Guiding DO Graduates: Strategic Residency Selection for Emergency Medicine

Understanding the Landscape: EM Match for DO Graduates

Emergency Medicine (EM) remains a highly desirable specialty, and the unified ACGME system has reshaped the path for DO graduates. As a DO graduate, you can absolutely match into an excellent emergency medicine residency, but your program selection strategy matters more than ever.

Several realities for DO applicants in the EM match:

• Competition has tightened: More MD and DO applicants are applying broadly to EM.
• Program composition varies: Some programs are historically DO-friendly, others remain predominantly MD.
• Step/Level scores and SLOEs matter: EM is still heavily driven by standardized metrics and specialty-specific evaluations.
• Geography and program type influence your competitiveness and experience.

A smart approach to selecting and ranking programs can dramatically increase your chance of success. This article walks you through how to choose residency programs strategically, estimate how many programs to apply to, and tailor your emergency medicine residency list as a DO graduate.

---

Step 1: Clarify Your Applicant Profile (Honest Self-Assessment)

Before you build a list, you need a realistic understanding of your competitiveness in the osteopathic residency match for EM.

Key elements to assess:

1. Objective Metrics

• USMLE Step 1/2 CK and/or COMLEX Level 1/2 CE
  • Strong: Step 2 CK ≥ 245 or Level 2 CE ≥ ~620
  • Solid: Step 2 CK 230–244 or Level 2 CE ~580–619
  • At-risk: Step 2 CK < 230 or Level 2 CE < ~580, or any failures
• Exam failures or repeats
  • One or more failures increase risk; program list should be broader and more DO-friendly.

2. EM-Relevant Evaluations

• SLOEs (Standardized Letters of Evaluation)
  For emergency medicine residency, SLOEs are arguably as important as scores.
  • Number: Aim for 2–3 SLOEs from EM rotations (preferably ACGME-accredited academic sites).
  • Quality: Comments about work ethic, clinical reasoning, and teamwork are critical.
  • Global assessment ranking: “Top 10%” and “Outstanding” help significantly.

3. EM Clinical Experience

• Core EM rotations at academic centers
• Audition rotations / away rotations at sites where you’d like to match (or where you need SLOEs).
• Procedural and ED exposure: Strong experiences and clear narratives from your rotations help your application stand out.

4. DO-Specific Factors

As a DO graduate, consider:

• Did you take USMLE in addition to COMLEX?
  • Programs vary in their comfort with COMLEX-only scores.
  • Some academic EM programs strongly prefer or require USMLE.
• Your school’s history of matching DO graduates into EM
  • Talk to your EM advisor or student affairs office for match outcomes.
• Whether you have osteopathic-specific strengths to highlight:
  • OMT in the ED
  • Whole-person, systems-based care perspective
  • Leadership in osteopathic organizations

5. Personal and Geographic Constraints

Be honest about:

• Must-have geographic locations (family, partner’s job, visa issues).
• Willingness to relocate to less competitive regions.
• Flexibility in urban vs. suburban vs. rural settings.

This self-assessment will drive your program selection strategy and help you answer the crucial question: How many programs to apply to, and which ones?

---

Step 2: Determining How Many Programs to Apply To (For a DO in EM)

The number of applications is a strategic decision—too few is risky, too many can be wasteful and dilute your efforts.

General EM Benchmarks (for DO Graduates)

For a DO graduate applying to emergency medicine residency programs:

• Highly competitive profile

  • Strong scores (Step 2 CK ≥ 245 or Level 2 ≥ 620), no failures
  • 2–3 strong SLOEs from academic EM rotations
  • Solid clinical narrative and some research or leadership
  • Recommended range: ~25–35 EM programs

• Average / solid profile

  • Step 2 CK 230–244 or Level 2 ~580–619
  • 2 EM SLOEs, no red flags
  • Some involvement but maybe less research
  • Recommended range: ~35–50 EM programs

• At-risk / more challenging profile

  • Lower scores, exam failure, weaker SLOEs, or late decision to pursue EM
  • Limited EM rotation access or fewer SLOEs
  • Recommended range: ~50–65 EM programs, plus a carefully planned backup strategy

These are ballpark estimates, not rigid rules. Use them as a starting point, then adjust based on your:

• Geographic constraints (fewer regions = need more applications).
• Number of SLOEs (fewer SLOEs = you may need to cast a wider net).
• Flexibility in program type (academic vs. community vs. hybrid).

How DO Status Influences “How Many Programs to Apply To”

As a DO, you should:

• Broadly prioritize DO-friendly and COMLEX-friendly programs.
• Add extra programs in regions or institutions known to be less familiar with COMLEX.
• Consider expanding beyond just your dream cities; some high-quality EM training happens in mid-sized or less competitive markets.

If you’re only applying to “top 20” urban academic programs, you will likely need to apply to more programs and accept a higher risk—even with strong metrics.

---

Step 3: Building an Initial List – Program Selection Strategy Fundamentals

Start with a large “long list” of emergency medicine residency programs, then refine.

1. Use Multiple Data Sources

To find programs:

• FREIDA (AMA) – filter by specialty, state, visa status, etc.
• ERAS Program Directory – check requirements (USMLE vs COMLEX, SLOEs, number of letters).
• Program websites – look for:
  • Current resident list (MD/DO mix)
  • Sample schedules
  • EM faculty composition
  • Mission/values and patient population
• EMRA/SAEM resources – some maintain lists or guidance on EM programs.

2. Identify DO-Friendly Programs

For a DO graduate residency strategy, prioritize programs that:

• List COMLEX scores as acceptable or equivalent to USMLE on their websites or ERAS pages.
• Show a visible DO presence in current or recent resident classes.
• Are affiliated with or have a history of recruiting from DO schools.
• Have former DO chiefs, faculty, or program leadership.

Ask upperclassmen or recent graduates from your DO school:

• Where did DO grads match in EM recently?
• Which programs seemed genuinely DO-friendly vs. “technically open but rarely interview DOs”?

3. Filter by Basic Eligibility

Eliminate programs where you clearly don’t meet requirements:

• Programs that require USMLE if you are COMLEX-only.
• Programs that set hard score cutoffs above your metrics.
• Programs that explicitly do not sponsor visas if you require one.
• 4-year EM programs if you are strongly committed to 3-year only (or vice versa, if that’s a deal-breaker).

This first pass may still leave you with 70–120 programs. That’s your starting pool.

---

Step 4: Strategic Tiers – How to Choose Residency Programs Wisely

Now refine your long list into tiers. This is the heart of your program selection strategy: creating a realistic, balanced mix of programs where you can earn interviews and ultimately match.

1. Categorize Programs into Tiers

Use your self-assessment to create:

• Reach Programs

  • Programs where your scores are below their typical averages or their reputation is top-tier.
  • Historically more competitive locations (major coastal cities, “name-brand” academic centers).
  • Programs with few DOs but strong training that you’d love to attend.

• Target (Realistic) Programs

  • Programs where your metrics are close to or slightly above their average.
  • Programs with a track record of taking DOs.
  • A mix of academic, community, and hybrid settings in flexible geographies.

• Safety Programs

  • Programs where you’re clearly above their typical applicant profile.
  • More DO representation, smaller markets, or lesser-known names.
  • Often community or hybrid EM programs in less saturated regions.

A healthy list might look like:

• 20–25% Reach
• 50–60% Target
• 20–25% Safety

For a DO graduate, err toward more Target and Safety programs than a comparable MD applicant, especially if:

• You are COMLEX-only.
• You have any academic red flags.
• You have narrow geographic preferences.

2. Weigh Key Fit Factors

When deciding how to choose residency programs to keep on your final list, consider:

a. Geographic and Lifestyle Fit

• Proximity to family or support systems.
• Urban vs. suburban vs. rural environment.
• Cost of living and resident salary.
• Climate, commute, and regional culture.

b. Program Structure and Training Style

• 3-year vs. 4-year emergency medicine residency:
  • 3-year: faster to attending salary; still standard for many EM careers.
  • 4-year: more leadership, teaching, research, or niche training time.
• Volume and acuity of patients:
  • High-volume trauma centers vs. balanced community exposure.
• Procedural opportunities:
  • Airway, ultrasound, critical care, pediatric EM, toxicology exposure.

c. DO Culture and Support

• DO representation in each resident class.
• EM faculty who are DOs (role models, mentors).
• Openness to osteopathic principles and OMT if that’s part of your identity.

d. Academic and Career Goals

• Interest in fellowship (EMS, ultrasound, critical care, peds EM, toxicology, etc.).
• Desire for academic vs. community career.
• Research infrastructure and mentorship.

Each of these helps you rank programs within tiers and decide which ones deserve an application—even if they are not big-name institutions.

---

Step 5: Aligning Your List with the EM Match Reality

To create a truly effective program selection strategy, you must pair your list with realistic expectations about the EM match process.

1. Interview Yield Considerations

Not all applications produce interviews equally. Your interview yield will depend on:

• Strength and number of SLOEs.
• Score profile and any red flags.
• How DO-friendly your chosen programs are.
• Your geographic clustering strategy (programs sometimes share applicant impressions regionally).

A typical strong DO EM applicant might:

• Apply to 35–45 programs
• Receive 12–18 interview invites
• Rank 10–14 programs

A more at-risk DO applicant might:

• Apply to 50–65 programs
• Receive 8–12 interviews
• Rank 7–10 programs

More interviews generally improve your match odds, but even 8–10 interviews can be enough for a reasonable chance at matching in EM, assuming your rank list is honest and not overly top-heavy.

2. Using EM Advising Resources

Use school-based and external advising:

• Your home EM advisor or clerkship director

  • Ask them to review your scores, SLOEs, and CV.
  • Get input on approximate competitiveness and recommended number of applications.
  • Request suggestions for DO-friendly programs regionally.

• EMRA/ACEP student sections

  • Webinars or match guides specific to EM.
  • Peer mentoring or near-peer advice from recent DO grads.

• Program-specific outreach (carefully)

  • If invited, participate in open houses or virtual Q&A events.
  • Use these sessions to understand DO-friendliness and culture—not to “sell yourself.”

3. Crafting a Backup Strategy (If Needed)

If you have significant red flags or are applying late to EM, you may need:

• A dual-application strategy to another specialty (e.g., IM, FM, transitional year).
• Honest discussion with mentors about risk tolerance.
• Clear “Plan B” if the EM match doesn’t go as hoped.

This does not apply to every DO applicant—but if it might apply to you, incorporate it early rather than waiting until January.

---

Step 6: Practical Workflow for Building and Finalizing Your List

Here’s a structured approach you can follow over 1–2 weeks:

Step 6.1 – Long List Creation (Day 1–3)

• Export or list all EM programs from FREIDA/ERAS.
• Remove programs that:
  • Do not accept DOs.
  • Require USMLE you don’t have.
  • Clearly state COMLEX not accepted.
• Flag programs with:
  • Visible DO residents or DO-friendly language.
  • Locations you’d be comfortable living in.

You may end with 60–120 potential programs.

Step 6.2 – Tiering and Research (Day 4–7)

For each program, create a spreadsheet with columns like:

• State/City
• Program type (Academic/Community/Hybrid)
• 3-year or 4-year
• DO presence (Low/Medium/High)
• Score requirement (if given)
• Visa policy (if relevant)
• Category (Reach/Target/Safety)
• Personal interest rating (1–5)

Then:

1. Use SLOEs, scores, and program reputation to assign tiers.
2. Remove:
   • Reach programs where your profile is far below typical range AND little DO presence.
   • Locations you truly cannot see yourself in.

Aim to land in your target range:

• 25–35 programs (highly competitive DO)
• 35–50 programs (average DO)
• 50–65 programs (at-risk DO)

Step 6.3 – Advisor Review (Day 7–10)

• Share your spreadsheet with:
  • EM advisor
  • Dean’s office or career advisor
  • Trusted residents/recent grads
• Ask:
  • “Which programs are unrealistic given my profile?”
  • “Which additional DO-friendly programs should I add?”
  • “Am I over-weighting any one geographic region?”

Adjust your list based on their feedback.

Step 6.4 – Final Check: Strategic Balance

Before you submit:

• Re-count your tiers:
  • Are at least 50–60% Target?
  • Do you have a meaningful Safety tier (especially as a DO)?
• Review DO representation:
  • Is at least half your list composed of programs with current or recent DO residents?
• Confirm program requirements:
  • Number of letters and SLOEs.
  • Score acceptance policies (COMLEX vs USMLE).
  • Any specific supplemental questions you need to prepare for.

Once this is done, you’ll have a conscious, data-driven program selection strategy tailored to your DO background and EM goals.

---

Step 7: Common Strategic Mistakes DO Applicants Make (and How to Avoid Them)

Mistake 1: Applying Almost Exclusively to “Big Name” Academic Programs

Issue: Many of these programs:

• Are in highly competitive cities.
• Have numerous MD applicants with similar or stronger metrics.
• May be less familiar with COMLEX-only applicants.

Fix:

• Limit these Reach programs to a modest percentage of your list.
• Balance them with solid Target and DO-friendly Safety programs in less saturated regions.

Mistake 2: Ignoring Program Culture Toward DOs

Issue: A program might say they “accept DOs,” yet have matched zero DO residents in the last 3–5 years.

Fix:

• Look at current resident rosters.
• Ask advisors about hidden reputations (e.g., DO-averse or COMLEX-skeptical).
• Favor programs with a track record of DO residents.

Mistake 3: Over-Focusing on One Region

Issue: Restricting your EM match applications to a single state or metro area dramatically lowers your odds, especially as a DO.

Fix:

• Decide on a primary region plus at least one secondary region where you’d be reasonably happy.
• Include a mix of urban and smaller city programs.

Mistake 4: Underestimating the Value of Safety Programs

Issue: Some applicants see Safety programs as “beneath them” and minimize or skip them entirely.

Fix:

• Remember that EM training quality does not always correlate with brand name.
• Community and hybrid programs can provide superb procedural and clinical exposure.
• A solid, supportive program where you match is far better than no match at all.

---

Putting It All Together: A Sample Strategy for a DO EM Applicant

Consider a hypothetical DO applicant:

• COMLEX Level 2: 605; Step 2 CK: 236
• Two strong SLOEs from academic EM rotations
• No exam failures
• Wants to be on the East Coast but is open to the Midwest and South
• Values a mix of academic and community settings

A reasonable program selection strategy might be:

• Total EM applications: ~40 programs
  • 8 Reach: major coastal academic centers, some with limited DO presence.
  • 22 Target: DO-friendly academic and hybrid programs in mid-sized cities, East Coast + Midwest.
  • 10 Safety: community or hybrid EM programs with strong DO representation in less competitive regions.

They would:

• Make sure at least half their list includes programs with visible DO residents.
• Include both 3-year and 4-year programs aligned with their goals.
• Work with an EM advisor to validate that the list is realistic and balanced.

This approach protects them from over-risking on prestige while still allowing them to shoot for a few dream programs.

---

FAQs: Program Selection Strategy for DO Graduates in Emergency Medicine

1. As a DO, do I need to take USMLE for emergency medicine residency?

Not strictly, but it helps:

• Many EM programs accept COMLEX-only, especially those with a history of DO residents.
• Some competitive academic programs either prefer or require USMLE, or are less accustomed to interpreting COMLEX.
• Taking USMLE can open more doors and make score comparison easier for PDs.

If you haven’t taken USMLE, focus on:

• Programs explicitly comfortable with COMLEX.
• Strong SLOEs and clinical evaluations.
• A broader, DO-friendly program list.

2. How many EM programs should I apply to as a DO if I’m an average applicant?

For a “solid but not stellar” DO applicant (e.g., Step 2 CK ~230–240 or Level 2 ~580–615, 2 SLOEs, no major red flags), a reasonable range is:

• 35–50 EM residency programs

Within that range, be sure to:

• Prioritize DO-friendly and COMLEX-accepting programs.
• Include a balanced mix of Reach, Target, and Safety options.
• Avoid over-representing just one ultra-competitive region.

3. How can I tell if a program is truly DO-friendly?

Look for multiple signs:

• Current or recent DO residents listed on the website.
• Program materials or ERAS descriptions that explicitly welcome DO applicants.
• Evidence that the program accepts COMLEX scores without requiring USMLE.
• Positive experiences reported by DO graduates from your school or from online forums (taken cautiously).

No single indicator is perfect, but consistent DO presence in multiple resident classes is the strongest sign.

4. Should I include non-EM programs on my rank list as a backup?

This depends on your risk profile:

• If you have major red flags (score failures, very limited EM exposure, late switch to EM), a dual-application strategy (e.g., EM + IM or FM) may be wise.
• If your EM profile is moderate to strong and you’ve applied broadly and strategically, you may be able to single-specialty apply safely.

Discuss this with:

• Your EM advisor
• Dean’s office / career advisor
• Mentors who understand the EM match and your specific situation

Your goal is to balance your desire for EM with the reality of your application strength and personal risk tolerance.

---

By combining an honest self-assessment, DO-aware program research, and a structured approach to how many programs to apply to, you can craft a powerful, realistic program selection strategy for the emergency medicine residency match. As a DO graduate, you bring a valuable perspective to EM—your task is to aim that value at programs ready to recognize it.