MS2 to MS4: A Year‑by‑Year Roadmap to Choosing IM vs FM vs Peds

Most students pick IM, FM, or Peds for the wrong reasons—and far too late.

They “liked their third‑year attending,” or they “didn’t hate” a rotation, and suddenly a 30‑year career is riding on a few random weeks. That’s lazy career planning. You can do better.

Here’s a year‑by‑year, month‑by‑month roadmap from early MS2 through MS4 that forces you to test drive Internal Medicine (IM), Family Medicine (FM), and Pediatrics (Peds) in a deliberate way—so by ERAS season you are not guessing. You’re executing.

---

MS2: Lay the Foundation (You’re Choosing Data, Not Just Vibes)

At this point you should set up the decision framework that will guide the next 24 months. You are not “choosing a specialty” yet. You’re deciding how you’re going to decide.

MS2, Fall (Aug–Dec): Define What Actually Matters

During organ systems and Step/Level studying, you should:

1. Build your comparison grid.
   Create a simple document with three columns: IM, FM, Peds. Rows:

   • Typical patient population
   • Inpatient vs outpatient mix
   • Procedures vs cognitive work
   • Continuity vs episodic care
   • Lifestyle (call, nights, weekends)
   • Fellowship options / scope
   • Practice settings (academic, community, rural, FQHC)
   • Breadth vs depth of knowledge

   You will fill this in over 2 years, not today.

2. Start low‑stakes shadowing.
   Two half‑days each—nothing intense, just enough to watch the workflow.

   • IM: Hospitalist service or general IM clinic
   • FM: Community clinic or residency clinic
   • Peds: General peds clinic or inpatient peds

   Watch for:

   • How often they say “I don’t know, let’s look it up” vs “I’ve seen this 100 times”
   • How much time is spent on documentation vs doctor‑ing
   • Whether you like talking to adults, kids, or entire families

3. Start your “specialty journal.”
   After each shadowing session, write 5 bullets:

   • 2 things you liked
   • 2 things you disliked
   • 1 thing that surprised you

   This will be gold when you’re writing personal statements and when your memory magically rewrites history later.

MS2, Spring (Jan–Apr): Use Step Prep to Test Your Brain Style

At this point you should use exam prep as a personality test.

1. Notice what content feels natural.

   • Do you enjoy multi‑system adult medicine vignettes with tons of comorbidities? That’s IM.
   • Do you like “well person + screening + preventive care” questions? Very FM.
   • Do you find peds growth charts, vaccine schedules, and congenital stuff oddly satisfying? That’s your Peds brain waking up.

2. Align early reading with interests.
   When you hit practice questions:

   • Tag “internal medicine‑type” cases that were fun, not just solvable
   • Same with FM (preventive care, chronic disease in clinic context)
   • Same with Peds (development, newborn issues, school‑age problems)

3. Schedule a reality‑check meeting.
   Before dedicated:

   • Meet with an IM generalist, an FM doc, and a general pediatrician
   • Ask each:
     • “What do you like least about your specialty?”
     • “What kind of student should absolutely not go into this?”
     • “If you were choosing again right now, would you pick it again?”

Take notes. If someone hesitates on that last question, highlight it.

MS2, Dedicated (Apr–Jun): Protect Options, Don’t Over‑Commit

Your job here is simple: scores keep all three doors open.

• IM: competitive for the more academic programs, especially if you want cards/crit care later
• FM: more forgiving on scores, but don’t coast just because you “might do FM”
• Peds: some programs are chill, others (children’s hospitals) absolutely care

You do not need a decision. You need a score that doesn’t close any of the three.

---

MS3: The Crucial Test‑Drive Year

Now you actually see the jobs. This is where people screw up and just “go with what’s next on the schedule.” Don’t do that.

Clinical Year Decision Timeline

Period	Event
MS2 - Fall	Shadow IM, FM, Peds lightly
MS2 - Spring	Meet mentors, define priorities
MS3 - Early rotations	Observe fit in core IM and Peds
MS3 - Mid year	Elective in FM or outpatient
MS3 - Late year	Solidify top 1-2 choices
MS4 - Early	Sub-I in chosen field
MS4 - Mid	ERAS applications and interviews
MS4 - Late	Rank list and backup planning

Before MS3 Starts (Scheduling & Strategy)

At this point you should plan your rotation order strategically:

• Aim to have IM and Peds in the first 2/3 of MS3, not both stuck at the very end.
• Try to add at least one FM or outpatient primary care elective late MS3 or early MS4.
• If your school allows:
  • Frontload IM
  • Put Peds soon after
  • Slot FM or a primary care elective once you’ve seen both

This gives you real comparisons, not vague impressions.

IM Rotation (Usually 8–12 Weeks): What You Must Track

During IM you should watch for three things:

1. Cognitive style:

   • Do you like complex, multi‑organ disease in older adults?
   • Do you enjoy long differential lists and guideline games (e.g., heart failure meds, anticoagulation)?
   • Do family meetings and disposition planning feel meaningful or just exhausting?

2. Inpatient vs outpatient preference:

   • Most IM rotations skew inpatient. Ask to spend time in clinic.
   • See if day after day of wards feels:
     • Energizing
     • Neutral
     • Soul‑sucking

3. Your reaction to future path options:

   • Attendings will talk about cards, GI, heme/onc, pulm/crit, etc.
   • Ask yourself: “Do I like the idea of specializing later?”
   • If the answer is yes, IM is your only pipeline of these three.

End of IM rotation checklist:

• Can you picture doing 80–90% adult medicine forever?
• Did you like logic‑heavy, data‑dense rounds?
• Did you mind that continuity is limited during residency?

If you’re “meh” on all three, IM might still be a backup, but probably not your main.

Peds Rotation (Usually 4–8 Weeks): Filter Out Fantasy

Peds looks cute from the outside. The reality is different.

During Peds you should:

1. Separate “liking kids” from “liking pediatric medicine.”

   • Liking kids = enjoying high‑fives and stickers
   • Peds medicine = parents, chronic conditions, growth charts, vaccines, lots of social work

2. Watch your patience level.

   • Can you explain the same thing three times—to the child, the parents, and maybe grandparents?
   • Does the emotional weight of sick kids crush you or motivate you?

3. Notice clinic vs hospital preference.

   • Outpatient well‑child checks + sick visits
   • Inpatient (if you see NICU/PICU, pay attention to how that feels)

End of Peds rotation checklist:

• Did sick kids leave you drained for days or were you okay after debriefing?
• Did you like growth & development as a core theme?
• Could you imagine dealing with parents’ anxiety all day, every day?

If you loved the medicine but hated the emotional load—or vice versa—write that down clearly.

FM Exposure (Varies by School): Don’t Rely on Stereotypes

Some schools have a dedicated FM clerkship. Others bury FM inside “primary care” or electives. At this point you should seek explicit FM exposure if it’s not built in.

When you’re in an FM setting:

1. Track the breadth.

   • Adults, kids, OB (in some practices), procedures (skin, joint injections), chronic disease, urgent care.
   • Ask: “Do I like doing a bit of everything, or does that feel scattered?”

2. Notice continuity and community vibe.

   • FM is usually where you see 5‑10 year relationships.
   • Look at the waiting room: this is your future panel.

3. Pay attention to scope limitations.

   • FM can do a lot, but often hands off complex stuff. Are you okay with being the coordinator, not the do‑everything expert?

End of FM exposure checklist:

• Did you enjoy “all ages, all problems” or did it feel chaotic?
• Did the idea of rural or underserved practice appeal to you?
• How did you feel about being the first stop for everything?

---

Late MS3: Narrow to Top Two and Stress‑Test

By the time you finish core rotations (or near the end), you should narrow to 2 of the 3: IM, FM, Peds.

If you “like all three,” that’s not a compliment; it means you haven’t asked hard enough questions yet.

Month‑by‑Month: End of MS3

Mar–Apr (or equivalent late‑year block): Sorting & Conversations

At this point you should:

1. Rank your rotations emotionally.
   Forget prestige. Which days:

   • Went by fastest
   • Left you tired but satisfied
   • Made you talk about interesting cases after you got home

2. Meet three kinds of mentors:

   • One categorical IM resident or attending
   • One FM resident or attending (ideally community based)
   • One general pediatrician (hospital or clinic)

   Ask each:

   • “What would push a student away from this specialty?”
   • “What do your unhappy colleagues usually complain about?”
   • “If I’m debating between IM vs FM vs Peds, what’s the deciding factor you usually see?”

3. Get honest feedback on your fit.

   • Share your self‑assessment: “Here’s what I liked on IM vs FM vs Peds.”
   • Ask: “Based on that, what would you suspect I’ll like five years from now?”

You are not asking them to choose for you. You’re asking for pattern recognition from someone 5–20 years ahead.

May–Jun: Plan MS4 to Answer Remaining Questions

Once you’ve got a tentative top two (say, IM vs Peds, or FM vs IM):

• Schedule:
  • One Sub‑I/Audition in the front‑runner (IM or Peds or FM) early MS4
  • One additional elective in the runner‑up field, if you’re genuinely torn
• If you’re leaning FM but your school has weak FM exposure:
  • Arrange an away or local community FM elective early MS4
• If you’re IM‑leaning and thinking fellowship:
  • Try to spend time on that subspecialty service (cards, pulm, etc.) during late MS3 or early MS4

---

MS4: Lock It In and Optimize Your Application

By MS4 start, you should have a primary specialty picked or be down to a very tight IM vs FM or IM vs Peds decision. Dragging a three‑way tie into July is asking for stress.

Key Exposure Hours to Aim For by Early MS4

Category	Value
Internal Med	400
Family Med	200
Pediatrics	250

Early MS4 (Jul–Sep): Sub‑Is and Final Decision

At this point you should:

1. Do a Sub‑I in your likely choice.

   • IM: inpatient ward Sub‑I
   • FM: inpatient FM service or heavy‑responsibility FM elective
   • Peds: inpatient peds or NICU/PICU‑adjacent Sub‑I

   During this month, track:

   • How you feel at 5 pm post‑call
   • How you interact with the intern/residents (these are your future peers)
   • Whether the cases feel “right” to you—challenging but satisfying, not soul‑draining

2. Use week 2 of your Sub‑I to make the call.
   Do not wait until ERAS opens to decide:

   • If you’re still torn IM vs FM:
     • Ask: “Do I want mostly adult internal medicine with later subspecialty options (IM), or do I want all‑ages continuity with more outpatient and community focus (FM)?”
   • If you’re torn IM vs Peds:
     • Ask: “Do I want adult chronic disease complexity, or do I want my cognitive energy going to growth/development and parents?”
   • If you’re torn FM vs Peds:
     • Ask: “Am I willing to give up caring for adults if I choose Peds? Or do I actually love adult chronic disease and just like kids on the side?”

3. Decide by the time ERAS opens. Could you dual apply (e.g., IM + FM, or Peds + FM)? Yes. Many do. Sometimes it’s smart. But your primary identity should be clear in your own head, even if you’re hedging.

Mid MS4 (Sep–Dec): Applications & Interviews

By now your job is execution, but you should still be checking for alignment.

Application Framing (How You Sell the Choice)

When you write your personal statement and talk in interviews:

• IM: Emphasize enjoyment of complexity, multi‑morbid patients, and interest in potential fellowship or becoming a “medical home” for complex adults.
• FM: Emphasize continuity, whole‑person/family care, community focus, and comfort with broad, cradle‑to‑grave medicine.
• Peds: Emphasize advocacy for children, development, working with families, and comfort with emotionally loaded situations.

If you’re dual‑applying:

• Make separate narratives. Programs can smell copy‑paste a mile away.

On Interview Days

During interviews you should silently track:

• Which residents look burned out vs content
• What percentage of graduates go to fellowship (IM, Peds) vs full‑scope practice (FM)
• How they talk about clinic volume and documentation burden

You’re not just ranking prestige. You’re ranking where you’ll learn the version of IM, FM, or Peds you actually want to practice.

---

Quick Comparison Snapshot: IM vs FM vs Peds

Factor	Internal Medicine (IM)	Family Medicine (FM)	Pediatrics (Peds)
Main Patient Group	Adults only	All ages	Children only
Typical Setting	More inpatient	More outpatient	Mixed, child‑focused
Fellowship Options	Many subspecialties	Limited, niche	Several subspecialties
Continuity Emphasis	Moderate	High	High (kids, families)
Breadth vs Depth	Deep adult medicine	Very broad	Deep child‑focused

---

Red Flags & Reality Checks by Stage

During MS2

• You’re “set” on Peds but have never spent a full day in a pediatric clinic.
• You dismiss FM because “it’s just simple clinic stuff.” (That’s wrong; FM can be extremely complex, just in a different way.)
• You ignore IM because “hospital medicine seems depressing,” without seeing a modern hospitalist team.

During MS3

• You love your IM team and decide “IM forever” even though what you actually liked was your resident’s personality.
• You choose Peds because you felt emotionally obligated after seeing sick kids, not because you liked the medicine.
• You rule out FM without a full‑scope exposure (including procedures, OB where applicable, and community work).

During Early MS4

• You still “haven’t decided” and are hoping some magical sign appears during your Sub‑I.
• You’re dual‑applying but giving exactly the same story to IM and FM programs.
• You’re picking purely based on perceived lifestyle without understanding that clinic‑heavy FM and Peds can be just as intense as IM, in different ways.

---

FAQs

1. Is it smart or dumb to dual‑apply (e.g., IM + FM or FM + Peds)?

It depends why you’re doing it. Dual‑applying because of geography or competitiveness can be very rational. Dual‑applying because you refuse to make a decision is less defensible. If you dual‑apply:

• Have a clear internal preference (even if you never say it out loud).
• Tailor your personal statements, letters, and talking points separately for each specialty.
• Be honest with yourself about which match result would actually make you happy.

2. What if my school barely offers any Family Medicine exposure?

Then you have homework. In late MS3 or early MS4:

• Arrange an FM elective at a community site or FM residency clinic.
• Spend at least 2–4 weeks seeing full‑spectrum FM, not just a half‑day shadow.
• Talk to FM residents specifically about scope, lifestyle, and how much inpatient/OB they actually do post‑residency.

Without that, you are essentially guessing about FM. That’s not acceptable if you’re seriously considering it.

3. I liked both IM and Peds. How do Med‑Peds and combined paths fit into this timeline?

Med‑Peds is not a loophole for indecision. It’s for people who genuinely want both adult and pediatric complex medicine and are okay with a more intense training path. Use the same timeline:

• By late MS3, if you still strongly like both IM and Peds and can clearly articulate why, start meeting Med‑Peds faculty.
• Do at least one IM Sub‑I and one Peds‑heavy elective or acting‑internship.
• Apply to Med‑Peds only if you can explain to yourself—and programs—why you want dual training instead of picking one.

---

Open your rotation schedule and your calendar right now. Block one hour this week to:

1. List IM, FM, and Peds across the top of a page,
2. Plug in your completed experiences under each, and
3. Decide which one you need to see next to move from “I’m not sure” to “I’m testing a real hypothesis.”