Unfocused CV? System to Restructure Experiences for a Clear Narrative

It is late January. You just uploaded your CV into ERAS to “get ahead.” You scroll through it and feel that familiar sinking feeling: it is long, cluttered, and somehow says nothing clear about who you are as a physician. Shadowing. Random volunteering. Research that goes nowhere. A couple of leadership things. It looks like 200 other applications you have seen.

Here is the problem: residency programs are not reading your CV looking for “everything you have ever done.” They are scanning for one thing:

A believable, coherent story about what kind of resident you will be.

If your CV is unfocused, it is not because you lack experiences. It is because the experiences are not organized around a narrative.

I am going to give you a system. Not vibes. Not “be authentic” nonsense. A concrete, repeatable process to:

1. Strip your CV down to the essentials
2. Identify the narrative that fits your real record
3. Rebuild the experience section so every line pushes that story

You can do this in a weekend if you are ruthless.

---

Step 1: Stop Thinking “List” and Start Thinking “Story”

Most applicants treat the CV as a chronological dump:

• Whatever they did
• In the order they did it
• With inflated verbs

That is exactly how you end up with an unfocused document.

Programs are skimming and doing pattern recognition:

• Is this person research-heavy?
• Are they a teacher/educator?
• Systems/improvement oriented?
• Community health / advocacy?
• Leadership / administration?

They do not need one of these. They want to see a pattern that feels intentional.

So first mental shift:
Your CV is not a list of what you did. It is evidence supporting a claim about who you are as a junior physician.

The “Claim Sentence” Exercise

Before you touch a single bullet point, write one sentence:

“I am a __________ -focused future [specialty] physician who brings __________ and __________ to a residency program.”

Examples:

• “I am a systems- and QI-focused future IM physician who brings data-driven problem solving and team leadership to a residency program.”
• “I am a community-oriented future pediatrician who brings long-term patient relationships and bilingual communication skills to a residency program.”
• “I am a research-driven future neurologist who brings hypothesis-driven thinking and experience moving projects to publication to a residency program.”

If you cannot write that sentence convincingly for yourself, you are not ready to edit your CV.

You are going to use this sentence as a filter for every experience:

• Does this support or weaken that claim?
• Or is it just “stuff I did”?

Anything that does not help the claim either:

• Gets cut, or
• Gets demoted (shorter, fewer bullets, moved down)

---

Step 2: Audit What You Have (Brutally)

Print your current CV or dump your experiences into a doc. One line per experience. No bullets yet. Just:

• Title / Role
• Organization
• Dates
• 1-sentence description (even rough is fine)

Now you are going to categorize them.

The 5 Buckets System

Take a highlighter and sort every experience into one primary bucket:

1. Clinical / Patient-Facing

   • Free clinics
   • Student-run clinics
   • Longitudinal preceptorships
   • Medical mission trips (if legit, not tourism)

2. Research / Scholarly Work

   • Bench, clinical, QI, educational research
   • Posters, abstracts, publications

3. Teaching / Education

   • TA roles
   • Peer tutoring
   • Curriculum development
   • OSCE coaching

4. Leadership / Administration

   • Committee roles
   • Student government
   • Organization president
   • Project lead roles

5. Service / Community / “Other”

   • Non-clinical volunteering
   • Jobs
   • Athletics, arts, hobbies (selectively)

Do not overthink it. Just put each thing where it mostly belongs.

Now, count. Where are your clusters?

Example Distribution of CV Experiences by Category

Category	Value
Clinical	6
Research	3
Teaching	2
Leadership	4
Service	5

This simple distribution tells you:

• What your record already emphasizes
• Where your emerging “angle” probably is (or should be)
• Where you are thin and should not pretend to be “that person”

If 60% of your experiences are research and you are trying to sell yourself as “deeply committed to primary care in underserved communities” with one free clinic stint… that will look fake.

Do not sell a story your CV cannot back up. You will get caught in interviews.

---

Step 3: Choose a Narrative Spine That Matches Reality

Based on your buckets, pick 1–2 “spines” your CV will revolve around. Not more.

Some common, legitimate spines:

• Research-forward applicant
• Community / primary care / continuity of care
• Systems / QI / operations
• Education / teaching
• Leadership / advocacy / policy

And these overlay on your specialty choice:

• Psych + community / severe mental illness advocacy
• Surgery + QI / efficiency, OR flow, safety
• EM + operations / systems / prehospital care
• OB/GYN + women’s health advocacy

Quick Reality Check

Ask yourself three questions:

1. Where have I spent the most actual time?
2. Where have I taken on increasing responsibility?
3. Where do I have at least one concrete result (publication, program created, measurable impact)?

Your spine has to pass all three. If it does not, pick a different one.

If your distribution is even and messy (2–3 things in every bucket), you can still build a narrative, but you will frame it as:

• “Broadly engaged but with a lean toward X”
• Then spotlight X with your strongest experiences

---

Step 4: Rank, Cut, and Consolidate Experiences

Now you are going to ruthlessly reorganize.

A. Rank within each bucket

Within each category, assign a rank:

• A-tier: Strongest, deepest, most impactful
• B-tier: Decent, but not central to your story
• C-tier: Filler, minor, or redundant

A-tier typically has:

• Longer duration (≥ 6–12 months)
• Leadership or ownership
• Clear outcomes (posters, curriculum written, clinic expanded)

C-tier is:

• 1-day events
• Purely observational
• “Member” of 5 clubs, did nothing specific

B. Decide what actually belongs on the CV

Hard rule: More is not better. Clear is better.

You do not need:

• 5 separate “premed volunteer” positions from college
• Every single poster presentation separately if they are the same project
• 8 committees where you were just a name on an email list

You should:

• Combine similar low-yield roles
• Drop anything that adds no new information about who you are now

Example consolidation:

• Instead of:

  • Volunteer, Hospital X front desk
  • Volunteer, Hospital X patient transport
  • Volunteer, Hospital X book cart

• Use:

  • Volunteer, Hospital X – Patient Support Roles (3 positions combined under one heading with one or two smart bullets)

C. Align the order with your narrative spine

Within each major ERAS section (work, research, volunteer), order your experiences like this:

1. A-tier experiences that support your spine
2. Other A-tier
3. B-tier that still add dimension
4. Optional: 1–2 C-tier if they cover a unique part of you (e.g., varsity athletics)

Stop thinking “chronological purity”. The first thing they read should scream your narrative.

---

Step 5: Rewrite Bullets to Prove Your Story (Not List Tasks)

Clumsy CV bullets are all the same:

• “Responsible for…”
• “Worked with…”
• “Helped to…”

Programs skim those and forget you two seconds later.

You are going to write bullets that:

• Show action
• Show scale or scope
• Show impact
• Echo your narrative spine

The 3-Part Bullet Formula

Every bullet should answer:

1. What did you do? (action)
2. What was the scale/context?
3. What changed because you did it? (impact)

Template:

Action verb + what you owned + how big / who with + with what measurable or concrete result.

Bad vs Better

Random volunteering:

• Bad: “Volunteered at student-run free clinic”
• Better (community/continuity spine):
  “Coordinated longitudinal follow-up for ~40 uninsured patients in student-run free clinic, improving 3-month follow-up rate from 45% to 68% through reminder calls and appointment tracking.”

Research:

• Bad: “Worked on neurology research project, collected data”
• Better (research spine):
  “Designed and executed retrospective chart review of 320 stroke admissions, identifying delayed thrombolysis patterns that informed protocol revision and abstract accepted at AAN annual meeting.”

Teaching:

• Bad: “Served as anatomy TA for first-year students”
• Better (education spine):
  “Led weekly anatomy review sessions for 25 MS1s, incorporating low-fidelity simulations; session attendance correlated with 12% higher mean exam scores versus non-attenders.”

Notice the pattern: verbs, numbers, outcomes.

Mirror Your Narrative Language

Go back to your “claim sentence.” Pull key words and concepts and echo them (lightly) in your bullets.

If your claim is “systems- and QI-focused,” bullets should actually mention:

• Workflow redesign
• Protocols
• Efficiency metrics
• Error reduction
• Handoffs
• Throughput

Do not just say “quality improvement” with no evidence. Show it.

---

Step 6: Build a Coherent Structure That Feels Intentional

Now we rebuild the CV in a way that tells the story at a glance.

A. Decide what “type” of applicant you are showing

You can think in “profiles.” Here is an example table to make this concrete.

Profile Type	Most Emphasized Buckets	Typical Spine Keywords
Research-Heavy IM	Research, Clinical, Leadership	Outcomes, publications, data
Community-Focused FM	Clinical, Service, Teaching	Continuity, underserved, longitudinal
QI/Systems EM	Clinical, Leadership, Research	Workflow, protocol, throughput
Educator-Peds	Teaching, Clinical, Leadership	Curriculum, mentorship, development
Advocacy-Psych	Service, Leadership, Clinical	Policy, stigma, outreach

You are not picking a costume. You are picking the clearest reflection of what you have already done.

B. Within each ERAS section, impose a clear internal logic

For each major category (Work, Volunteer, Research, Teaching if separate), structure like this:

1. Lead with the flagship experience that best expresses your spine
2. Cluster related experiences together
3. Move generic / filler to the bottom with minimal description

Example: Community-Focused FM Applicant – Volunteer Experiences

1. Street Medicine Outreach Team – Volunteer Coordinator

   • 3 strong bullets (leadership, continuity, outcomes)

2. Student-Run Free Clinic – Care Coordinator

   • 2–3 bullets (follow-up systems, underserved care)

3. Mobile Vaccination Clinics – Volunteer

   • 1–2 bullets (scale, community reach)

4. Hospital Gift Shop Volunteer – Hospital X

   • 1 short bullet or no bullet; just to show early sustained service

They can skim and see: “Oh, this person lives in the community/continuity space.”

C. Be consistent with style and tense

Sloppy CVs wobble:

• Mixed tenses
• Random capitalization
• Inconsistent bullet formats

You are not going to lose a spot over a comma, but you will look more serious if:

• Past experiences: past tense
• Ongoing roles: present tense
• Same verb style and structure across entries

---

Step 7: Tie CV, Personal Statement, and LoRs into One Narrative

An unfocused CV is often part of a deeper problem: every document tells a slightly different story.

You fix this by making your narrative spine the backbone of everything:

• Personal statement:

  • 1–2 anchor experiences from your CV expanded into narrative
  • Explicit connection of those experiences to residency and future goals
  • Echo of key themes and even specific projects

• Letters of recommendation:

  • Choose letter writers who have seen you in the roles that match your spine
  • Tell them directly: “I am emphasizing my X-focused work in Y; would you be comfortable commenting on that?”

• Interview answers:

  • “Tell me about yourself” → hits the same 2–3 spine themes and experiences

If your CV screams “educator,” your PS is about your love for procedural specialties, and your letters focus on research grind… you look scattered.

---

Step 8: Common CV Mistakes That Kill Your Narrative (And How to Fix Them)

Let me be blunt about the usual offenders.

Mistake 1: Overweighting Premed Stuff

If you are at residency application time and half your CV is college:

• You look underdeveloped as a medical trainee
• It smells like you did not engage much in med school

Fix:

• Keep only premed experiences that are:
  • Truly major (D1 athlete, Fulbright, major leadership)
  • Directly reinforcing your current spine

Everything else: compress or delete.

Mistake 2: “Leadership” with No Actual Authority

“Member, leadership committee” means nothing if you did nothing.

Fix:

• If you keep a role, your bullets must show:
  • Budgets
  • People you supervised
  • Decisions you owned
  • Programs you initiated or significantly changed

If you cannot write that, demote that role and promote something else.

Mistake 3: Listing Every Research Poster Separately

You are not impressing anyone by spreading one project across six line items.

Fix:

• Group:
  “Stroke Outcomes Project – Research Assistant / Co-Author”
  Then in bullets include:
  • “Co-author on 2 posters (AAN 2023, ISC 2024) and 1 manuscript under review.”

Mistake 4: Inflated Language That Does Not Match Your Level

You were not “Directing clinical operations” as an MS2 in a free clinic. Reviewers know this.

Fix:

• Use strong but honest verbs:
  • Coordinated
  • Implemented
  • Co-developed
  • Led student team
  • Streamlined workflow

They respect grounded, precise language more than obviously exaggerated titles.

Mistake 5: CV That Does Not Match What You Say in Interviews

This is where people get in trouble. They talk like they ran the hospital; their CV shows 3 hours/week volunteering.

Fix:

• Before interview season, read your own CV line by line.
• For each experience ask: “Could I talk about this for 3–5 minutes with specifics?”
• If not, trim or rephrase now.

---

Step 9: A Practical 2-Day Restructure Plan

If you are pressed for time, here is a simple Gantt-style overview to get it done in a weekend.

Two-Day CV Restructure Plan

Task	Details
dateFormat HH	mm
axisFormat %H	%M
Day 1: Audit & Categorize	a1, 09:00, 3h
Day 1: Choose Narrative Spine	a2, 12:00, 1h
Day 1: Rank/Cut/Consolidate	a3, 13:00, 3h
Day 2: Rewrite A-tier Bullets	b1, 09:00, 3h
Day 2: Reorder Sections	b2, 12:00, 1h
Day 2: Cross-check with PS/LoRs	b3, 13:00, 2h

Day 1 is all about thinking and cutting.
Day 2 is rewriting and polishing.

Do not jump straight into editing bullets. You will just produce a more polished version of the same unfocused CV.

---

Step 10: Quick Example – From Messy to Narrative

Let me walk you through a stripped-down example.

Raw Experiences (Unstructured)

• Volunteer, Hospital gift shop (college)
• Shadowing, Orthopedic surgery
• Research assistant, cardiology lab (3 months)
• Student-run free clinic volunteer
• QI project on discharge summaries
• Peer tutor for MS1s (renal, cardio)
• Treasurer, Internal Medicine Interest Group
• Volunteer, homeless shelter meals
• Short-term global health trip, 1 week
• EM sub-I shift leader (informal peer role)

This is chaos as listed. No clear story.

Audit & Category Tally

• Clinical: free clinic, EM sub-I role, global health trip
• Research: cardiology lab, QI project
• Teaching: peer tutor
• Leadership: treasurer, EM sub-I informal leadership
• Service: gift shop, homeless shelter

Look closer:

• QI project + EM sub-I responsibility + discharge summaries = systems/operations angle
• Free clinic + homeless shelter = some community/continuity
• Research is short and weak (3 months, maybe no outputs)

So I would not sell this person as “research-focused.” That would be a lie.

Pick Spine

Spine: Systems- and communication-focused EM/IM applicant with strong interest in care transitions and underserved care.

Now re-rank:

• A-tier: QI discharge project, student-run free clinic, EM sub-I leadership, homeless shelter
• B-tier: peer tutor, IM interest group treasurer
• C-tier: cardiology research (short), gift shop, global trip (short duration)

Group, cut, and write bullets that prove that spine:

• QI project → metrics about discharge errors, handoff clarity
• Free clinic → continuity, follow-up systems
• EM sub-I → managing flow, communication with nurses, rapid sign-outs
• Homeless shelter → insight into barriers to follow-up at discharge

By the time a PD reads 30% of that CV, they already have the story:
“This person cares about transitions of care, high-functioning systems, and underserved patients.”

That is what you want.

---

Strategic Use of Visual Planning Tools (Optional)

If you are a visual planner, a quick chart of how much time you actually spent in each area can keep you honest.

Hours Spent by Experience Category (Example Applicant)

Category	Value
Clinical	450
Research	120
Teaching	80
Leadership	150
Service	200

If your doughnut looks 60% research and you are insisting on a “community-focused” story with 40 total hours in a free clinic, you know you are off.

And if you like mindmaps, sketching your narrative spine with branches for experiences can help:

This is overkill for some people, but if you are overwhelmed, a visual scaffold can make it concrete.

---

FAQ (Exactly 4 Questions)

1. Should I hide “weak” or short-term experiences completely?
Not necessarily. Keep them if they either:

• Fill a real gap (e.g., your only formal teaching experience), or
• Add a unique dimension (significant job, athletics, art, language)
  But demote them: fewer bullets, lower position in the section, combined with similar roles. What you must not do is feature them as if they prove your core narrative.

2. How many total experiences is “too many” on a residency CV?
If your experiences are well-structured, 12–18 total across work, research, and volunteer is usually plenty. When people creep above 25, the CV almost always gets noisy and repetitive. Focus on depth: multi-year, progressive-responsibility roles beat five one-off activities in the same domain.

3. What if my experiences do not match the specialty I am applying to?
You do not need a “pure” specialty-matched CV, especially for less competitive fields. You do need an argument. Example: a student with lots of cardiology and some surgery exposure applying to anesthesiology can frame a spine around perioperative care, hemodynamics, and team-based acute care. Pull out the threads that make sense for the new field and emphasize those. Do not panic if you did not live in that department for two years.

4. Can I use different narratives for different specialties I apply to?
You can slightly adjust emphasis, but you cannot credibly maintain totally different personas in the same cycle. Programs will see through it. If you are applying to both IM and EM, for example, you might use one core spine (“acute care, systems, communication under pressure”) and lean slightly more inpatient/QI in IM applications and more resuscitation/flow in EM applications. Same core story, different angles—do not try to be a different person.

---

Key Takeaways

1. Your CV must support a single, believable narrative spine, not act as a dumping ground.
2. Choose that spine based on where you have actually invested time, responsibility, and produced outcomes.
3. Rewrite and reorder every experience so that, when skimmed, your CV clearly answers: “What kind of resident will this person be, and why should we believe that?”