Anxious About Academic Politics: Can I Teach Without Playing the Game?

Anxious About Academic Politics: Can I Teach Without Playing the Game?

What if loving teaching isn’t enough because you refuse to kiss up, network at fake happy hours, or pretend to be thrilled about committee nonsense?

You’re not crazy for worrying about this. Academic medicine does have politics. Sometimes petty. Sometimes career-breaking. And if you’re the type who just wants to teach, care for patients, and not constantly strategize your “brand” in the department… yeah, it’s scary.

Let me say the thing out loud: you’re afraid that if you don’t play the game, you’ll either:

• Never get hired in an academic role
• Get stuck at the bottom forever
• Be punished for speaking up or not being “charming” to the right people

You’re not the only one thinking this. I’ve watched residents whisper in hallways after grand rounds like, “I love teaching the med students but no way I’m dealing with this promotion committee crap.”

So let’s go straight at the big question:

Can you build a real teaching career in medicine without selling your soul to academic politics?

Short answer: yes, but not the way you’re probably imagining. And not in every environment.

Let’s break it down.

---

What “Playing the Game” Actually Looks Like (And Why It Feels Gross)

First, it helps to name what you’re afraid of. When people say “academic politics,” they usually mean some combo of:

• Acting overly agreeable to senior faculty even when they’re objectively wrong
• Joining useless committees just to be “visible”
• Going to networking events you hate so someone might remember your name at promotion time
• Staying quiet about toxic behavior because “you don’t want to be labeled difficult”
• Pretending to be obsessed with research even if you’d rather just teach

And here’s the worst-case scenario that lives in your head: you spend years doing all that, only to get passed over anyway for someone’s buddy, or someone from a fancier program.

You’re not imagining this. I’ve seen:

• Great teachers who never made associate professor because they “weren’t very strategic”
• A junior faculty member frozen out after calling out a high-volume attending for bad behavior
• Med schools where teaching is praised in speeches and ignored in promotion packets

So no, you’re not ridiculous for being anxious. You’re reacting to real structural problems.

But here’s the nuance: “playing the game” and “being completely powerless” aren’t the only two options.

There’s a middle path.

---

The Hard Truth: Where Politics Matter Most

Some roles basically scream “you must play, or you’re done.”

You’re going to run into more politics if you want to be:

• A tenured/basic science faculty member at a big-name university
• A division chief, program director, clerkship director at a large academic center
• A “triple threat” (research, teaching, admin) in a prestige-obsessed department

These environments are often:

• Hierarchical
• “Who you trained with” obsessed
• Committee-driven

If your dream is: “I want to be full professor at a top-20 institution and avoid all politics,” that combo is… unlikely. Not impossible, but you’d be fighting an uphill battle every step.

But that’s not the only version of “teaching in medicine.”

Let’s look at other lanes.

---

The Quiet Truth: Teaching Jobs With Way Less Politics

Here’s what almost no one tells anxious people like us: there are lots of ways to teach in medicine that don’t require you to worship the academic pyramid.

Think of teaching as an activity, not a rank. You can do a ton of teaching without ever becoming “Professor So-and-so.”

Here are real options where politics are way less suffocating:

1. Community-based clinician educator

You work in a community hospital or large group practice that takes students and residents.

You might:

• Precept medical students in clinic
• Take residents on inpatient rounds
• Teach bedside skills or procedures
• Give noon conference talks

The promotion ladder is usually flatter. Fewer committees, fewer “who’s aligned with which vice chair” games. You’re judged more on: do you show up, do learners like working with you, do you do your job.

Downside: You might not get the fancy academic title. But you’re still teaching. A lot.

2. Affiliate faculty / volunteer clinical faculty

This is one of the best-kept secrets for people who hate politics.

You can be:

• A volunteer clinical instructor / assistant professor through a med school
• Teaching a half-day clinic a week
• Supervising OSCEs, small groups, or anatomy labs
• Precepting in your office as a “teaching site”

You typically:

• Don’t sit on endless committees
• Aren’t forced into research
• Get evaluated mainly on teaching and professionalism

Upside: you get the teaching without living inside the political machine every day.

3. Teaching through CME, workshops, and courses

Not everything has to go through a med school.

You can teach by:

• Giving CME talks at hospitals or conferences
• Running ultrasound or procedure workshops
• Creating online courses for clinicians or students
• Teaching board review courses

These can be independent of any specific institution. You’re working with systems, not owned by them.

4. Health professions education roles outside MD-only tracks

Nurse practitioner programs, PA programs, allied health programs, simulation centers, standardized patient programs — all of these need teachers.

Politics exist everywhere, but the ego and prestige games can be dialed down compared to certain MD departments.

---

Where You Can Draw the Line (And Still Have a Career)

Let’s get real. You’re probably not asking, “Can I 100% avoid all politics forever?” You’re asking:

• “Can I refuse to fake enthusiasm for things I hate?”
• “Can I not go to every glad-handing event?”
• “Can I not suck up to toxic senior people?”

Here’s what you can usually get away with and still be okay:

1. Saying no to obviously useless committees (especially early on), as long as you say yes to something meaningful and visible
2. Opting out of social events that you genuinely can’t stand, as long as you show up prepared and reliable in teaching/clinical settings
3. Not pretending to love research if you aim for a primarily clinician-educator or teaching-oriented job
4. Refusing to back bullies or toxic attendings, even if it means quietly avoiding them instead of going head-on against them from day one

Where you’ll probably need to compromise at least a little:

• Being somewhat collegial with people you don’t love
• Doing a few things that help your annual review look decent (a talk here, a committee there)
• Documenting teaching, getting student evaluations, asking for letters — which can feel like self-promotion even if you’re not a “game player” by nature

It doesn’t mean becoming a fake version of yourself. It means understanding the minimum “cost of entry” for certain environments and deciding what you’re willing to pay.

---

Mapping Paths: Different Teaching Career Types

Here’s a quick comparison to make this less abstract.

Path Type	Politics Level	Research Pressure	Teaching Volume	Title Prestige
Big-name academic, tenure	High	High	Medium	High
Clinician-educator at AMC	Medium-High	Medium	High	Medium-High
Community teaching hospital	Low-Medium	Low	High	Medium
Volunteer/affiliate faculty	Low	Low	Low-Medium	Low-Medium
CME / online / independent	Very Low	None	Variable	Variable

If your anxiety is off the charts at the idea of politics, you probably don’t want to build your whole life around the first row.

You can absolutely shape a career around rows 3–5 and still be a real, impactful teacher.

---

How to Test This Before You Commit Your Whole Life

The worst fear is committing to a path, getting deep into it, and only then realizing, “Oh. This whole thing is a political swamp and I hate it.”

So you test early. You treat this like clinical exposure — but for your career.

Testing Teaching Careers Without Overcommitting

Step	Description
Step 1	Student or Resident
Step 2	Try informal teaching
Step 3	Precept or tutor a small group
Step 4	Keep as side thing only
Step 5	Ask faculty about roles
Step 6	Shadow clinician educator
Step 7	Explore community or CME
Step 8	Consider academic educator track
Step 9	Did you like it?
Step 10	Politics tolerable?

A few low-risk experiments:

• Ask to lead a case-based small group or review session
• Precept MS1/MS2 physical exam or clinical reasoning sessions
• Shadow a clinician-educator at your institution and ask blunt questions like:
  • “What’s the annoying part of your job?”
  • “How much time do you spend in meetings?”
  • “Is promotion heavily political here?”

Then pay attention not only to what they say, but how tired they look talking about it.

---

How to Survive If You Do Enter Academic Medicine

Let’s say you still want an academic title, med school affiliation, residents, the whole thing — but you have zero tolerance for drama.

You’re not doomed. You just need some protective strategies.

Time Allocation for a Clinician-Educator

Category	Value
Clinical Work	55
Teaching	25
Admin/Meetings	15
Research/Scholarship	5

Typical week for a clinician-educator might look like that. Notice: admin and meetings exist — but they don’t have to dominate your life if you choose the right place.

Basic survival rules:

1. Pick your institution very carefully
   During interviews, ask:

   • “How is teaching valued in promotion decisions?”
   • “Can you show me a CV of someone who was promoted mainly on teaching?”
     If they can’t name anyone? Huge red flag.

2. Align with the right people, not all the people
   You don’t need everyone to like you. You need:

   • 1–2 mentors who actually care about teaching
   • A division chief or program director who isn’t threatened by good teachers

3. Do visible, meaningful teaching — and document it
   This is the least political “political move” you can make:

   • Keep a running list of lectures, small groups, workshops
   • Save teaching evaluations
   • Once or twice a year, send an update to your mentor/chief: “Here’s what I’ve been doing in teaching this year.” Short, factual, not braggy.

4. Avoid obvious landmines early on
   Your first 2–3 years are not the moment to:

   • Go to war with the most powerful attending in the department
   • Publicly blast departmental policies on Twitter/X
     You can have values and boundaries without charging headfirst into every battle.

---

If You Hate All of This: Alternatives That Are Still Real Careers

If your chest tightens just reading about committees and promotions, maybe the real answer is:

You don’t need a traditional “academic career” to be a real educator.

You can:

• Work full-time clinically in a community setting
• Precept students a half-day weekly
• Run a simulation or skills workshop a few times a year
• Serve as volunteer faculty with a nearby med school
• Build a small YouTube/online presence teaching core topics to students or residents

You won’t get the same prestige as a full professor at Mass General or Hopkins. But you also won’t sacrifice your sanity living in an environment that constantly makes you feel like you’re failing some invisible political exam.

Impact and prestige are not the same thing. Students remember the attendings who taught them clearly and treated them like humans, not the departmental org chart.

---

One More Fear: “If I Don’t Play, Will I Be Punished?”

This is the ugliest, most honest worry, so let’s say it explicitly.

You might be thinking: “If I don’t play the game — don’t network, don’t flatter, don’t join stupid committees — will they quietly blacklist me? Will I get bad schedules, no promotions, fewer opportunities?”

Sometimes… yes. In certain departments? Absolutely.

But here’s the less depressing angle: that’s data.

If you see that:

• Saying no to a third pointless committee gets you punished
• Teaching excellence is shrugged off
• Promotion decisions are purely about politics

That’s not a sign that you are broken. It’s a sign the environment is.

You are allowed to leave.

You’re not signing a lifelong loyalty contract with any one institution. You can:

• Switch to a different academic center with a better culture
• Move to a community teaching hospital
• Shift to part-time academic, part-time independent teaching

You’re allowed to chase the version of teaching that doesn’t crush you.

---

Simple, Practical Moves You Can Make Right Now

Just to ground this:

• You’re a med student?
  Volunteer to tutor a class below you or lead a review session. Notice if you love that part, regardless of the system around it.

• You’re a resident?
  Ask to give a short teaching talk and request anonymous feedback from students. See what that feels like.

• You’re in fellowship or early attendinghood?
  Ask your program director: “Are there volunteer/affiliate teaching roles with the med school that are mainly clinical/teaching, not heavy research?”

You don’t have to decide your forever plan this year. You just have to collect data on what you love and what you can tolerate.

---

Quick Reality Check: What You Can Have

You can absolutely:

• Teach students and residents regularly
• Make education a core part of your identity as a doctor
• Avoid a ton of the worst academic politics by choosing your environment carefully
• Keep your integrity without being naïve about how institutions work

You probably can’t:

• Work in the most prestige-obsessed, research-heavy environments
• Refuse all visibility, all committees, all networking forever
• Expect promotion and titles in places that fundamentally don’t value teaching

So the real question isn’t “Can I teach without playing any game?” It’s:

“What kind of game am I willing to play, and in what environment, so I can keep teaching without losing myself?”

That’s a much better question. And it has real answers.

---

Teaching Opportunities by Setting

Category	Value
Academic Center	9
Community Hospital	7
Private Practice	4
Online/CME	8

---

FAQ (Exactly 5 Questions)

1. If I hate politics, should I avoid academic medicine completely?
Not automatically. Some academic centers genuinely support clinician-educators and don’t obsess over politics as much. But if you’re deeply conflict-averse and get drained by hierarchy games, you may be happier in a community teaching hospital or as volunteer faculty, where you can teach without making your whole life about the institution.

2. Can I be promoted mainly for teaching, without big research?
At some places, yes — especially where they have formal clinician-educator tracks. But you need to see proof. Ask for CVs of people who were promoted primarily on teaching. If everyone promoted has major grants and 50+ papers, and the “great teachers” are stuck at the bottom, that’s a warning sign.

3. Will saying no to committees or social events ruin my chances?
Saying no to everything will probably hurt you. Saying no to obviously pointless or overloading things, while saying yes to a few strategic, meaningful roles, is usually fine. You don’t need to be at every happy hour, but you do need to be seen as engaged, reliable, and not totally invisible.

4. How do I know if a department is “too political” for me?
Watch how people talk when doors close. Do junior faculty look exhausted and bitter when you ask about promotion? Do they warn you “don’t cross Dr. X”? When you ask how teaching is valued, do they give specifics or just buzzwords? Trust your discomfort. If everyone lowers their voice to talk about leadership, that’s not nothing.

5. What if I start in academic medicine and end up hating the politics?
You’re allowed to leave. You can shift to a community hospital, a hybrid clinical-teaching role, or independent CME/online teaching. The years you spent teaching in academics aren’t wasted — they build your skills and your credibility. You’re not trapped in one system forever unless you decide to be.

---

Key points to keep in your head:

1. You absolutely can build a real medical teaching career without drowning in politics — but you have to pick your setting carefully.
2. You don’t need a big-title academic job to be a meaningful, memorable teacher; community and volunteer roles are very real paths.
3. Your discomfort with “the game” isn’t a flaw; it’s data. Use it to choose places where your love of teaching actually counts.