clinical performance, improvement, feedback you acted on.
• Limited PM&R exposure → highlight key experiences, self-learning, and clear understanding of the field.
• Gaps/Leaves → prepare a concise, honest, growth-focused explanation.

3. Draft SOAP-Specific Personal Statement Variants

During SOAP, you may apply to:

• PM&R categorical programs
• Preliminary or transitional year programs
• Possibly backup specialties

You do not want to be writing new personal statements from scratch during Match Week. Prepare:

1. PM&R-focused personal statement (SOAP version)

   • Slightly shorter and more direct than your original.
   • Emphasize:
     • Your sustained interest in physiatry,
     • Hands-on rehab experiences,
     • Interdisciplinary teamwork,
     • Adaptability and resilience (without sounding desperate).
   • Remove any language that implies you would only accept a “top-tier” academic program.

2. Preliminary/Transitional year personal statement

   • Highlight:
     • Strong work ethic,
     • Reliability,
     • Breadth of clinical interest,
     • Commitment to delivering excellent patient care regardless of final specialty.
   • You can mention PM&R as your long-term interest, but:
     • Focus on how you will add value to the prelim year team.
     • Avoid giving the impression you’re “half-committed” to the year.

3. Backup specialty statement (if applicable)

   • If there’s a realistic secondary specialty you’d accept categorically via SOAP (e.g., FM, IM, neurology), create a focused statement for that specialty.

Keep all versions ready as editable files so you can quickly tailor them to specific programs.

---

4. Update Your CV and ERAS Content

Most of your ERAS application is already fixed, but ensure:

• All experiences are:
  • Accurate and up to date,
  • Well described with clear impact/roles,
  • Free of typos and inconsistencies.
• Any recent activities (sub-internships, research submitted, new leadership roles) are included.
• Your photo is professional and appropriate.

Even though you can’t substantially rewrite ERAS during SOAP, PDs will scrutinize what is there, often in only a few minutes.

5. Line Up Advisors and Support

During SOAP, you’ll need fast, honest advice:

• Identify:
  • A PM&R mentor (faculty or senior resident),
  • An advising dean or career counselor,
  • Possibly a trusted recent graduate who went through SOAP or the physiatry match.
• Ask if they are willing to:
  • Be available during Match Week,
  • Quickly review your target list,
  • Conduct mock interviews (even brief) focusing on unexpected questions.

Also:

• Clarify your school’s SOAP procedures:
  • Where will you physically be during SOAP?
  • Who submits your MSPE or updated dean’s letter if requested?
  • How does your school support contacting programs (if appropriate)?

6. Logistical and Emotional Preparation

SOAP is a sprint under pressure. Prepare:

• A quiet workspace with stable internet, camera, microphone, and background suitable for video interviews.
• Professional interview attire ready to go (no last-minute scrambling).
• A master spreadsheet template for:
  • Program name
  • Specialty (PM&R vs prelim vs other)
  • Geographic location
  • Program type (academic/community/VA)
  • Contact info
  • Application status
  • Interview time/notes
  • Impression and rank preference

Emotionally:

• Accept that preparing for SOAP does not mean you won’t match; it simply means you’re being a mature, responsible adult.
• Talk with supportive peers or family about the possibility of SOAP now, so the shock is less intense if it happens.

---

Match Week: Step-by-Step SOAP Strategy for PM&R Applicants

When Monday of Match Week arrives, you’ll know whether you matched, partially matched, or did not match. For PM&R, partial matches often involve:

• Matching a prelim year but not the advanced PM&R position,
• Or the reverse (less common in PM&R).

Monday Morning: Interpreting Your Status

You’ll see one of these outcomes:

1. Fully Matched (categorical or advanced + prelim)

   • SOAP does not apply to you. Focus on celebrating and preparing for residency.

2. Partially Matched

   • For PM&R, this might mean:
     • Matched to a PM&R advanced spot but no prelim year,
     • Or matched to a prelim year but no PM&R advanced spot.
   • You are still SOAP-eligible and should use SOAP to fill your missing position (typically prelim/transitional).

3. Unmatched

   • You are SOAP-eligible if you:
     • Registered for NRMP,
     • Are eligible for the Match,
     • Did not withdraw and did not violate rules.
   • This is where your SOAP preparation becomes critical.

Accessing the List of Unfilled Programs

Later on Monday, SOAP-eligible applicants receive access to the List of Unfilled Programs in NRMP. This list updates as positions fill or change.

For PM&R-focused applicants:

• Filter for:
  • Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation programs (categorical or advanced).
  • Preliminary/TY positions in IM, surgery, or transitional programs.
  • Select backup specialties (if you’ve decided in advance you’d accept them).

Don’t panic if PM&R positions are few or none; lists may change slightly, and your prelim/TY strategy can still set you up to reapply successfully.

Building Your Application Strategy (Up to 45 Programs)

You can apply to a maximum number of programs (recently 45) across all specialties during SOAP. How you distribute these is strategic.

For a PM&R-focused SOAP plan, consider:

1. If PM&R positions are available:

   • Apply to all PM&R programs you’d realistically attend, regardless of geography or prestige.
   • Then fill remaining application spots with:
     • Prelim IM / TY programs in a range of locations and competitiveness.
     • Possibly one backup categorical specialty if you’ve decided you’d accept it.

2. If there are no PM&R positions:

   • Focus on:
     • A diversified mix of prelim IM, prelim surgery, and TY programs, especially those in:
       • Regions you’d be willing to reapply in,
       • Institutions with PM&R departments or affiliated rehab hospitals (can help later).
   • Optionally add:
     • Categorical backup specialty programs (FM, IM, neurology) if that aligns with your long-term flexibility.

Your goal in SOAP, if PM&R positions are scarce, is to secure a strong clinical year that:

• Allows you to excel,
• Keeps you close to PM&R services,
• Provides new letters and experiences for a future physiatry match.

---

Communicating with Programs During SOAP

During SOAP, unsolicited direct communication rules are strict. Generally:

• You cannot cold-call or cold-email programs to ask for positions or lobby for interviews.
• Programs reach out to you if interested, usually via:
  • ERAS messaging,
  • E-mail,
  • Phone, or
  • Video platform invitations.

However, you can:

• Promptly respond to any outreach.
• Confirm availability.
• Request clarification on logistics.

Be familiar with the current year’s NRMP and ERAS SOAP communication rules, as they update periodically.

---

Excelling in SOAP Interviews: PM&R-Focused Approach

SOAP interviews are different from traditional residency interviews: they are shorter, more focused, and more time-pressured—for both you and the program.

Common SOAP Interview Formats

• 5–20-minute virtual interviews (Zoom, Teams, phone).
• Often with:
  • PD or APD,
  • Chief resident,
  • Sometimes a faculty member or coordinator.

You must be able to convey your value quickly and clearly.

Core Themes PM&R Programs Look For During SOAP

In PM&R residency SOAP interviews, programs often focus on:

1. Clarity of interest in PM&R

   • Do you understand what physiatrists do?
   • Have you worked with rehab teams?
   • Can you articulate why PM&R over other specialties?

2. Resilience and professionalism

   • How have you handled academic or personal setbacks?
   • How are you processing not matching?

3. Teamwork and communication

   • Can you collaborate with PT/OT, SLP, nursing, social work, and other disciplines?
   • Are you empathetic with patients facing long-term disability?

4. Clinical readiness

   • Can you manage complex, medically fragile patients?
   • Have you had strong inpatient medicine experiences?

High-Yield SOAP Interview Questions and How to Answer Them

Prepare concise, 60–90 second responses for:

1. “Tell me about yourself.”

   • Briefly cover:
     • Medical school background,
     • Key PM&R-relevant experiences,
     • A defining attribute (e.g., collaborative, persistent, systems-thinker).

2. “Why PM&R?”

   • Mention:
     • A formative PM&R or rehab experience (patient or rotation),
     • Your interest in function, quality of life, neuro/MSK medicine,
     • Alignment with PM&R’s team-based and longitudinal care.

3. “Why did the match not work out for you?”

   • Be honest, brief, and growth-focused:
     • “I believe my late decision to pursue PM&R limited the time I had for audition rotations and networking. Since realizing this, I’ve…”
     • Or “My Step score was a challenge, but my subsequent clerkship performance and sub-I evaluations show consistent, high-level clinical performance.”

4. “What did you do when you learned you didn’t match?”

   • Show professionalism and resilience:
     • “I took a few hours to process, then contacted my dean and PM&R mentor to reassess my options. I organized my priorities for SOAP and started preparing updated materials. It reinforced how committed I am to this field and to improving from setbacks.”

5. “If you don’t end up in PM&R this year, what is your plan?”

   • Demonstrate realism and persistence:
     • “If I do not secure a PM&R or a compatible prelim position, I plan to complete a strong clinical year, remain engaged with PM&R through electives or research, and reapply with more experience and stronger letters. My long-term goal remains to become a physiatrist.”

Presenting Yourself in Prelim / TY SOAP Interviews

For prelim or transitional year positions, focus on:

• Reliability: “We can count on this resident on call, on nights, on weekends.”
• Work ethic and team-first attitude.
• Ability to handle volume, acuity, and administrative tasks.
• Respect for the role, even if your ultimate goal is PM&R.

Do not:

• Sound disinterested in the prelim year.
• Frame it as “just a box to check” before PM&R.

Instead:

• “I want a prelim IM year where I will develop strong inpatient skills and be an integral member of the team. I know that being a good physiatrist begins with being an excellent physician, and this year is essential to that foundation.”

---

Making Smart SOAP Decisions and Planning Beyond Match Week

As SOAP offers begin, decisions come quickly. You need a predefined decision algorithm to avoid last-minute panic.

Ranking Your Priorities Before Offers Arrive

Before SOAP offer rounds start, use your spreadsheet to define:

• Tier 1: Programs you would definitely accept if offered (categorical PM&R, or ideal prelim/TY).
• Tier 2: Programs you would accept but would prefer less (less ideal location, smaller program, etc.).
• Tier 3: Programs you would only accept if no Tier 1 or 2 offer comes.

This helps you align offers with your goals quickly.

Understanding SOAP Offer Rounds

Traditionally:

• Offers are released in multiple rounds over Wednesday–Thursday.
• When you receive an offer in a round, you:
  • Can Accept (binding),
  • Reject (cannot receive another offer from that program),
  • Or Let it expire (treated as a rejection).

You can receive only one offer per round per the current rules. If you accept, you’re done and exited from SOAP.

Strategic Considerations for PM&R-Focused Applicants

1. Categorical PM&R vs. backup specialty vs. prelim

   • A categorical PM&R offer is usually worth accepting if you are sure physiatry is your long-term goal.
   • A categorical backup specialty offer (e.g., FM) should only be accepted if you truly see yourself happy there long-term.
   • A strong prelim/TY offer is valuable if you are willing to reapply to PM&R next cycle.

2. Geographic flexibility

   • During SOAP, geographic selectiveness often must soften.
   • A solid program in a less-desired location is almost always better than no program.

3. Long-term vs. short-term thinking

   • A single difficult year or less ideal city can be outweighed by:
     • Becoming a physiatrist,
     • Access to mentors,
     • Strong training and future opportunities.

If You Don’t Secure a Position Through SOAP

If SOAP ends without a position:

• It is emotionally devastating—but not the end of your path to PM&R.
• Immediately:
  • Meet with your advising dean and PM&R mentor.
  • Develop a 1–2 year plan:
    • Research position in PM&R, neurology, or MSK fields,
    • Clinical assistant or preliminary role outside NRMP,
    • Additional coursework or degrees (e.g., MPH) paired with clinical exposure.

Use that time to:

• Strengthen your application (scores, publications, letters, clinical work).
• Clarify whether you will reapply to PM&R or pivot specialties.

---

Putting It All Together: A PM&R SOAP Preparation Checklist

Use this as a quick-reference action list:

1–2 Months Before Rank List Deadline

• Clarify: Is PM&R your primary long-term goal?
• Evaluate your application with a mentor or advisor.
• Identify likely weaknesses and create a plan to address them in interviews.

Before Match Week

• Draft SOAP-specific:
  • PM&R personal statement (short, focused),
  • Prelim/TY personal statement,
  • Backup specialty statement (if applicable).
• Ensure ERAS is up-to-date, polished, and free of errors.
• Secure PM&R mentor and advising dean for SOAP guidance.
• Prepare interview space, technology, and professional attire.
• Build a SOAP spreadsheet template for program tracking.
• Discuss emotional and logistical support with family/friends.

Monday of Match Week

• Confirm your match status and SOAP eligibility.
• Access the unfilled program list.
• Filter for PM&R, prelim/TY, and any backup specialties.
• Draft your program application strategy (how you’ll use your 45 applications).

Monday–Tuesday

• Finalize which programs to apply to; submit applications as early as allowed.
• Tailor personal statements as needed for key programs.
• Respond promptly and professionally to all interview invitations.
• Conduct mock interviews if time permits, focusing on PM&R and SOAP questions.

Wednesday–Thursday

• Attend SOAP interviews on time, prepared, and dressed professionally.
• Take brief notes after each interview (impressions, culture, strengths/concerns).
• Rank programs into tiers for decision-making.
• When offers appear, decide quickly based on your pre-planned priorities.

After SOAP

• If matched: Notify your mentors, thank your supporters, and begin preparing for residency.
• If unmatched: Debrief with advisors, build a concrete 1–2 year plan, and maintain your engagement with PM&R through shadowing, research, or clinical roles.

---

FAQ: SOAP Preparation in PM&R

1. If I’m very committed to PM&R, should I apply only to PM&R programs in SOAP?
Not usually. PM&R positions in SOAP are limited and not guaranteed. To maximize your chances of starting clinical training, you should also apply strategically to prelim/TY positions and, if appropriate, a small number of backup categorical specialties. This keeps the door open to reapplying to PM&R with a stronger clinical foundation.

2. How can I show continued interest in PM&R if I end up in a prelim or TY year?
Seek out:

• Electives with PM&R or related services (neuro, ortho, trauma, pain).
• Opportunities to rotate on inpatient rehab or consult services at your institution.
• Research or QI projects with physiatrists.
• PM&R conferences or journal clubs when possible.

Strong evaluations, new letters from that year, and clear, sustained engagement with physiatry significantly improve your odds in a future physiatry match.

3. Will programs look down on me if I enter PM&R through SOAP?
No. Many programs recognize that the match can be unpredictable. Once you start residency, your performance as a resident matters far more than how you entered. SOAP residents often become strong, motivated trainees because they’ve already overcome adversity and demonstrated resilience.

4. I have lower board scores. Should I still target PM&R during SOAP?
Yes, if PM&R is truly your goal—but do so strategically. Apply to any PM&R programs with open positions, especially those with a history of holistic review or DO/IMG-friendly environments. At the same time, apply broadly to prelim/TY programs to ensure a solid clinical year. Use interviews to highlight your growth, clinical strengths, and alignment with PM&R values.

---

Preparing thoughtfully for SOAP doesn’t mean you’re expecting to fail; it means you’re serious about becoming a physician—and, if it’s your path, a future physiatrist—no matter how winding the road. With clear goals, honest self-assessment, and a structured plan, you can navigate SOAP in a way that preserves both your options and your confidence.