Mastering SOAP Preparation Strategies for MD Graduates in Residency

Understanding SOAP: What It Is and Why It Matters for MD Graduates

If you’re an MD graduate from an allopathic medical school, you likely approached Match Week expecting to see a “Congratulations, you have matched” email. When that doesn’t happen—or when you only partially match—the Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) becomes your critical second chance.

Before you plan your SOAP preparation, it’s essential to understand what is SOAP, what it is not, and how it differs from the regular allopathic medical school match.

What Is SOAP?

SOAP (Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program) is a structured, time-limited process run by NRMP during Match Week to fill unfilled PGY-1 and some preliminary or advanced positions. It allows eligible unmatched or partially matched applicants to apply to unfilled positions and receive multiple rounds of offers through ERAS/NRMP.

Key features:

• Eligibility-based: Only certain applicants may participate (e.g., those who are unmatched, partially matched, or withdrawn but eligible, and registered for the Main Residency Match).
• Time-limited: Occurs over a few intense days during Match Week, with strict schedules and multiple offer rounds.
• Centralized offers: Programs extend offers only through the NRMP SOAP system, not directly via email or calls.
• Application cap: Historically, applicants can send up to 45 applications to unfilled programs (verify each year’s rules).

SOAP vs. the Regular Match

The allopathic medical school match happens earlier in the season through ROLs (rank order lists) and an algorithm. SOAP is different:

• No rank lists: You don’t rank programs; programs decide who to offer, and you either accept or reject in each round.
• Rapid decisions: Offer windows are short (often a few hours). You must respond quickly, or offers expire.
• Different psychology: During the regular match, you cast a wide net months before results. During SOAP residency, you respond in real time under time pressure and emotional stress.

Who Typically Enters SOAP?

Among MD graduate residency applicants, SOAP may include:

• US MD graduates who are completely unmatched
• US MD graduates who are partially matched (e.g., matched to an advanced position but not a preliminary year)
• Applicants who withdrew or didn’t certify a rank list but are still NRMP-eligible
• Applicants whose only matched position is not viable (e.g., program closure before start)

SOAP is not a sign that you are a “bad” candidate. Positions go unfilled every year for many reasons: program expansion, geography, specialty competitiveness, interview misalignment, or simply random chance in the algorithm.

---

Pre-SOAP Preparation: What to Do Before Match Week

The best SOAP preparation starts months before Match Week—ideally while you’re still in the regular MD graduate residency application cycle. Preparation reduces panic and increases strategic clarity if you need SOAP.

1. Know Your Risk Profile Early

As an MD graduate, consider your risk of needing SOAP residency based on:

• Board scores (USMLE Step 1/2 CK) and failures or repeats
• Red flags (LOA, professionalism issues, failed rotations)
• Specialty competitiveness (e.g., dermatology vs internal medicine)
• Number and quality of interviews received
• Geographic restrictions (rigid vs flexible)
• Personal constraints (visa status is more relevant for IMGs, but MD grads may still have location or family limitations)

If your interview count is low for your specialty (e.g., fewer than 10–12 for IM/FM, 6–8 for more competitive fields), plan as if SOAP might be needed.

2. Identify Your Plan B (and Possibly Plan C) Specialties

SOAP rarely has abundant positions in hyper-competitive specialties. Your SOAP preparation should include:

• Realistic backup specialties:
  • Broad-access fields: Internal Medicine, Family Medicine, Pediatrics, Psychiatry
  • Transitional Year (TY) or Preliminary Medicine/Surgery for those seeking advanced specialties later
• Flexible geographic ranges:
  • Be open to rural, community, or less popular locations
  • Emphasize training quality and board pass rates over name recognition

Create a prioritized list:

1. Primary SOAP target specialty (e.g., Internal Medicine)
2. Secondary specialty (e.g., Family Medicine or Psychiatry)
3. Preliminary or transitional options if relevant to your long-term goal

3. Prepare SOAP-Specific Application Materials in Advance

You will have very little time once SOAP starts. Have the following ready before Match Week:

Updated CV and ERAS Content

• ERAS application: Ensure all experience sections, publications, and activities are up-to-date.
• CV: Maintain a clean, one- to two-page CV you can share if a program requests it outside ERAS (e.g., via your dean’s office or advisor).

SOAP-Oriented Personal Statements

Craft multiple tailored personal statements before Match Week:

• One for each likely SOAP specialty (IM, FM, Peds, Psych, etc.)
• One preliminary/TY-focused personal statement if relevant
• Optional: a brief, more generalist version that can be rapidly adapted for unexpected options

These statements should:

• Highlight commitment to patient care and learning
• Address red flags succinctly and positively, if needed
• Emphasize fit with broader program missions (e.g., community care, underserved populations)

Letters of Recommendation (LoRs) Strategy

LoRs are usually locked in ERAS, but you can pre-load options:

• Ensure you have at least 3–4 strong letters:
  • 2 from your primary specialty
  • 1–2 from internal medicine or family medicine if you might SOAP there
• Ask letter writers in advance if they’d be comfortable with your using the letter for broader specialties if needed.

Communicate with your dean’s office or advising team about SOAP so they know you may contact them urgently during Match Week.

4. Prepare Your Support System

SOAP is emotionally intense. A structured support network is part of solid SOAP preparation:

• Advisors / mentors: Identify one or two faculty who:
  • Understand SOAP residency mechanics
  • Can quickly review your preferences and offer advice during Match Week
• Dean’s office liaison: Know who handles SOAP logistics at your school.
• Emotional support: Trusted friends, family, or a counselor who can help you process emotions without derailing your focus.

---

Strategic SOAP Preparation: Research, Targeting, and Flexibility

Beyond materials, high-yield SOAP preparation is about strategy—understanding which programs are likely to be available, how to prioritize them, and how to communicate your value quickly and convincingly.

1. Understand SOAP-Eligible Positions

Historically, SOAP includes:

• Categorical PGY-1 positions (IM, FM, Peds, Psych, etc.)
• Preliminary Medicine/Surgery
• Transitional Year positions
• Some advanced positions (less common in SOAP for MD graduates)

Trends to keep in mind:

• More unfilled positions tend to occur in:
  • Community and rural programs
  • Programs in less popular locations or with resource limitations
  • Newer or expanding programs still building reputation
• Fewer unfilled positions in:
  • Highly competitive programs and specialties
  • Major academic centers in popular cities

2. Build a “Shadow List” of Likely SOAP Targets

Before Match Week, build a shadow program list with potential SOAP targets:

• Review previous years’ SOAP data (NRMP publishes unfilled position reports).
• Note:
  • Programs that frequently have unfilled spots
  • Specialties with recurrent SOAP availability
  • Geographic areas you’d accept (including “last resort” areas)

For each program, research:

• Board pass rates
• Patient population
• Clinical volume (breadth of training)
• Alumni placement (fellowships, practice sites)
• Any deal-breakers (e.g., ACGME warning, chronic instability)

Keep a spreadsheet with:

• Program name / specialty
• Location
• Past SOAP history (if known)
• Pros/cons
• Priority tier (A, B, C)

This becomes your rapid triage tool once the unfilled list is released.

3. Clarify Your Non-Negotiables vs Flexibles

SOAP requires trade-offs. Before you’re under time pressure:

Non-negotiables might include:

• Specific visa/eligibility constraints (less common for US MDs but can include citizenship, contract issues, etc.)
• Programs with clear accreditation problems or patterns of resident mistreatment
• Absolute family/location constraints (e.g., you’re a primary caregiver with fixed obligations)

Flexibles should include:

• Location preference (city vs rural, region of the country)
• Program “prestige”
• Academic vs community setting
• Exact specialty if you’re open to more than one primary-care type field

Write these down. In the heat of SOAP, impulsive decisions are common; a written priority list helps you stay consistent with your values and long-term goals.

4. Craft a Strong SOAP Pitch

In SOAP, programs may reach out for brief phone or video conversations. You should be ready with a concise, confident “pitch”:

Include:

1. Who you are

   • “I’m a recent MD graduate from [School], with strong clinical performance in [core areas] and a particular interest in [X].”

2. Why this specialty/program

   • Show you understand their program: patient population, philosophy, or structure.
   • “I’m drawn to your program’s focus on [underserved care/research/primary care] and your track record of [board pass rate, fellowships].”

3. What you bring

   • A few concrete strengths: work ethic, teamwork, specific skills, leadership, research aligned with their mission.

4. Addressing concern(s) (if relevant)

   • Briefly and confidently frame any red flag and what you learned from it.

Rehearse with a mentor or friend before Match Week. You want this to feel natural, not scripted.

---

Execution During SOAP Week: Step-by-Step Game Plan

SOAP preparation only pays off if you execute calmly and systematically during Match Week. Here’s how to navigate it.

1. Monday Morning: When You Learn You Are Unmatched or Partially Matched

Once NRMP notifies you that you are unmatched or partially matched:

1. Pause for 15–30 minutes

   • Emotional shock is normal. Cry, vent, or step outside briefly.
   • Then, shift deliberately to “problem-solving mode.”

2. Contact Your School’s Advising Office Immediately

   • Many schools have dedicated SOAP teams.
   • Schedule an urgent meeting to review your situation and strategy.

3. Clarify Your Status

   • Fully unmatched
   • Partially matched (e.g., advanced position matched but no prelim year)
   • With or without specific geographic or personal constraints

This affects which SOAP positions you should prioritize.

2. Reviewing the Unfilled Positions List

Once NRMP releases the list of unfilled positions:

1. Compare it against your “shadow list”
   • Highlight your top-choice programs and specialties.
2. Sort by priority:
   • Tier 1: Programs you’d be very happy to attend
   • Tier 2: Acceptable but not ideal
   • Tier 3: Last-resort options, but still better than not matching

Apply your non-negotiables upfront: remove any program that clearly violates them (troubling accreditation history, impossible location constraint, etc.).

3. Allocating Your Limited SOAP Applications

Because you’ll typically have only 45 applications, allocation is crucial.

Example strategy for an MD graduate:

• 20–25 applications to your primary SOAP specialty (e.g., Internal Medicine)
• 10–15 to secondary SOAP-friendly specialties (e.g., FM, Psych, Peds)
• 5–10 to preliminary or TY positions (if needed for an advanced match or as a bridge year)

Adjust based on:

• The actual number of unfilled programs in your target fields
• Your relative competitiveness (stronger MD graduates may aim more heavily toward categorical positions)

4. Customizing Personal Statements and ERAS Details

You won’t fully rewrite your application for each program, but you should:

• Use specialty-specific personal statements you prepared in advance.
• Ensure ERAS experiences emphasize what each specialty values:
  • IM/FM: Continuity of care, communication, teamwork, broad clinical skills
  • Peds: Patience, family-centered care, child advocacy
  • Psych: Empathy, communication, interest in mental health care
• Where allowed and practical, tailor the program field or additional comments section (if available) briefly to reflect why you’re a good fit.

5. Managing Communication With Programs

During SOAP, programs may:

• Request additional information via email
• Ask for quick phone or video interviews
• Reach out indirectly via your dean’s office

Best practices:

• Respond promptly and professionally (within minutes to an hour during business hours).
• Keep your voicemail greeting professional and your phone on loud.
• Have your SOAP pitch ready and notes about each program visible when they call.

What not to do:

• Do not attempt to pressure programs into offers.
• Do not send mass, generic emails to dozens of programs; targeted, specific communication is more effective (if allowed by rules that year—always verify NRMP/ERAS communication rules).

6. Handling SOAP Offers in Real Time

SOAP typically includes several rounds of offers. In each round:

• You may receive multiple offers, one offer, or none.
• You must accept or reject within a short window (e.g., a few hours).

How to decide:

• Refer to your prewritten priority list.
• If you receive an offer from a program in your Tier 1, you will almost always accept.
• If the offer is from a Tier 2 or 3 program:
  • Consider your realistic probability of getting something better in later rounds.
  • If you are relatively less competitive (few interviews, red flags), be more inclined to accept a solid offer early.

Once you accept:

• You are committed and removed from further SOAP participation.
• Celebrate your success; you now have a residency position.

---

After SOAP: Next Steps, Alternative Plans, and Long-Term Perspective

Whether you successfully match through SOAP residency or remain unmatched, your work isn’t over. Your long-term career trajectory still holds many options.

If You Match Through SOAP

1. Shift into Success Mode

   • Make contact with your new program coordinator promptly.
   • Complete onboarding tasks (credentialing, licensing, health forms) quickly.

2. Reframe Your Narrative

   • You are now a resident physician. Focus less on how you matched and more on:
     • Clinical excellence
     • Professionalism
     • Board exam success
   • Few people care how you matched once you are a high-performing resident.

3. Plan for Long-Term Goals

   • If you matched into a different specialty than you initially wanted, be open-minded:
     • Many physicians discover unexpected satisfaction in a SOAP-acquired specialty.
   • If you still hope to pursue another specialty later, focus first on excelling in your current program; good evaluations and strong performance give you options.

If You Do Not Match Through SOAP

It is painful and disorienting, but your career is not over.

Steps:

1. Take 24–48 hours to process emotions with support from family, friends, or professionals.

2. Meet with advisors to analyze:

   • Which factors contributed: specialty choice, application strategy, academic issues, timing, etc.
   • Whether to reapply next year—and if so, in which specialty.

3. Develop a structured gap-year plan:

   • Clinical roles (e.g., research assistant, hospitalist scribe, clinical coordinator where allowed)
   • Research fellowships in your desired specialty
   • Additional degrees or certifications only if they meaningfully enhance your candidacy
   • Addressing academic or professionalism gaps

4. Reflect on Flexibility

   • Consider whether broadening your next application to more SOAP-friendly specialties (e.g., IM, FM, Psych) would align with your values and goals.
   • Many MD graduates who didn’t match in a highly competitive field find rewarding careers in a different specialty the second time around.

---

Frequently Asked Questions: SOAP Preparation for MD Graduates

1. As an MD graduate, how likely am I to need SOAP?

Your need for SOAP residency depends more on specialty choice, interview volume, and red flags than on your MD vs DO/IMG status. MD graduates applying to competitive specialties with fewer than ~8 interviews or with significant red flags are at higher risk. If you’re even moderately worried, invest in SOAP preparation—having a plan doesn’t hurt you, and it may be invaluable.

2. Can I still apply to my original specialty during SOAP?

Yes, if there are unfilled positions in that specialty and you meet their criteria, you can apply. However, many competitive specialties have very few or no SOAP-eligible spots. Most MD graduate residency applicants in SOAP find greater success by targeting broader-access specialties (IM, FM, Peds, Psych) or preliminary/TY positions, depending on their long-term goals.

3. How should my SOAP personal statement differ from my original one?

For SOAP:

• Be more concise and focused on readiness to start residency.
• Emphasize reliability, teachability, and commitment to patient care.
• If you are switching specialties (e.g., from surgery to internal medicine), clearly explain your authentic interest in the new specialty, not just that it is a “backup.”
• Briefly address major red flags if not explained elsewhere; keep the tone constructive and forward-looking.

4. Is it better to accept a less desirable SOAP offer or risk waiting for something better?

This depends on your competitiveness and risk tolerance:

• If you have significant red flags or very few interviews, a solid SOAP offer— even at a less-desired location—may be your best path into residency.
• More competitive MD graduates might cautiously wait for later rounds if they have reason to believe better options are coming.
• Use your pre-written priority list and discuss decisions in real time with a trusted advisor; remember that once SOAP ends, you cannot join the Match until the following year.

---

By approaching SOAP preparation deliberately—understanding the process, building strategic backup plans, preparing materials in advance, and staying grounded during Match Week—you significantly improve your chances of landing a position that moves your career forward. As an MD graduate, your training, skills, and resilience remain your greatest assets, regardless of the route you take into residency.