How to Help a Busy Attending Write You a Powerful, Specific LOR

The usual way students ask for letters of recommendation almost guarantees a generic, forgettable letter. You can fix that. And you do it by doing most of the heavy lifting for your busy attending without making it awkward or pushy.

You are not “bothering” them. You are managing a professional process they frankly do not have time to manage well on their own.

Let me walk you through how to turn “Sure, I’ll write you a letter” into a powerful, specific LOR that actually moves the needle on your residency application.

---

Step 1: Choose the Right Attending (and Know When to Walk Away)

Do not start by thinking, “Who is the biggest name?” Start with, “Who has actually seen me work and will say I am excellent?”

A powerful letter needs:

1. Direct observation
2. Genuine enthusiasm
3. Concrete stories

If an attending barely saw you, has no clue who you are, or kept confusing your name, that is a bad letter waiting to happen.

You want someone who:

• Rounded with you frequently (not just once or twice)
• Gave you feedback or teaching
• Saw you in challenging situations: nights, codes, difficult patients, new consults, family meetings
• Has at least one moment they could remember if prompted (“You handled that angry family very well”)

Red flags that they are the wrong choice:

• They consistently mispronounce or forget your name
• You mostly interacted with their fellow and not them
• They never saw you present, write notes, call consults, or talk to patients
• Their feedback to everyone is, “You’re doing fine”

If that is your only option, fine. But if you have a choice, pick the person who actually saw you in the trenches.

---

Step 2: Ask the Right Way: “Strong and Specific”

You are not asking, “Can you write me a letter?” That is too vague. You are asking, “Can you write me a strong and specific letter of recommendation?”

Yes, literally use those words. They matter.

Here is a template you can adapt for an in-person ask (best) or Zoom/phone:

“Dr. Smith, I have really appreciated working with you on this rotation, and I am applying into internal medicine this cycle. I was wondering if you would feel comfortable writing a strong and specific letter of recommendation for my residency applications?”

Then stop talking. Let them respond.

You are listening for one of three things:

1. Clear yes with enthusiasm
   “Absolutely, you were great. I’d be happy to.”
   → This is what you want.

2. Hesitant yes
   “Uh, sure, I can do that,” said with no eye contact, or “Remind me what specialty again?”
   → Proceed with caution. You will need to support them a lot with details.

3. Soft no
   “I do not know if I got to know you well enough,” or “I think Dr. Lee might be a better person to ask.”
   → Thank them and back out gracefully. You just dodged a weak letter.

Your line if they hedge:

“Thank you for being honest. I really appreciate that. I will reach out to someone who worked more closely with me.”

No drama. No convincing. You do not want a lukewarm letter anywhere near ERAS.

---

Step 3: Offer a “Letter Packet” Up Front (So They Don’t Have to Chase You)

Here is where you separate yourself from 90% of applicants.

The moment they say yes, you reply with something like:

“Thank you very much. I will email you a short packet with my CV, personal statement draft, and a one-page summary of my work on your service to make this as easy as possible for you.”

You are signaling three things:

• You are organized.
• You respect their time.
• You are going to make writing this letter painless.

What goes in your “Letter Packet”

Keep it tight. Busy attendings will not read a novel.

Include:

1. Brief cover email (not an essay)
2. CV (1–2 pages)
3. Personal statement draft (or at least a solid outline)
4. One-page “LOR support sheet” customized for that attending
5. ERAS/NRMP details + deadlines

You can assemble this once, then lightly tweak for each attending.

---

Step 4: Write a Ruthlessly Useful Support Sheet

This is the part most students screw up. Either they do nothing, or they send a vague “brag sheet” that is useless.

Your attending needs two things to write a strong, specific letter:

• Reminders of what they saw.
• Language and themes that match your application narrative.

You give them both in one page. Not three. One.

Here is the structure that works.

A. Header with key info

At the top:

• Your full name
• Email + phone
• ERAS AAMC ID
• Specialty you are applying to
• How you worked together (e.g., “Sub-I on inpatient cardiology, July 2025”)
• Letter deadline (bolded)

Example:

John Nguyen, MS4 – IM Residency Applicant
ERAS AAMC ID: 87654321 | john.nguyen@medschool.edu | (555) 123-4567
Worked together: Inpatient Cardiology Sub-I, July 2025, University Hospital
Requested LOR deadline: August 25, 2025

B. 3–5 bullet points: what they directly saw you do

These must be concrete, not vague buzzwords.

Bad: “Hard worker, team player, compassionate.”

Good examples:

• “Took primary responsibility for 6–8 patients daily, pre-rounded independently, and presented concise, problem-based plans at 7 a.m. rounds.”
• “Handled two new admissions overnight with limited supervision, including a patient with decompensated heart failure; organized data, called cardiology fellow appropriately, and presented clearly the next morning.”
• “Led a difficult goals-of-care conversation with an elderly patient’s daughter, demonstrating empathy while clearly explaining prognosis and options.”

Write these as reminders. Your attending will grab, reword, and expand them. That is exactly what you want.

C. Traits you hope they will emphasize (3–5 max)

Think about what matters in your specialty and your own narrative. Then give them a menu.

Example for Internal Medicine:

• Clinical reasoning / problem-solving
• Ownership of patient care
• Communication with patients & families
• Reliability and follow-through
• Teamwork and teaching junior learners

Example blurb:

“If you feel these are accurate, traits that would be especially helpful to highlight for my internal medicine applications include: clinical reasoning, ownership of patient care, communication with patients/families, and reliability.”

You are not telling them what to say. You are letting them know where your application is aiming.

D. How this letter fits your overall story

Two or three lines:

• Why you chose this specialty
• How this rotation/attending’s field fits that
• What role you hope their letter will play

Example:

“My application focuses on my interest in complex inpatient medicine and longitudinal care of patients with cardiovascular disease. Your letter will be one of my primary clinical IM letters and will help programs understand how I function as a near-intern in a high-acuity setting.”

That gives them context. They know they are not just “filling a slot,” but anchoring a specific part of your narrative.

---

Step 5: Script the Ask Email So They Barely Have to Think

Here is a sample email you can adapt. Keep it short, clean, and decisive.

---

Subject: LOR for [Your Name] – [Specialty] Residency, [Deadline]

Dear Dr. Smith,

Thank you again for agreeing to write a strong and specific letter of recommendation for my internal medicine residency applications. I very much appreciated working with you on the inpatient cardiology service in July.

I have attached:
– My CV (1 page)
– My current personal statement draft
– A one-page summary of my work on your service and the qualities I hope to highlight

The letter can be uploaded directly to ERAS using the link you will receive from the system once I enter your information. The target deadline I am aiming for is August 25, 2025, to ensure the letter is in by the time programs begin reviewing applications.

Please let me know if there is any additional information that would be helpful.

Sincerely,
[Your Full Name], MS4
[Medical School Name]
ERAS AAMC ID: [########]

---

Two details people forget:

• Clear deadline (earlier than ERAS open date by at least 1–2 weeks)
• How the letter is submitted (ERAS uploads, not email attachments)

If you have multiple letters, track them in a simple table so you do not lose control of who has what and when.

Attending	Specialty of Letter	Date Asked	Deadline	Packet Sent	Letter Received
Dr. Smith	Internal Medicine	Jul 10	Aug 25	Jul 10	Yes
Dr. Patel	Cardiology	Jul 15	Sep 1	Jul 15	Pending
Dr. Rodriguez	Emergency Medicine	Aug 1	Sep 10	Aug 1	Pending

---

Step 6: Give Them Specific Stories to Steal

Attendings are not sitting around with detailed memory logs of every student. You have to jog their memory. Explicitly.

In your support sheet or in a second short attachment, include a section called:

Examples of clinical encounters you may recall

Then list 2–4 bullets like this:

• “Patient with STEMI and cardiogenic shock (Mr. J., late 60s) – I helped stabilize him in the ED, obtained collateral history from his wife, and presented an initial management plan that we refined on rounds.”
• “New diagnosis of heart failure in a 40-year-old woman – I performed the initial H&P, did the first goals-of-care discussion regarding lifestyle changes and medication adherence, and coordinated follow-up with primary care and cardiology clinic.”
• “Complex discharge planning – Patient with multiple readmissions for CHF who lived alone with limited support; I arranged PT/OT evaluation, social work involvement, and collaborated on a safe discharge plan with close follow-up.”

That kind of detail is gold for them. They will not copy-paste, but it will snap their memory into place. Suddenly they can write:

“One memorable encounter involved a patient with cardiogenic shock, where [Student] took the initiative to obtain a thorough collateral history and present a clear initial plan. I remember being struck by how calmly and systematically he approached a high-stress situation.”

That is exactly the kind of sentence you are trying to make possible.

---

Step 7: Align the Letter With Your Overall Application Narrative

You are not just collecting random letters. You are building a coherent story.

Ask yourself:

• What is my main pitch as a residency applicant?
  (Example: Thoughtful, steady clinician with strong inpatient skills and long-term interest in academic IM.)

• What is each letter’s role in supporting that story?
  – Sub-I attending: “Functions like a near-intern, safe and reliable.”
  – Outpatient preceptor: “Great with patients, continuity, communication.”
  – Research mentor: “Intellectually curious, persistent, can finish projects.”

Then you subtly reflect that in the support sheet for each attending.

For example, for your research mentor, your support sheet might emphasize:

• Your role in the project (what you actually did)
• Specific skills: data analysis, literature review, writing, IRB work
• A line like: “Your letter will be particularly helpful in highlighting my ability to carry projects to completion and engage with academic medicine.”

They do not need to see what the other letters will say, but they should understand their lane.

This is how you avoid getting four letters that all say the same generic thing.

---

Step 8: Make It Logistically Frictionless

Busy attendings bail on letters when it becomes a hassle. Remove friction.

1. Confirm how they prefer to receive requests
   Some want the ERAS email trigger first. Some want your packet first. Ask once:
   “Would you like me to start the ERAS request now, or would you prefer I send my materials first and trigger it closer to the deadline?”

2. Send ERAS request the same day you ask (if they are ready)
   Do not wait. The email gets buried if you send it two weeks later.

3. Name your files cleanly

   • Lastname_Firstname_CV.pdf
   • Lastname_Firstname_PersonalStatement.pdf
   • Lastname_Firstname_LOR_Support_Smith.pdf

4. Avoid attachments over 2–3 docs total
   You want them to open, skim, and move on. Not drown in files.

---

Step 9: Follow Up Without Being Annoying

There is a right way to nudge. And there is the “make them regret agreeing” way.

Use this timeline:

• Initial ask: 4–8 weeks before you need the letter
• First reminder: 10–14 days before the deadline
• Second reminder (if needed): 3–5 days before deadline

Sample reminder email (polite but direct):

Subject: Friendly reminder – LOR for [Your Name], [Deadline]

Dear Dr. Smith,

I hope your week is going well. I wanted to send a brief reminder about my internal medicine residency letter of recommendation. ERAS begins reviewing applications soon, and I am aiming to have all my letters uploaded by August 25, 2025.

The ERAS system should have sent you an email with an upload link. If you need this resent or if it would be easier to use a different email, I am happy to update it. I have reattached my CV and support sheet here for convenience.

Thank you again for your support.

Best regards,
[Your Name]

If they still have not uploaded by a few days after the deadline and you already sent two reminders, you have three options:

1. One last short nudge
   • “Just checking in, as programs are starting to review applications.”
2. Activate backup writers
   • This is why you do not rely on a single critical letter.
3. Adjust expectations
   • Some letters will come in late. Annoying, but not catastrophic if your core letters are in.

---

Step 10: Do Not Write Your Own Letter – But You Can Shape It

Some attendings will say something like:

“Why do not you draft something, and I will edit and sign it?”

This is common. It is also a problem.

Program directors can smell a student-written letter. The tone is wrong. The diction is wrong. It often over-sells or hits weird notes.

Here is a better response:

“I appreciate your trust. I would feel more comfortable providing you with detailed notes about my work and specific examples that might be helpful, and leaving the actual wording to you. I have seen programs become wary of student-drafted letters.”

Nine times out of ten, they will agree to that. Then you send an excellent support sheet instead.

If they absolutely insist on you drafting something, you are in a gray zone. You need to:

• Keep it modest and factual
• Use plain language
• Avoid over-the-top praise

But if you have any alternative attendings who can write their own letter, prioritize those.

---

Step 11: After the Match – Close the Loop Like a Professional

This is optional, but it separates the adults from the kids.

After Match Day:

1. Email each letter writer:
   • Tell them where you matched.
   • Thank them specifically for their help.
2. If they had significant impact, a handwritten note does not hurt.

Example:

Dear Dr. Smith,

I wanted to share the good news that I matched at [Program Name] in internal medicine. Your support and the opportunity to work with you on the cardiology service were an important part of my application, and I am very grateful for your time and mentorship.

Thank you again,
[Your Name]

Why do this? Because in a few years you might need a fellowship letter. Or a job recommendation. Or a connection at another program. Relationships outlast ERAS.

---

Visual: From Ask to Upload – A Simple Process Map

LOR Request and Completion Flow

Step	Description
Step 1	Identify Attending
Step 2	Ask in Person Strong & Specific?
Step 3	Attending Agrees
Step 4	Send LOR Packet (CV, PS, Support Sheet)
Step 5	Trigger ERAS Request
Step 6	First Reminder 10-14 days pre-deadline
Step 7	Second Reminder 3-5 days pre-deadline
Step 8	Letter Uploaded
Step 9	Thank You + Match Update

---

What a Powerful Letter Actually Contains

So you know what you are trying to help them create, here is what a strong attending LOR usually includes:

• Clear statement of how they know you and for how long
• Comparison to peers: “Among the top 10% of students I have worked with in the last 5 years”
• Specific examples of:
  • Clinical reasoning
  • Work ethic and reliability
  • Communication with patients/families
  • Teamwork and professionalism
• Concrete language rather than vague adjectives
  (“He independently managed 6 patients and presented well-organized plans” beats “He is very smart.”)
• A firm, unambiguous endorsement at the end
  (“I recommend her without reservation.”)

You are not writing those words. You are supplying the raw material.

---

Common Mistakes That Sink Otherwise Good Letters

Quick list so you can avoid them:

• Waiting until 1–2 weeks before ERAS opens to ask for letters
• Asking via a casual hallway comment and never following up in writing
• Sending a 7-page packet no one will read
• Forgetting to include ERAS ID, specialty, or deadline in your email
• Asking people who barely worked with you because they are “famous”
• Never clarifying “strong and specific” when you ask
• Not giving any examples or reminders from the rotation
• Failing to send polite reminders, then panicking at the last minute

Each of these is fixable. Most are fixed by being the organized one who respects how busy your attendings really are.

---

Quick Reality Check: Why This Works

Program directors read hundreds of letters. The majority blend together:

“Hardworking, compassionate, pleasure to work with, will be an asset to your program.”

That might as well be white noise.

When you help an attending remember specific incidents, they naturally write sentences that stand out:

• “He anticipated patient needs by pre-emptively arranging PT/OT and family meetings.”
• “She voluntarily stayed late to ensure a safe and well-coordinated discharge.”
• “He handled a difficult conversation with a grieving family with maturity beyond his training level.”

And when they see that across multiple letters, with consistent themes, your application stops being a stack of documents and starts being a coherent picture of a resident they can trust.

---

FAQ

1. How many letters should I help in this level of detail? It seems like a lot of work.
Do this properly for every letter that actually matters to your application. For most residency applicants, that is 3–4 core letters:

• 2–3 specialty-specific clinical letters (sub-I, clerkship, elective)
• 1 additional letter (research, another clinical, or a strong non-core rotation)

You can build one master CV and personal statement, then make short, customized support sheets (one page each) for every attending. The first one takes the longest. After that, you are changing 20–30% of the content each time. Call it an hour per attending. That hour can translate directly into a letter that shapes how PDs see you.

---

2. What if an attending agrees but still writes a weak or generic letter despite my packet?
It happens. Some people are just bad letter writers. Protect yourself upfront by:

• Asking explicitly for a “strong and specific” letter
• Watching their reaction when you ask
• Prioritizing attendings who gave you meaningful feedback and know you better

If you suspect a letter might be weak, do not make it your only letter from that role. For example, if your IM sub-I attending seemed lukewarm, also get a letter from your core IM clerkship attendings or another inpatient rotation. You usually do not see the letter, so the only real control point is before you ask, not after. Your job is to stack the odds with the right person and give them excellent raw material. The rest is out of your hands.

---

Open your email right now and draft the exact message you will send the first attending on your list, including your deadline and the promise of a one-page support sheet. Then set a calendar reminder for when that letter absolutely must be requested.