Program Selection Strategy for DO Graduates in General Surgery Residency

Understanding the Landscape: DO Graduate in the General Surgery Match

As a DO graduate pursuing general surgery, you’re navigating a competitive and evolving environment. Since the single accreditation system went into full effect, the line between “MD programs” and “DO programs” has blurred, but legacy perceptions and institutional habits still matter—especially in surgical specialties.

Your program selection strategy is one of the most important decisions you’ll make during the residency application process. It determines:

• How many programs you should apply to
• Which types of programs are realistic and strategic
• How to build a balanced list that maximizes your chances of a successful surgery residency match without overextending your time, money, and energy

For a DO graduate targeting general surgery residency, you must think intentionally about the intersection of:

• Your academic profile
• Your osteopathic background (COMLEX vs USMLE, school reputation, letters)
• Program culture and historical track record with DOs
• Geographic and personal constraints

This article breaks down a stepwise program selection strategy designed specifically for DO graduates seeking categorical general surgery positions, with practical numbers, examples, and tools to help you build a smart and realistic application list.

---

Step 1: Honestly Assess Your Profile as a DO Applicant

Before asking how many programs to apply to, you need a clear-eyed understanding of where you stand. Your realistic range of programs—and the size of your list—flows from this assessment.

1. Academic Metrics: COMLEX and/or USMLE

For a general surgery residency, programs often use board scores as an initial screen.

Key considerations:

• Did you take USMLE Step 1 and/or Step 2 CK in addition to COMLEX?

  • Many historically MD-oriented general surgery programs still feel more comfortable interpreting USMLE scores.
  • DOs with both COMLEX and USMLE often have broader access to programs, particularly at larger academic centers.

• Relative strength of your scores:
  While specific numeric cutoffs change by year, practically think about your scores as:

  • Strong: Well above national mean; multiple offers likely at mid-tier programs; some reach programs reasonably in play.
  • Average: Around the mean; competitive at community and some university-affiliated programs; academic powerhouses are true reaches.
  • Below average or with a failure: Need careful list construction, strong clinical performance, and heavier emphasis on DO-friendly and community programs.

If you did not take USMLE, focus on programs that explicitly accept COMLEX-only applicants and have a history of matching DOs.

2. Clinical Performance and Clerkship Honors

General surgery programs heavily weight:

• Performance in core surgery rotations
• Sub-internships (sub-Is) or audition rotations in surgery
• Letters from surgeons who know you well

A DO applicant with:

• Honors in surgery, strong evaluations, and robust letters can offset slightly weaker scores.
• Average or mixed evaluations should emphasize programs that value holistic review and academic improvement over time.

3. Research, Leadership, and Fit for Academic vs Community Programs

• Research-heavy academic centers in major cities often prioritize applicants with:

  • Multiple publications (especially surgical)
  • Research years or substantial projects
  • Strong letters from academic surgeons

• Community or hybrid programs may place more emphasis on:

  • Work ethic and clinical performance
  • Strong team communication
  • Reliability in the OR and wards

As a DO, if your research is limited, it doesn’t exclude you from surgery, but it does suggest targeting more community and hybrid programs rather than only elite academic institutions.

4. DO-Specific Considerations

Factors particularly relevant to a DO graduate residency applicant:

• Does your osteopathic school have a track record of matching into general surgery?
• Do your mentors and advisors have connections with surgery programs willing to advocate for you?
• Have you done away rotations at institutions with historically DO-friendly surgery departments?

The more aligned your experience is with surgery and the more “visible” you are to programs, the stronger your candidacy becomes.

---

Step 2: Determine a Target Range for Number of Applications

There is no universal perfect number, but there are rational ranges for how many programs to apply to as a DO in general surgery.

Typical Ranges for DO Applicants in General Surgery

For categorical general surgery, DO applicants often require a larger and more carefully curated program list than their MD counterparts because:

• Some programs still rarely or never interview DOs.
• Some may accept DOs only in preliminary positions, not categorical.

Reasonable target ranges (categorical programs only):

• Stronger DO candidate (good scores, strong clinicals, at least some research, USMLE taken):
  • 35–55 programs
• Average DO candidate (average scores, solid but not exceptional research, COMLEX ± USMLE):
  • 50–70 programs
• Challenged DO candidate (score concerns, red flags, limited research, COMLEX-only):
  • 65–90+ programs, focusing on DO-friendly, community, and smaller programs

These numbers can vary with geography, personal constraints, and goals, but they provide a starting framework.

Don’t Confuse Volume with Strategy

Submitting 100+ applications without a thoughtful program selection strategy is wasteful and emotionally draining. Your goal is not just “more” but better-targeted.

A well-curated list of 60 programs that:

• Have a history of interviewing and matching DOs
• Align with your profile and preferences
• Represent a balanced mix of reach, target, and safety

is far more powerful than 100+ random submissions.

---

Step 3: Build a Tiered Program List (Reach / Target / Safety)

A structured approach will anchor your osteopathic residency match strategy in logic rather than anxiety.

1. Start with Your Ideal Programs

List 5–10 “dream” programs, for example:

• Large academic centers with strong surgical subspecialties
• Programs in highly desirable cities or your home region
• Programs where you’ve done rotations or have strong connections

For a DO, many of these will be reach programs, especially if the program matches few or no DOs historically. It’s still reasonable to apply to some, but they shouldn’t dominate your list.

2. Define Your Core “Target” Programs

These are programs where:

• Your academic metrics align with their residents’ profiles
• They regularly interview and match DOs
• The geographic and lifestyle factors fit your needs

Target programs often include:

• Solid mid-tier university-affiliated programs
• Regional academic/community hybrids
• Larger community programs with strong operative volume

For a general surgery residency match as a DO, most of your applications should fall into this target category.

3. Identify Realistic “Safety” Programs

No program is a true “safety” in general surgery, especially for DO applicants, but relatively safer programs might be:

• Community-based programs in less competitive geographic areas
• Programs previously accredited by AOA (legacy osteopathic programs)
• Smaller or newer programs actively trying to grow their applicant pool

These programs should:

• Explicitly consider DOs
• Show a clear track record of matching DOs
• Not have score cutoffs beyond your range

A balanced program list might look like this for an average DO applicant applying to 60 programs:

• 10–15 reach programs
• 30–35 target programs
• 10–15 safety programs

---

Step 4: Researching Programs with a DO-Friendly Lens

Strategically selecting programs means going deeper than name recognition. As a DO, you must ask: Will this program realistically consider me?

1. Use Data to Identify DO-Friendly Programs

Key data sources:

• Program websites

  • Look at the current residents’ bios:
    • How many DOs are in each class?
    • Do DOs appear regularly or rarely?
  • Confirm whether they explicitly state: “We accept COMLEX” or “USMLE required/recommended.”

• FREIDA and Residency Explorer (where available)

  • Some tools provide insights into the percentage of DOs, score ranges, and prior match outcomes.

• Your school’s match list and alumni network

  • Where have previous DO graduates matched in general surgery?
  • Can you connect with them for unfiltered perspectives on program culture and DO acceptance?

Prioritize programs that consistently have DO residents in their categorical surgery spots.

2. Assess Program Attitude Toward DOs

Red flags for DO applicants:

• Program rosters with 0 DOs over many years
• Websites or documents explicitly stating “USMLE required” when you are COMLEX-only
• PD or coordinator statements (from Q&A, open houses) suggesting they “rarely” or “never” consider DOs for categorical slots

Positive signs:

• Several DOs in each PGY level
• PD or faculty with a DO background
• Explicitly DO-inclusive wording during open houses or recruitment events
• Programs familiar with your osteopathic school

3. Consider Program Type and Structure

When thinking about how to choose residency programs, stratify by type:

• Academic University Programs:

  • Pros: Research, subspecialty exposure, prestige
  • Cons: Often more competitive; some may be hesitant with DO applicants without strong USMLE scores

• University-Affiliated Community Programs:

  • Pros: Good balance of operative volume and academic exposure
  • Often more open to DOs, especially if prior DO graduates have excelled

• Community Programs:

  • Pros: High operative volume, earlier hands-on experience, often more DO-inclusive
  • Best yield for many DO applicants, especially without major research background

As a DO graduate targeting general surgery, your program selection strategy should lean heavily on university-affiliated and community-based programs where DOs are well-represented.

---

Step 5: Integrating Geography, Lifestyle, and Personal Priorities

Your application strategy isn’t purely academic. Geographic and lifestyle priorities matter—but they must be balanced with realism.

1. Geographic Flexibility = More Options

In general surgery, particularly for DOs:

• If you limit yourself to one or two major cities (e.g., only New York City or only California coastal programs), your match risk increases substantially.
• Being open to:
  • Mid-sized cities
  • The Midwest, South, or less competitive regions
  • Newer or smaller programs

dramatically increases your odds of matching.

If you have geographic constraints (family, partner, visas), compensate by:

• Applying to more programs in that region
• Including a diverse mix of program types in that area
• Maximizing connections via away rotations and networking

2. Personal Fit: Operative Volume, Fellowship Opportunities, Culture

Factors to consider when evaluating how to choose residency programs beyond just name and location:

• Case volume and autonomy

  • Do senior residents get robust operative experience?
  • How early do interns get into the OR in a meaningful way?

• Fellowship pathways

  • Do graduates match into fellowships you might be interested in (trauma, MIS, vascular, etc.)?
  • Some DO-friendly community programs still have excellent fellowship outcomes.

• Program culture

  • Resident cohesion and support
  • How leadership treats trainees
  • Work-life balance (as much as possible in surgery)

Create a simple spreadsheet where you rate each program (1–5) on:

• DO-friendliness
• Geographic acceptability
• Training quality/operative volume
• Culture (based on resident input, interviews, online forums)

Use this to refine your final application list.

---

Step 6: Special Considerations for DOs in General Surgery

1. USMLE vs COMLEX: Strategic Implications

If you are early enough in training to decide:

• For DOs seriously targeting competitive specialties like surgery, taking USMLE Step 2 CK in addition to COMLEX often expands options, especially at historically MD-oriented academic centers.

If you’re already past that decision point:

• COMLEX-only applicants should:
  • Focus more heavily on documented DO-friendly programs
  • Pay attention to programs that explicitly list COMLEX score thresholds
  • Use clinical excellence and strong letters to stand out

2. Value of Away Rotations for DO Applicants

Away rotations can be especially beneficial for DO applicants in the surgery residency match:

• They allow programs to see you as an individual, not just a DO on paper.
• Strong performance on a surgery sub-I can:
  • Overcome lingering bias or uncertainty
  • Lead to powerful letters of recommendation
  • Convert a “maybe” into an interview or ranking

Strategically choose:

• 1–2 away rotations at programs that:
  • Are DO-friendly or at least DO-open
  • Are realistic target or modest reach programs
  • You would be genuinely happy to rank highly

Avoid spending all your away rotations at ultra-elite programs that rarely take DOs.

3. Backup Planning: Preliminary Positions and Parallel Plans

General surgery is competitive, and even well-qualified DO applicants might face an uncertain path. Consider:

• Whether you’re willing to apply to preliminary surgery positions as a backup.
• Whether you have a parallel specialty in mind (e.g., categorical internal medicine or anesthesia) if you’re strongly risk-averse.

Your decision here should influence:

• How many programs you apply to in general surgery
• How heavily your list leans on safer, DO-friendly options

---

Step 7: Putting It All Together – An Example Strategy

Consider three sample DO general surgery applicants:

Applicant A: Strong DO Candidate

• COMLEX and USMLE both above national mean
• Honors in surgery, strong sub-I performance
• Some research with one publication
• Open geographically, prefers academic/hybrid programs

Strategy:

• Total applications: 40–50 programs
• Mix:
  • 10–12 academic reach programs
  • 20–25 academic/hybrid target programs (many DO-friendly)
  • 8–12 community “safety” programs
• At least one away rotation at a realistic academic target program that has DOs in current residents.

Applicant B: Average DO Candidate

• COMLEX average; USMLE Step 2 CK slightly below mean
• Good but not stellar clinical evaluations
• Minimal research
• Wants East Coast but willing to expand to Midwest and South

Strategy:

• Total applications: 55–70 programs
• Mix:
  • 8–10 reach programs in desired regions (DO-open with some DO residents)
  • 30–35 DO-friendly hybrid and community programs in multiple regions
  • 10–20 community-heavy “safety” programs, including smaller towns
• Prioritizes programs with multiple DOs in residency rosters.

Applicant C: Challenged DO Candidate

• COMLEX below mean, no USMLE
• One exam failure remediated; strong recent performance and letters
• No research
• Needs to stay roughly within a 4–5 state region for family reasons

Strategy:

• Total applications: 70–90+ programs
• Mix:
  • 5–8 reach programs (still worth trying, especially with DOs on roster)
  • 30–40 programs in region that have a consistent DO presence
  • 30–45 community-heavy and smaller programs, including some newly accredited
• Strong backup consideration:
  • Apply to some preliminary surgery positions
  • Consider a smaller parallel list in a less competitive field if risk tolerance is low

---

Actionable Checklist for Your Program Selection Strategy

1. Clarify your profile:

   • Board scores (COMLEX ± USMLE)
   • Clinical performance in surgery
   • Research and letters

2. Decide on a target application range based on your competitiveness:

   • Strong: 35–55 programs
   • Average: 50–70 programs
   • Challenged: 65–90+ programs

3. Create a spreadsheet with columns for:

   • Program name, location, type (academic/hybrid/community)
   • DO presence (number of DOs per class)
   • Board requirements (USMLE vs COMLEX)
   • Personal ratings (fit, geography, DO-friendliness)

4. Classify programs into:

   • Reach
   • Target
   • Safety

5. Verify DO-friendliness:

   • Check current resident rosters
   • Use alumni connections
   • Attend virtual open houses or Q&A sessions

6. Refine your list until:

   • You reach your target number of applications
   • You have a realistic distribution of reach/target/safety programs
   • You are not overconcentrated in hypercompetitive cities or a single region

7. Plan away rotations strategically at realistic target programs with some DO history.

By following this structured approach, you transform the overwhelming question of how many programs to apply to into a deliberate, data-driven program selection strategy tailored to you as a DO graduate targeting general surgery.

---

FAQs: DO Graduate Program Selection Strategy for General Surgery

1. As a DO, do I need to take USMLE to match into general surgery?

No, it’s not mandatory—but it can significantly broaden your options. Many historically MD-oriented programs still rely heavily on USMLE for screening. If you already have strong COMLEX scores and are focusing on DO-friendly or community/hybrid programs, COMLEX-only can still be sufficient. If you’re early in training and serious about academic or highly competitive general surgery programs, taking USMLE Step 2 CK is often advantageous.

2. How many programs should I apply to for general surgery as a DO?

It depends on your competitiveness and constraints, but typical ranges are:

• Strong DO applicants: 35–55 programs
• Average DO applicants: 50–70 programs
• Challenged DO applicants: 65–90+ programs

These numbers refer primarily to categorical general surgery programs. Adjust upward if you have major geographic limitations or downward if you have exceptional metrics and broad flexibility.

3. How can I tell if a program is truly DO-friendly?

Look for:

• Multiple DO residents across several PGY levels
• Program leadership or faculty with DO backgrounds
• Program statements or Q&A indicating they value and welcome DO applicants
• Historical match data from your school or others showing DOs matching there regularly

If a program has no DO residents over many years, it’s less likely (though not impossible) to be DO-friendly, especially for categorical spots.

4. Should I also apply to preliminary surgery positions?

Preliminary positions can be a reasonable backup if:

• You are strongly committed to surgery
• Your application has significant red flags or weaker metrics
• You’re applying in a highly constrained geographic area

However, prelim positions do not guarantee transition to a categorical spot. If you choose this route, do so intentionally and pair it with a realistic evaluation of your long-term goals and willingness to reapply or consider alternative specialties.

---

By approaching program selection with this structured, data-informed mindset, you give yourself the best chance to secure a general surgery residency that values you as a DO graduate and sets you up for a successful surgical career.