Essential SOAP Preparation Strategies for DO Graduates in Residency

Preparing for the Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) can feel overwhelming, especially as a DO graduate navigating a competitive residency landscape. With thoughtful, early preparation, SOAP can become a structured opportunity rather than a last-minute scramble. This guide is designed specifically for DO graduates and will walk you through how to prepare strategically—emotionally, logistically, and academically—for a successful osteopathic residency match through SOAP.

---

Understanding SOAP: What It Is and Why It Matters for DO Graduates

Before diving into SOAP preparation strategies, you need a clear answer to “What is SOAP?” and how it intersects with the unique realities of DO graduates.

What is SOAP?

The NRMP Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) is a structured process that takes place during Match Week for applicants who:

• Are unmatched or partially matched (e.g., advanced position but no prelim)
• Are eligible for the Main Residency Match
• Have unfilled residency positions available that they can apply to

SOAP is not a separate match; it is a controlled, time-limited process where:

• You can apply to a defined number of unfilled positions via ERAS.
• Programs review applications and initiate contact (you cannot cold-call).
• You may receive offers in predefined offer rounds, which you can accept or reject.

For DO graduates, SOAP is a crucial safety net, particularly if:

• You focused heavily on ACGME programs with limited osteopathic recognition.
• You had lower exam scores or needed multiple attempts on COMLEX or USMLE.
• You applied narrowly to selective specialties (e.g., dermatology, ortho, radiology).

SOAP and the DO Graduate: Key Considerations

As a DO graduate in the osteopathic residency match environment (now unified under ACGME), you bring unique assets:

• Training in osteopathic principles and OMT.
• Often stronger clinical skills and patient-centered communication.
• A holistic approach many programs value.

However, you may also face:

• Programs that historically favored MD applicants.
• Misunderstandings about COMLEX vs USMLE scores.
• Regional biases or limited exposure outside osteopathic-heavy regions.

SOAP preparation for DO graduates means:

• Anticipating which programs will be DO-friendly.
• Being ready to explain your osteopathic training confidently.
• Strategically using both COMLEX and USMLE (if you took both) in your application.

---

Pre–Match Week Preparation: Building a SOAP-Ready Foundation

The biggest SOAP mistake is assuming, “I’ll deal with it if I don’t match.” SOAP preparation should begin months before Rank Order List certification.

Step 1: Perform an Honest Risk Assessment

Well before Match Week, ask:

1. How competitive is my specialty choice?

   • High risk: Derm, ortho, plastics, urology, ENT, neurosurgery, radiology, some competitive IM subspecialty tracks.
   • Moderate risk: EM, anesthesiology, OB/GYN, gen surg, some community IM/FM in saturated regions.
   • Lower risk (but not zero): FM, IM, peds, psych—though geography and visa issues still matter.

2. How strong is my application?

   • COMLEX and USMLE scores (if taken).
   • Number and quality of audition rotations/sub-internships.
   • Class rank, AOA/other honors, research, leadership.
   • Red flags: leaves of absence, failures, professionalism issues, exam retakes.

3. How broad is my application strategy?

   • Number of programs applied to.
   • Mix of academic vs community.
   • Geographic spread.
   • DO-friendly programs vs historically MD-dominant.

If your risk profile is moderate or high, you should plan as if SOAP is a possibility, even if you ultimately match.

Step 2: Learn the SOAP Mechanics Early

Read the latest NRMP and ERAS SOAP guides (they change slightly year to year). Understand:

• Eligibility requirements
• Timeline of Match Week and SOAP rounds
• Limits on the number of applications you can send during SOAP
• Rules on:
  • Contacting programs (you cannot contact them first)
  • Accepting/declining offers
  • Simultaneous offers and deadlines

Make a personal SOAP timeline with key events:

• Monday of Match Week: Did I match? Email.
• Monday–Tuesday: Access the Unfilled List (via your school advisor) and plan applications.
• Wednesday–Thursday: Offer rounds.
• Friday: Match Day and final outcomes.

Step 3: Clarify Your Specialty and Geographic Flexibility

SOAP often demands rapid decisions about alternatives. Before Match Week:

• Decide which backup specialties you are realistically willing to pursue.

  • Example: A DO student applying EM might be open to FM, IM, or prelim medicine through SOAP.
  • A DO applying gen surg might consider prelim surgery, transitional year, or prelim medicine.

• Define your geographic boundaries:

  • Are you willing to move anywhere in the country?
  • Are there regions you absolutely cannot consider?
  • For visa-requiring IMGs with a DO degree (less common but relevant), note visa policies.

Write down:

• “Primary target SOAP specialty(ies)”
• “Acceptable backup program types” (FM, IM categorical, prelim, TY)
• “Non-negotiable deal-breakers” (location, program size, certain call structures, etc.)

This written framework will help you make clear-headed decisions during SOAP’s fast-paced offer rounds.

Step 4: Update Your ERAS Application with SOAP in Mind

Your ERAS application should be SOAP-ready before Rank Order List certification:

• Personal Statement(s)

  • Create a primary PS for your main specialty.
  • Draft 1–2 alternative personal statements for backup specialties (e.g., IM, FM, prelim).
  • Each statement should:
    • Be specialty-specific.
    • Highlight osteopathic training (OMT, holistic approach).
    • Address any weaknesses without dwelling on them.

• Experiences Section

  • Ensure all experiences are up to date.
  • Emphasize continuity of patient care, team-based work, and adaptability—qualities attractive for SOAP positions, especially in primary care and hospital-based fields.

• Licensing Exams

  • Confirm COMLEX scores are fully uploaded and verified.
  • If you have USMLE scores, make sure they are visible and properly reported.
  • If you only have COMLEX, prepare a brief, professional explanation for programs that are less familiar with COMLEX (more on that later).

• Letters of Recommendation

  • Aim for at least 3–4 strong LORs, including:
    • 1–2 from your primary specialty.
    • 1 from a core discipline (IM, FM, surgery) that can support a backup plan.
  • Clarify with letter writers whether you can use their letters across specialties.

Step 5: Develop a SOAP-Ready CV and Intro Email Template

Even though you won’t initiate contact during SOAP, some programs may ask for:

• An updated CV
• A short email about your interest
• Clarification on your specialty redirection (if switching fields)

Prepare:

• A 1–2 page CV highlighting:

  • DO degree and osteopathic-specific training.
  • Clinical rotations relevant to the specialty.
  • Any OMT experience that’s clinically relevant.
  • Research or QI projects.

• A short interest statement template that you can rapidly customize:

  • 2–3 sentences on:
    • Why you are interested in this program and this specialty.
    • How your DO training and experiences prepare you for their environment.
    • Why you’re serious about staying if matched.

Have these documents saved, polished, and easily accessible.

---

Day-by-Day SOAP Preparation During Match Week

The emotional and logistical intensity of Match Week cannot be overstated. Having a clear playbook allows you to act instead of react.

Monday Morning: You Learn You Did Not Match

If you receive the “Did Not Match” message:

1. Allow yourself a brief emotional response.
   Take 30–60 minutes. Call a trusted person if helpful. Then pivot to action.

2. Immediately connect with your school’s advising resources:

   • Dean of students or clinical education office.
   • Residency advising committee.
   • Specialty advisors who know your file.

3. Clarify your status:

   • Completely unmatched vs partially matched (e.g., advanced position but no prelim).
   • This distinction impacts which positions you should target.

Accessing and Interpreting the Unfilled List

Your school will typically provide access to the NRMP List of Unfilled Programs:

• Filter by:

  • Specialty (FM, IM, IM-prelim, transitional year, gen surg prelim, psych, etc.)
  • Geographic region
  • Program type (university vs community vs hybrid)

• Identify:

  • Programs historically friendly to DO graduates.
  • Positions in states where you are licensed or plan to seek licensure.
  • Programs that explicitly accept COMLEX-only candidates (if relevant).

Strategy for Selecting SOAP Programs as a DO Graduate

You will have a limited number of applications you can submit during SOAP (the exact number is set by ERAS for that year). Use them wisely:

1. Prioritize categorical positions over prelim if you are completely unmatched.
2. Target DO-friendly programs first, especially:
   • Those with osteopathic recognition or a history of DO residents.
   • Community programs in less saturated regions (Midwest, South, some rural areas).
3. Balance reach and realism:
   • Avoid using too many slots on highly competitive programs that likely prefer MD or have high test score cutoffs.
   • Focus on programs where your application is at or slightly above their typical range.

Example strategy for a DO graduate unmatched in EM:

• 10–15 applications to FM categorical (DO-friendly, community-heavy mix).
• 10–15 applications to IM categorical.
• 5–10 to transitional year or IM-prelim if there’s a strong chance of reapplying EM later.

Tailoring Your Application During SOAP

For each program (or at least each specialty), tailor:

• Personal statement:

  • Use the correct specialty-specific statement.
  • If you are switching specialties (e.g., EM to IM), explicitly explain:
    • Why the new specialty genuinely fits your interests.
    • How your prior experiences are relevant.
    • That this is not a “fallback” but a serious redirection.

• Program signals (if applicable that year):

  • If your specialty or ERAS cycle includes signaling, coordinate with your advisor on late-stage signaling strategies for SOAP.

---

Presenting Yourself as a Strong DO Candidate During SOAP

SOAP is not just about filling unfilled positions; it’s about demonstrating fit quickly and clearly. As a DO graduate, you bring distinct strengths that can be leveraged during this compressed process.

Highlighting the Value of Osteopathic Training

Programs may ask (explicitly or implicitly): “Why a DO graduate? What do you bring?”

Prepare 2–3 concise talking points:

• Whole-person care and continuity:

  • “My osteopathic education emphasized treating the whole person, not just the disease. On my FM and IM rotations, I learned to integrate psychosocial factors, lifestyle, and patient goals into every care plan.”

• Hands-on physical exam and procedural comfort:

  • “OMT training sharpened my palpation and physical exam skills, which translates directly into better bedside assessments—even when I’m not performing formal OMT.”

• Teamwork and flexibility:

  • Many DO schools embed early clinical exposure and strong community-based rotations. Emphasize how this prepared you for the workflow of busy community hospitals and clinics.

Addressing COMLEX and USMLE Questions

If you took COMLEX only:

• Be prepared with a neutral explanation:
  • “My DO curriculum required COMLEX, and my school’s advising team recommended focusing on COMLEX alone. My scores reflect consistent performance across the osteopathic content and core clinical subjects. I’m confident they accurately reflect my readiness for residency training.”

If you took both COMLEX and USMLE:

• Have a brief, honest, non-defensive explanation if one score line is lower:
  • “I took both exams to maximize my opportunities. My COMLEX scores are somewhat stronger, likely reflecting familiarity with osteopathic content and exam style. I’ve consistently performed well in clinical settings, which I believe is the best indicator of my readiness.”

SOAP Interview Preparation: Fast, Focused, and Professional

Programs may conduct:

• Phone interviews
• Video interviews (Zoom, Teams)
• Very brief “screening” conversations

Anticipate common questions:

1. “Tell me about yourself.”

   • Keep it to 60–90 seconds.
   • Emphasize DO training, key clinical strengths, and why you’re interested in their specialty/program.

2. “Why did you not match?”

   • Avoid bitterness or blaming.
   • Example:
     • “I applied to a very competitive specialty with a relatively narrow geographic focus. In hindsight, my strategy was more limited than ideal. I’ve reflected on that, broadened my thinking, and I’m now excited about the opportunity to bring my skills to [IM/FM/psych/etc.].”

3. “Why this specialty, and why now (during SOAP)?”

   • You must show this is a genuine, thoughtful choice, not pure desperation.
   • Connect your prior experiences (rotations, interests, personality) to the core values and daily work of that specialty.

4. “Why our program?”

   • Have reviewed their website beforehand if possible.
   • Mention:
     • Patient population.
     • Training structure.
     • Osteopathic-friendly culture (if applicable).
     • Geographic ties or interest.

Practice with:

• Your school advisor.
• A trusted faculty mentor.
• A friend/peer in medicine who can simulate SOAP-style rapid interviews.

---

Emotional Resilience and Long-Term Strategy if SOAP Does Not Work Out

Even with strong SOAP preparation strategies, not every applicant will secure a position in SOAP. As difficult as this possibility is, planning for it protects your long-term career.

If You Do Match Through SOAP

• Fully commit to your new program and specialty.
• Clarify expectations early:
  • Orientation dates.
  • Credentialing.
  • Any requirements regarding OMT or osteopathic recognition (if present).
• If you’ve matched into a prelim or TY, work closely with mentors to build a plan for:
  • Applying again for a categorical position.
  • Strengthening your dossier with research, letters, and clinical excellence.

If You Do Not Match Through SOAP

First 48–72 hours:

• Allow space for grief and disappointment.
• Avoid impulsive decisions, such as immediately abandoning medicine or rushing into unrelated training.

Then, move into structured reflection and planning:

1. Post-SOAP Debrief with Advisors

   • Review:
     • Application strengths and weaknesses.
     • Exam performance and patterns.
     • Specialty choice fit.
     • Geographic and program selection strategy.

2. Decide on a 1-Year Plan Options may include:

   • Research position (clinical or bench).
   • Clinical fellowship (e.g., some non-ACGME fellowships).
   • Additional degrees or certificates (MPH, MS, etc.).
   • Continued clinical work in non-residency settings (where allowed).

3. Strengthen Application Metrics

   • Retake exams if justified and feasible.
   • Publish or present research.
   • Gain additional US clinical experience (if needed, especially for international DO grads).

4. Reevaluate Specialty and Geography

   • Consider shifting to a specialty historically more open to DO graduates (FM, IM, psych, peds).
   • Broaden geographic scope, particularly to less saturated regions.

Throughout this process, your identity as a DO graduate remains an asset—one that can be framed powerfully as you reapply or reposition your career path.

---

Practical SOAP Preparation Checklist for DO Graduates

Use this as a working list before Match Week:

3–4 Months Before Rank List Deadline

• Honest risk assessment of match chances.
• Explore backup specialties and geographic flexibility.
• Confirm all COMLEX (and USMLE, if taken) scores released and verified.
• Secure at least 3–4 strong LORs, including at least one flexible letter useful across specialties.
• Draft primary personal statement plus 1–2 alternative specialty PSs.
• Update ERAS experiences and CV thoroughly.

1–2 Months Before Match Week

• Read current NRMP and ERAS SOAP rules.
• Meet with residency advisor to discuss:
  • SOAP eligibility.
  • Likely realistic SOAP targets.
• Identify DO-friendly programs and regions that historically welcome DO graduates.
• Prepare a generic but customizable interest email template.
• Conduct 1–2 SOAP-style mock interviews.

1–2 Weeks Before Match Week

• Confirm all documents (PS variants, CV, transcripts, exam reports) are final and accessible.
• Create a personal SOAP plan:
  • Target specialties in order of priority.
  • Geographic “yes/maybe/no” list.
• Arrange availability:
  • Limit obligations during Match Week.
  • Ensure stable internet and phone service.

During Match Week (If Unmatched)

• Meet with advising team immediately on Monday.
• Review the Unfilled List with filters for DO-friendly programs.
• Prioritize categorical DO-friendly programs, then prelim/TY as needed.
• Tailor PS and application for each specialty.
• Keep phone on and email refreshed—respond promptly and professionally.
• Debrief after each interview; refine talking points.

---

FAQs: SOAP Preparation for DO Graduates

1. As a DO graduate, should I take USMLE in addition to COMLEX to be more competitive in SOAP?
It can help, especially for historically MD-dominant or academic programs, but it is not mandatory. Many DO graduates successfully match through SOAP with COMLEX only, particularly into DO-friendly fields like FM, IM, psych, and peds. If you are early in your training, discuss pros/cons of USMLE with your dean’s office; if SOAP is imminent, focus on optimizing your existing application rather than adding new exams.

2. How do I choose which specialties to target in SOAP if I was aiming for a competitive field?
Start by mapping your core strengths (clinical evaluations, letters, rotation performance) to specialties that value them and traditionally welcome DO graduates. Common SOAP targets for DO graduates include FM, IM, psych, peds, and sometimes prelim/TY positions. Discuss realistic options with advisors and be prepared to articulate a genuine interest in any new specialty you choose.

3. Is it better to accept a prelim/TY SOAP position or remain unmatched and reapply next year?
It depends on your long-term goals, finances, geographic preferences, and how likely you are to significantly improve your application in the next cycle. A prelim or TY can provide strong clinical evaluations and help you re-enter the match stronger, but it does not guarantee a future categorical position. A personalized discussion with advisors is essential; there is no one-size-fits-all answer.

4. How can I quickly demonstrate the value of my osteopathic training during SOAP interviews?
Prepare a concise narrative that links DO training to residency success: highlight your whole-person care approach, hands-on exam skills, comfort in community-based settings, and any OMT experience that improved patient outcomes. Programs value residents who communicate well, work hard, and integrate clinical reasoning with patient-centered care—areas where DO graduates often excel.

---

Thoughtful, early SOAP preparation allows you, as a DO graduate, to navigate Match Week with clarity, professionalism, and resilience. By understanding the process, acknowledging your unique strengths, and planning for multiple outcomes, you give yourself the best possible chance of securing a residency position that aligns with your skills and long-term goals.