Navigating Match Day Results: Essential Steps for Future Residents

Introduction: Making Sense of Match Day Outcomes

Match Day is one of the most intense milestones in medical education. In a single moment, years of exams, clerkships, research, and interviews converge into an outcome that shapes where and how you begin residency training. For some, the result is a dream come true—a top-choice program in a desired specialty. For others, it’s more complicated: an unexpected location, a preliminary year without an advanced position, or not matching at all.

Regardless of your outcome, Match Day is not the end of your story—it’s a critical step in your broader journey of career development as a physician. Understanding what your result means, what options you have, and how to move forward strategically is essential for your personal and professional well-being.

This guide breaks down Match Day outcomes, explains the SOAP process, and outlines practical, step-by-step next moves whether you matched, partially matched, or did not match. Use it as a roadmap to navigate this high-stakes transition thoughtfully and confidently.

---

Understanding Match Day and the NRMP Match Process

How the Residency Match Works

The National Resident Matching Program (NRMP) pairs applicants and residency programs through a computerized algorithm designed to favor applicant preferences. While the process can feel mysterious, the key steps are straightforward:

1. Application Submission via ERAS

   • You build and submit your ERAS application (CV, letters, MSPE, personal statement, etc.) to residency programs.
   • Programs review applications and issue interview invitations.

2. Residency Interviews

   • You meet with program leadership, faculty, and often residents.
   • Programs assess your fit, clinical potential, professionalism, and alignment with their mission.
   • You evaluate culture, training quality, geographic fit, and lifestyle.

3. Rank Order Lists

   • Applicants rank programs in order of preference.
   • Programs rank applicants they are willing to train.
   • Rank lists are confidential—neither side sees the other’s list.

4. The Match Algorithm

   • The NRMP algorithm starts with an applicant’s first-choice program and tries to place them, moving down the rank list as needed.
   • The algorithm is applicant-favoring—your preferences drive the initial attempt to match.

5. Match Week and Match Day

   • Monday of Match Week: You learn whether you matched (but not where).
   • Monday–Thursday: Unmatched or partially matched applicants may participate in the SOAP process.
   • Friday (Match Day): You open your results and see where you matched.

Understanding this structure helps you interpret your outcome more objectively and frame your next steps appropriately.

The Three Main Match Day Outcomes

On Match Day, you will fall into one of the following categories:

1. Matched

   • You obtained a residency position, either:
     • In a categorical program (includes all years of training),
     • In an advanced position (e.g., start PGY-2, needing a separate prelim year), or
     • In a preliminary or transitional year only.
   • This may or may not be your top-choice program or specialty.

2. Partially Matched

   • You matched into one component but not the full pathway, such as:
     • Matched into an advanced position but not a preliminary year, or
     • Matched prelim but not into an advanced specialty (e.g., matched prelim medicine but not neurology or radiology).
   • Your next steps involve securing the missing component.

3. Not Matched

   • You did not obtain any position in the main Match.
   • This is emotionally difficult, but you still have structured options, starting with the SOAP process and extending to reapplication and alternative pathways.

---

If You Matched: Maximizing Your Residency Transition

Matching into residency is a major professional milestone. Once the initial surge of relief and excitement fades, it’s time to shift into preparation mode so you can start strong.

1. Celebrate Intentionally and Process the Moment

You’ve worked incredibly hard to get here. Before diving into logistics:

• Take time to celebrate with family, friends, classmates, or mentors.
• Allow mixed emotions. You may feel joy, surprise, or even disappointment if you didn’t get your top choice or desired city. All of these reactions are valid.
• Avoid immediate comparisons with peers—focus on your path. The “perfect” program is often the one where you grow, not just the one with the biggest name.

2. Establish Early Contact with Your Residency Program

Proactive communication sets a positive tone with your new team:

• Respond promptly to emails from program coordinators.
• Introduce yourself via a brief, professional email if not prompted:
  • Thank them for the opportunity.
  • Express enthusiasm about joining the program.
  • Ask about next steps, key dates, and required paperwork.

Build Connections with Future Colleagues

• Join any WhatsApp, GroupMe, Slack, or email groups for incoming residents.
• Follow your program’s social media accounts (if applicable) to get a feel for culture and events.
• Reach out to current residents (especially interns) for informal insights on:
  • Call schedules
  • Housing recommendations
  • “Hidden curriculum” tips for success in that program

3. Clarify Requirements, Licensure, and Onboarding Tasks

Each residency has its own set of requirements and timelines. Stay organized by creating a checklist.

Key elements:

• State Licensure and Credentialing

  • Determine whether your state requires a training license or any specific exams or forms before starting.
  • Some states take weeks to process applications—start early.

• Institutional Onboarding

  • Background checks, drug screening, and health clearance
  • Occupational health requirements: immunizations, TB testing, fit-testing for N95 masks
  • Mandatory online modules (HIPAA, professionalism, institutional policies)

• Program-Specific Expectations

  • Review the resident handbook and rotation schedule.
  • Understand call structure, vacation policies, and evaluation systems (e.g., milestones, direct observation, in-service exams).
  • Identify any pre-residency courses or certifications, such as:
    • ACLS/BLS or PALS
    • ATLS (for some surgical and EM programs)
    • NIH or GCP training (for research-heavy programs)

4. Plan Your Relocation Strategically

Relocating for residency can be stressful, especially on a tight budget and timeline. A structured approach helps:

Choosing Where to Live

• Consider:
  • Commute time and reliability (traffic patterns, public transit access).
  • Safety and neighborhood feel—ask current residents for candid perspectives.
  • Proximity to hospital if you anticipate frequent or unpredictable call.
• Decide between:
  • Living alone (privacy, quieter post-call rest) vs.
  • Roommates (cost-sharing, built-in support system).

Logistics to Address Early

• Lease timing relative to your start date and orientation.
• Transferring utilities, updating addresses, and setting up internet.
• Getting a local PCP or mental health support if needed—residency is demanding; your health matters.

5. Create a Realistic Financial Plan for Residency

Residency often brings your first consistent paycheck but also new expenses and loan realities.

Key steps:

• Build a starter budget

  • Fixed costs: rent, utilities, car payment or transit, insurance, loan payments.
  • Variable costs: groceries, transportation, professional attire, exams, conferences.
  • Emergency fund, even if small (e.g., 1–2 weeks of essential expenses).

• Review Student Loan Options

  • Consolidation, refinancing (if appropriate), or income-driven repayment plans.
  • Consider Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) if training at a qualifying institution.
  • Speak with a financial counselor at your institution if available.

• Plan for Professional Expenses

  • Licensing fees, exam registrations (e.g., Step 3 or COMLEX Level 3).
  • Board review resources and potential conference travel.

6. Prepare Clinically and Personally for Day One of Residency

You don’t need to know everything before you start, but you can set yourself up for smoother onboarding:

• Refresh Core Knowledge
  • Review common inpatient emergencies and initial management.
  • Brush up on order writing, basic pharmacology, and interpretation of labs and imaging.
• Gather Practical Tools
  • A reliable stethoscope and comfortable footwear.
  • Scrubs, professional attire, ID badge holder, small notepad or digital note app.
• Set Personal Boundaries and Wellness Plans
  • Think proactively about sleep, exercise, nutrition, and mental health.
  • Identify mentors you can turn to if you struggle.

---

If You Didn’t Match: Navigating Disappointment and Next Steps

Not matching is deeply painful—but it is not the end of your path in medicine. Many excellent physicians have faced this scenario and gone on to successful careers. Your focus now is to process the emotions, understand your options, and choose your next steps with intention.

1. Acknowledge the Emotional Impact

Allow space for your feelings:

• You may feel grief, shame, anger, or confusion.
• Avoid making major, irreversible decisions in the first 24–48 hours.
• Lean on trusted people—friends, family, mentors, advisors, mental health professionals.

Importantly: You are more than one algorithmic outcome. Your skills and potential as a physician are not defined by this moment.

2. Understand the SOAP Process and Decide Whether to Participate

The Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) provides a structured opportunity during Match Week for unmatched and partially matched applicants to obtain unfilled residency positions.

SOAP Basics

• Eligibility: Applicants who:
  • Registered for the Match,
  • Are unmatched or partially matched on Monday of Match Week,
  • And are certified as eligible by NRMP.
• ERAS in SOAP Mode:
  • You can apply to a limited number of unfilled programs listed in the NRMP’s SOAP data.
  • You are not allowed to contact programs directly outside of ERAS-approved communication.
• Rounds of Offers:
  • Programs review applications and extend offers in multiple timed rounds.
  • You can only accept one offer at a time.

Strategic SOAP Preparation

If you choose to participate:

• Meet early with your dean’s office, advisors, or a residency director to:
  • Review your prior application.
  • Identify realistic SOAP targets (specialties, program types, locations).
• Update Your Application Materials Quickly:
  • Tailor your personal statement to the SOAP specialty (or more general if applying across several).
  • Refresh your CV with any new experiences or accomplishments.
• Be Flexible:
  • Consider a broader range of specialties and locations than in the main Match.
  • Some applicants use a prelim or transitional position obtained via SOAP as a stepping stone to reapply later.

3. If SOAP Doesn’t Work Out: Exploring Alternatives

If you do not secure a position through SOAP, you still have options. Your path may be less linear, but it can still lead back to residency or to other fulfilling roles in healthcare.

Clinical and Academic Gap Year Strategies

• Research Fellowships or Clinical Research Positions

  • Especially useful if you’re reapplying to competitive specialties.
  • Allows you to strengthen your CV, build mentorship relationships, and produce scholarly work.

• Postgraduate Clinical Roles

  • Examples: clinical research coordinator, medical scribe, hospital quality improvement roles.
  • For some international graduates, observerships or externships can maintain clinical exposure.

• Public Health or Policy Roles

  • Positions in local health departments, NGOs, or health policy organizations allow you to gain population-level perspectives and build unique skill sets.

International and Non-Traditional Options

• Work abroad (where legally and ethically appropriate) in research, global health, or health education.
• Pursue advanced degrees (MPH, MBA, MS in clinical investigation, etc.) aligned with long-term goals.
• Explore medical education, simulation, or digital health roles.

The goal is not just to “fill time” but to choose experiences that:

• Keep you engaged in medicine or health-related fields,
• Demonstrate growth and maturity, and
• Address specific weaknesses in your original residency application.

4. Reflect Honestly and Create a Reapplication Strategy

If you plan to re-enter the Match in the next cycle, be intentional.

Conduct a Structured Self-Assessment

Examine each component of your application:

• Academic Record: USMLE/COMLEX scores, course/clerkship performance, any professionalism concerns.
• Specialty Choice: Was your chosen specialty appropriately aligned with your credentials and experiences?
• CV and Experiences: Clinical exposure, research, leadership, volunteering.
• Letters of Recommendation: Were they strong, specific, and from appropriate faculty?
• Personal Statement and Interview Skills: Did they clearly articulate your story, motivations, and strengths?

Seek frank feedback from:

• Your dean’s office or student affairs advisors.
• A program director or core faculty member in your target specialty.
• Mentors who can compare your profile to typical successful applicants.

Adjust Your Strategy

Depending on the feedback, consider:

• Broadening specialty choices (e.g., including a less competitive specialty or prelim year).
• Applying to a wider geographic range or more community-based programs.
• Addressing academic gaps (e.g., Step 3, additional clinical electives with strong evaluations).
• Securing new, stronger letters from faculty who know your current work.

Write down a 12-month reapplication plan with specific goals, such as:

• X number of clinical shifts or months in hands-on work.
• Y research abstracts or manuscripts submitted.
• Z new letters of recommendation.

This structured approach turns a painful setback into an opportunity for deliberate career development.

---

Long-Term Career Development Perspective: Match Day Is a Milestone, Not the Final Verdict

In medical education and residency, it’s easy to see Match Day as a pass/fail test of your worth as a future doctor. In reality:

• Many outstanding physicians did not match on their first attempt and later excelled in competitive fellowships and leadership roles.
• Others matched into a specialty or location that was not initially their dream—and discovered a deeply fulfilling career path.
• Career development in medicine is iterative. You will continue to refine your interests through residency, fellowship, and beyond.

Key mindset shifts:

• From “perfect outcome” to “next best step.” Focus less on whether this was your ideal scenario and more on what you can learn and build from here.
• From comparison to collaboration. Your classmates’ successes do not diminish your own potential. Medicine is a team sport.
• From single event to ongoing journey. Match Day is a major waypoint, but clinical performance, professionalism, relationships, and continuous growth ultimately define your career.

Whether you matched, partially matched, or did not match, your path can still align with your values and long-term goals with thoughtful planning, mentorship, resilience, and flexibility.

---

FAQs: Common Questions About Match Day, SOAP, and Next Steps

1. What should I do immediately if I didn’t match on Match Day?

First, give yourself permission to feel your emotions—shock, sadness, or anger are all normal. Then, as soon as you can think clearly:

• Contact your student affairs office or dean to confirm your eligibility and options for SOAP.
• Schedule urgent meetings with mentors or advisors who understand the Match.
• Gather your materials (CV, personal statement, letters) to adjust for SOAP applications.
• Avoid impulsive public announcements or social media posts; protect your privacy while you decide your next steps.

2. How can I best prepare for residency once I’ve matched?

To prepare effectively:

• Communicate early with your program and respond quickly to requests.
• Complete all onboarding tasks (licensure, health forms, modules) ahead of deadlines.
• Arrange housing and finances with a realistic budget in mind.
• Review high-yield clinical topics and common on-call scenarios in your specialty.
• Establish personal wellness strategies, including sleep habits, exercise routines, and support systems.

3. What are my options if I want to reapply for residency next year?

If you plan to reapply:

• Conduct a candid assessment of your previous application with advisors and mentors.
• Identify clear goals to strengthen your profile—research, clinical work, new letters, or improved exam performance.
• Consider whether you should:
  • Reapply to the same specialty with a stronger application,
  • Add a second, less-competitive specialty, or
  • Adjust geographic and program-type preferences.
• Use your gap year purposefully (e.g., research, public health, clinical roles) to demonstrate growth and commitment.

4. How does the SOAP process actually work in practice?

During SOAP:

• The NRMP releases a list of unfilled positions to eligible unmatched or partially matched applicants.
• Through ERAS, you can apply to a limited number of these programs, typically up to 45.
• Programs review applications and may contact you for brief interviews.
• Offers are extended in multiple timed rounds; you may receive, accept, or decline offers during these windows.
• Once you accept an offer, you are committed to that position and exit SOAP.

Your school or advising office usually has detailed SOAP timelines and support systems—use them extensively.

5. What should I consider if I have to relocate for residency?

When relocating:

• Ask current residents about best neighborhoods, average commute times, and safety.
• Compare rent and cost of living to your expected salary and budget realistically.
• Think about transportation: Will you need a car? How is parking at the hospital?
• Consider proximity to:
  • Grocery stores and pharmacies
  • Parks or gyms
  • Childcare or family support (if applicable)
• Start searching early for housing options, and be mindful of lease start dates relative to orientation and your first day.

---

Match Day can feel like the most defining moment of your medical career—but it is only one step in a long and evolving journey in residency and beyond. Whether your envelope brought celebration, surprise, or disappointment, you still have meaningful, actionable paths forward. With clarity, support, and strategic planning, you can turn any Match Day outcome into a foundation for growth and long-term success in medicine.