SOAP Preparation Guide for Transitional Year Residency Success

Understanding SOAP in the Context of Transitional Year

The Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) is the structured process that helps unmatched or partially matched applicants secure unfilled residency positions in the days immediately following the NRMP Main Match.

For Transitional Year (TY)–focused applicants, SOAP has some unique features and strategic implications. Before planning your SOAP preparation, you need to understand a few key elements:

What is SOAP (and How It Actually Works)?

SOAP is NOT the old “Scramble.” It is a tightly regulated, time-limited, application and offer system run through ERAS and NRMP. In brief:

• Eligibility
  You may participate if:

  • You are registered for the Match and
  • You are unmatched or partially matched at the start of Match Week and
  • You are SOAP-eligible per NRMP rules (shown in your NRMP portal).

• Timeline (high-level)

  • Monday of Match Week:
    • Morning: You learn if you’re matched, partially matched, or unmatched.
    • Midday: ERAS opens to view the List of Unfilled Programs.
  • Monday–Thursday: Multiple application and offer rounds:
    • You can apply to up to 45 programs total throughout SOAP.
    • Programs review, interview (often virtually or by phone), and make offers via NRMP.
  • Thursday: SOAP ends; any remaining unfilled positions become available for post-SOAP contacting (“Open Positions”).

• Application mechanics

  • You use your existing ERAS application (no new ERAS created).
  • You can edit some components (we’ll detail this later).
  • You send applications to programs directly through ERAS; there is no fee for SOAP applications.

• Offer rounds

  • Programs submit rank lists of SOAP applicants.
  • NRMP issues offers in waves; you have a short window (typically 2 hours) to accept or reject each offer.
  • Accepting a position is binding; you are removed from further SOAP participation.

Understanding what is SOAP and its constraints is essential before you design a strategy tailored to Transitional Year positions.

Why SOAP Strategy Is Different for Transitional Year

Transitional Year (TY) programs are 1-year general clinical internships, commonly used by applicants who:

• Need an intern year for advanced specialties (e.g., Radiology, Anesthesiology, PM&R, Derm, Rad Onc).
• Want broad clinical exposure before committing to a categorical specialty.
• Are re-applicants building clinical and professional strength.

For SOAP, TY positions have special considerations:

1. Highly variable availability

   • Some years have several unfilled TY spots; other years very few.
   • Many TY programs fill through the main Match; SOAP may offer limited choice.

2. Advanced vs. categorical planning

   • If you’re aiming for an advanced specialty (e.g., you matched an advanced spot but not prelim/TY, or vice versa), your SOAP strategy must consider:
     • Location compatibility with your advanced position.
     • Visa and institutional policies if you are an IMG.

3. Program expectations

   • TY programs in SOAP often prioritize:
     • Strong work ethic, flexibility, and professionalism.
     • Clear communication about long-term goals (even if not staying at that institution).

4. Competition

   • SOAP for TY may pit you against:
     • Strong U.S. grads who went unmatched in advanced specialties.
     • IMGs specifically targeting TY/prelim spots as a route into the U.S. system.

Successful SOAP preparation for Transitional Year therefore requires:

• Realistic self-assessment
• Early document preparation
• Clear preference strategy (TY vs prelim vs categorical)
• Rapid communication during Match Week

---

Pre–Match Week Preparation: Building a SOAP-Ready Application

Your best SOAP preparation happens weeks to months before Match Week. Waiting until Monday of Match Week is too late to do this properly.

1. Clarify Your Transitional Year Goals

Before editing your application or contacting advisors, answer:

• Do I need a TY specifically, or would a Preliminary Medicine or Preliminary Surgery year also meet my needs?
• If I’m pursuing an advanced specialty:
  • Do I already have an advanced PGY-2 position secured?
  • Am I trying to secure both an intern year and an advanced spot in SOAP?
• Am I open to:
  • Any geographic location?
  • Community programs, non-university hospitals?
  • Night float-heavy or ICU-heavy schedules?

Write down:

• A “Must-Have” list (e.g., visa sponsorship, proximity to spouse, specific region).
• A “Nice-to-Have” list (e.g., academic affiliation, research time).

You’ll use this framework to rapidly screen SOAP residency programs during Match Week.

2. Optimize Your ERAS for Transitional Year and SOAP

Most applicants design their initial ERAS application around a specific specialty (Radiology, Anesthesiology, etc.). For SOAP, you may suddenly be targeting TY programs that want:

• Evidence of broad clinical interest.
• Clear explanation of why a Transitional Year makes sense for you.
• Professional resilience and adaptability.

Key sections to pre-optimize:

1. Personal Statement(s)
   Prepare at least one SOAP-ready personal statement that:

   • Clearly states your:
     • Long-term specialty interest (if known).
     • Rationale for needing a strong, broad-based Transitional Year.
   • Emphasizes:
     • Clinical skills and professionalism.
     • Teamwork, adaptability, and work ethic.
     • Your willingness to work hard in different rotations.

   Example structure:

   • Paragraph 1: Brief narrative about your clinical growth during rotations.
   • Paragraph 2: Why you value broad clinical training and how TY aligns with your goals.
   • Paragraph 3: Specific strengths you bring to a TY program (reliability, communication, patient-centered care).
   • Paragraph 4: Future goals and how a TY year will position you for your planned specialty.

   Also consider:

   • A second version emphasizing Preliminary Medicine or Preliminary Surgery, in case TY positions are limited and you need broader options.

2. Experience Descriptions

   • Highlight:
     • Rotations in Internal Medicine, Surgery, Emergency Medicine, ICU.
     • Leadership roles, call responsibilities, and systems-based practice.
   • Use bullets that show:
     • Responsibility level (“managed admission workup under supervision…”)
     • Team role (“coordinated with multidisciplinary teams…”)
     • Outcomes (“improved clinic flow by…”)

3. MSPE and Transcripts

   • You can’t change their content, but you should:
     • Know your strengths and weaknesses.
     • Prepare to verbally contextualize any red flags if asked (failed COMLEX/USMLE, remediation, extended time, etc.).

4. Letters of Recommendation

   • Before rank order list certification, consider:
     • Do you have 3–4 letters that demonstrate “good intern” qualities?
     • At least one strong letter from Internal Medicine or Surgery is ideal for TY.
   • During SOAP, you can reassign existing letters to different programs, but you cannot upload new letters.

3. SOAP-Specific Documents and Logistics

Set yourself up with everything you’ll need ahead of time:

• SOAP-focused CV (for your own reference)

  • Not uploaded to ERAS, but useful to quickly answer questions, craft emails, and structure your pitch.

• Standardized email templates (drafted)

  • For post-SOAP communication with programs that remain unfilled.
  • For polite, concise self-introduction if program coordinators request more info.

• Technology and environment

  • Reliable high-speed internet.
  • Quiet room with professional background for video calls.
  • A charged phone at all times during Match Week.
  • Professional attire ready (jacket, tie, or neat blouse/top).

• Time blocked off

  • Keep Match Week as free as possible:
    • Inform rotations that you may need brief periods off for urgent calls (many schools have SOAP policies).
    • Avoid scheduling major exams or travel.

---

Match Week Strategy: Executing Your Transitional Year SOAP Plan

Once Match Week starts, your SOAP preparation must translate into decisive action. This phase is intense but manageable if you’ve prepped well.

1. Monday Morning: Process the Result, Then Move to Action

You learn one of three outcomes:

• Fully matched: You are not eligible for SOAP. Focus on next steps for your matched program.
• Partially matched:
  Example for TY applicants:
  • Matched to an advanced position (e.g., Radiology PGY-2) but no PGY-1.
  • Or matched to a PGY-1 only and not the advanced spot you wanted.
• Unmatched: No positions secured.

If you are partially matched or unmatched:

1. Allow yourself a brief emotional reaction.
2. Then shift immediately into problem-solving mode:
   • Contact your Dean’s Office or Student Affairs—many have dedicated SOAP advisors.
   • Clarify your eligibility status in your NRMP portal (“SOAP-Eligible” should be clearly indicated).

2. Reviewing the List of Unfilled Programs

When the list opens:

• Filter specifically for:
  • Transitional Year
  • Preliminary Medicine
  • Preliminary Surgery
  • Relevant categorical backups (e.g., Internal Medicine, Family Medicine) if you’re open to them.

Consider:

• Geography: Are there regions you absolutely cannot go to (for family, health, or legal reasons)? Otherwise, keep an open mind—SOAP is about securing a position, not perfection.
• Program type:
  • Community vs university-affiliated.
  • Hospital size and patient volume.
• Visa sponsorship: For IMGs, check J-1/H-1B policies as best you can from program websites or school advisors.

Create a priority list of:

• High-desirability programs (ideal location/fit).
• Acceptable programs (good training, workable tradeoffs).
• Safety programs (less ideal but acceptable for one year).

3. Allocating Your 45 SOAP Applications

You can send up to 45 applications total during SOAP. These must be allocated strategically.

For a Transitional Year–focused applicant, one practical distribution might look like:

• TY programs: 15–25 applications

  • If many TY slots are open, lean heavily into them.
  • If few are available, allocate more to prelim pathways.

• Preliminary Medicine: 10–15 applications

  • Particularly if your advanced specialty aligns more with medicine-based intern experience.

• Preliminary Surgery: 5–10 applications

  • If you are open to surgical rotations and call-heavy schedules; especially relevant for some advanced fields (e.g., Radiology, Anesthesia).

• Categorical backup specialties (if you’re open to them):

  • Internal Medicine, Family Medicine, PM&R, etc., using remaining slots.

The exact mix will depend on:

• Number of unfilled positions in each category.
• Your long-term goals and flexibility.

Be realistic:

• If there are only 6 TY programs with 1–2 spots each, don’t send 40 of your 45 applications only to TY. Build parallel paths.

4. Tailoring Applications Rapidly

Within ERAS during SOAP, you cannot rewrite your whole application, but you can:

• Assign SOAP-specific personal statements to appropriate program types (TY vs prelim vs categorical).
• Reassign letters of recommendation to highlight the most relevant ones for transitional or preliminary training.

Practical example:

• For a community hospital Transitional Year:

  • Use your broad clinical interest personal statement.
  • Include at least one strong IM letter and one Surgery or EM letter if available.

• For a Preliminary Medicine position:

  • Use personal statement emphasizing internal medicine interest and skills.
  • Prioritize your strongest IM letters.

Apply broadly early in the first SOAP application window; you can re-balance across waves as needed if ERAS allows reassignments to programs that haven’t yet received your application.

---

Interviewing and Communication During SOAP

SOAP interviews move fast and can be very different from standard ERAS interviews.

1. SOAP Interview Format and Common Questions

Programs may conduct:

• Phone calls
• Web-based video interviews (Zoom, Teams, Webex)
• Brief “screening” conversations with PDs or APDs.

Expect shorter, more focused interactions—sometimes 10–20 minutes.

Common Transitional Year–relevant questions:

• “Why are you interested in a Transitional Year program?”
• “What are your long-term career goals or intended specialty?”
• “How would your past experiences prepare you to be an effective intern?”
• “Tell me about a time when you had to handle a very heavy workload.”
• “Can you explain [USMLE/COMLEX] challenges or academic gaps?” (if applicable)
• “We’re very service-heavy—how do you manage stress and fatigue?”

Prepare brief but specific answers:

Example answer structure for “Why Transitional Year?”:

1. Acknowledge your broader goals:
   “My long-term goal is to become a radiologist…”
2. Connect TY to your development:
   “…but I recognize that to be an excellent radiologist I need a strong foundation in direct patient care…”
3. Highlight your match to their program:
   “…your Transitional Year’s mix of inpatient medicine, ICU, and emergency medicine would give me that foundation while allowing me to contribute as a reliable, hard-working intern.”

2. Presenting Yourself as a Strong TY Candidate

Programs want interns who are:

• Reliable and responsive
• Team-oriented and low-drama
• Able to learn quickly and safely
• Comfortable working in various departments

Emphasize:

• Examples of handling call or night shifts during rotations.
• Times you helped teammates, picked up extra tasks, or handled complex patients.
• Concrete actions you take to maintain patient safety and seek help appropriately.

Avoid:

• Overemphasis on research if it suggests you are disinterested in clinical work.
• Speaking negatively about previous programs, institutions, or mentors.
• Making it sound like this is a “consolation prize” rather than a meaningful year of growth.

3. Communication Etiquette During SOAP

Because SOAP is compressed, timing and professionalism matter even more:

• Answer unknown calls during Match Week—many will be from programs.
• If you miss a call:
  • Return it as soon as possible.
  • Leave a clear, concise voicemail if no one answers.
• For emails:
  • Check frequently and respond within minutes to hours, not days.
  • Keep responses professional, brief, and error-free.

Do NOT:

• Attempt to bargain or negotiate offers during SOAP.
  Offers are extended and accepted through NRMP; side agreements can violate rules.
• Ask programs if they will rank you highly during SOAP rounds (it puts them in an awkward position and is often prohibited).

---

Making Decisions and Planning Beyond SOAP

Once offers begin, decision-making must be rapid and thoughtful.

1. Understanding SOAP Offers for Transitional Year

During each offer round:

• You may receive:
  • No offers
  • One offer
  • Multiple offers (less common but possible)

Key points:

• You must decide within the NRMP-specified window (often 2 hours).
• Accepting an offer is binding:
  • You leave SOAP and cannot seek or accept another NRMP Match position for that year.
• You may decline an offer and wait for later SOAP rounds—but there is risk.

For a TY-focused applicant:

• If you receive a Transitional Year offer that:
  • Meets your minimum geographic/visa needs and
  • Seems reasonably supportive and educational
• It is usually wise to strongly consider accepting, especially if:
  • You are an IMG or have application weaknesses.
  • This is the only or first offer, and your advisor agrees it is solid.

2. Balancing TY, Prelim, and Categorical Offers

If you receive:

• TY offer vs Preliminary Medicine offer:

  • If your chosen advanced specialty values a broad base (Radiology, Anesthesia, Derm), many applicants prefer TY for exposure to multiple fields.
  • If TY options are limited or far from your advanced position’s location, a Prelim Medicine spot may be more practical.

• TY offer vs categorical in a different specialty:

  • This is a deeply personal decision:
    • Do you want one year of clinical training and then reapply to your chosen specialty?
    • Or are you open to spending your career in the categorical specialty if you enjoy it?
  • Discuss with:
    • Dean’s Office adviser
    • Trusted faculty mentors
    • Family/partners (for geographic and life implications)

Always keep in mind:

• A TY or prelim year can strengthen you as a reapplicant:
  US clinical experience, strong letters, improved exam attempts.
• A categorical position may offer more stability but may alter your specialty trajectory.

3. If You Do Not Secure a Position Through SOAP

Not matching through SOAP is emotionally difficult, but it is not the end of your career.

Immediate steps:

• Debrief with advisors:
  • Review your application honestly: exams, red flags, personal statement, letters, school record.
• Analyze patterns:
  • Did you get interviews but no offers?
    • May indicate interview style or ranking behaviors to adjust.
  • Very few interviews?
    • May indicate exam performance, school support, or specialty competitiveness issues.

Post-SOAP options:

• Post-SOAP open positions (independent “scramble”):

  • Some programs may still be unfilled after SOAP ends.
  • Your Dean’s Office may help connect you, but this is highly variable.

• Re-application strategy:

  • Strengthen weak areas:
    • Consider a research year (ideally with some clinical exposure).
    • Improve USMLE/COMLEX scores if eligible and appropriate.
    • Seek observerships or hands-on clinical work (depending on your status).
  • Reassess specialty choice:
    • Some highly competitive specialties have very low re-match rates for marginal applicants.
    • A broader or less competitive specialty may be a wise long-term pivot.

• Emotional and practical support:

  • Utilize wellness and counseling resources.
  • Connect with alumni or older trainees who’ve successfully matched on subsequent attempts.

---

FAQs: SOAP Preparation for Transitional Year Applicants

1. How can I specifically tailor my SOAP preparation for a Transitional Year residency?

• Prepare a TY-focused personal statement highlighting:
  • Desire for broad-based clinical training.
  • Your adaptability and team-based mindset.
  • How a Transitional Year fits into your long-term goals.
• Ensure you have:
  • Strong letters from core clinical rotations (especially IM/Surgery).
  • Clear explanations for any gaps or red flags.
• During interviews, emphasize:
  • Your readiness to work hard in various departments.
  • Your respect for the value of this one-year internship, not just as a stepping stone.

2. Is it realistic to target only Transitional Year programs in SOAP?

That depends on the number of unfilled TY positions and the strength of your application. In many years, Transitional Year spots in SOAP are limited and competitive. For most applicants, it is safer to:

• Apply to TY + Prelim Medicine + Prelim Surgery programs.
• Consider additional categorical specialties if your long-term plan is flexible.

Concentrating exclusively on TY may severely limit your chances of securing any position, especially as an IMG or if you have exam/academic challenges.

3. How does SOAP residency strategy change if I already matched an advanced spot but not a PGY-1?

If you have an advanced PGY-2 position but no intern year:

• Your top priority in SOAP is obtaining a PGY-1 (TY or prelim) that will allow you to start that advanced spot on time.
• Focus on:
  • Programs that are geographically compatible with your advanced position if possible.
  • Being very clear in interviews that:
    • You already have a PGY-2 advanced position.
    • You are highly motivated to perform well during your intern year.
• In many cases, TY programs value candidates who have a clear, secured path for PGY-2, as it suggests direction and stability.

4. What is the best way to prepare for SOAP interviews for Transitional Year programs?

• Practice short, focused answers to:
  • “Why Transitional Year?”
  • “What are your strengths and weaknesses as a future intern?”
  • “Tell me about a clinical challenge you handled.”
• Do mock interviews with:
  • Faculty, residents, or Dean’s office staff.
• Prepare 1–2 concise stories each about:
  • Teamwork
  • Handling heavy workload
  • Dealing with a mistake or near-miss
• Test your video setup:
  • Camera, microphone, lighting, and background.
  • Professional attire ready and comfortable.

---

By understanding what SOAP is, preparing a Transitional Year–focused ERAS profile, and approaching Match Week with a practical, flexible strategy, you significantly improve your chance of landing a strong intern year. Whether you secure a transitional year, a prelim position, or need to re-strategize for a future cycle, thorough SOAP preparation positions you to move forward in your medical career with clarity and resilience.